← StudyX Devlog

Cambridge English Writing Assessment: Four Subscales and Bands 0 to 5

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperAlphaGeorgeHow-To
Cambridge English Writing Assessment: Four Subscales and Bands 0 to 5

In Cambridge English Qualifications, a Writing answer is marked on four subscales: Content, Communicative Achievement, Organisation and Language. The B2 First handbook for teachers puts it in one line: “Responses are marked on each subscale from 0 to 5.” According to the B2 First for Schools guide for teachers on assessing writing, each task is worth a maximum of 20 marks.

The scales were developed with reference to the CEFR and have the same shape from B1 Preliminary to C2 Proficiency. The same band number does not mean the same thing in every exam, though, and A2 Key uses only three subscales. This post lays the scales from each exam’s handbook side by side to show how they work. How to build a B2 First essay is in B2 First (FCE) Writing: How to Structure the Essay.

What the four subscales look at

The handbook describes the subscales like this:

Subscale What it looks at
Content How well the candidate has fulfilled the task: whether they did what they were asked to do
Communicative Achievement How appropriate the writing is for the task, and whether the register is appropriate
Organisation How the piece is put together: whether it is logical and ordered
Language Vocabulary and grammar, both range and accuracy

The B2 First for Schools guide points out that three of the four subscales are not about language accuracy.

Bands 0 to 5

Only bands 5, 3 and 1 have their own descriptors. Band 4 is “Performance shares features of Bands 3 and 5.”, band 2 is “Performance shares features of Bands 1 and 3.” and band 0 is “Performance below Band 1.” The guide explains that the descriptors for bands 1, 3 and 5 show what a candidate is expected to demonstrate at lower, average and higher levels of ability.

“The subscale Content is common to all levels”:

Band Content descriptor
5 All content is relevant to the task. Target reader is fully informed.
3 Minor irrelevances and/or omissions may be present. Target reader is on the whole informed.
1 Irrelevances and misinterpretation of task may be present. Target reader is minimally informed.
0 Content is totally irrelevant. Target reader is not informed.

The guide draws attention to how the wording steps down from band to band: minor irrelevances, irrelevances, totally irrelevant. It says this should make it easier to compare the bands when deciding which mark to give.

The other three subscales change with the level

Communicative Achievement, Organisation and Language have separate descriptors for each CEFR level. The handbook prints the whole table from A2 to C2, and each exam takes three rows from it:

Exam Band 5 Band 3 Band 1
B1 Preliminary B2 descriptors B1 descriptors A2 descriptors
B2 First C1 descriptors B2 descriptors B1 descriptors
C1 Advanced C2 descriptors C1 descriptors B2 descriptors
C2 Proficiency The row above C2 C2 descriptors C1 descriptors

The exam’s own level sits at band 3, the level above at band 5 and the level below at band 1. The marking scales in the B1 Preliminary handbook, the C1 Advanced handbook and the C2 Proficiency handbook follow the same pattern. The B2 First for Schools guide says that band 3 or above generally indicates an ability of at least B2, and that bands 1 and 2 mean the learner is “still performing at B1 level”.

The Organisation descriptors show the steps clearly:

  • A2: Text is connected using basic, high-frequency linking words.
  • B1: Text is connected and coherent, using basic linking words and a limited number of cohesive devices.
  • B2: Text is generally well organised and coherent, using a variety of linking words and cohesive devices.
  • C1: Text is well organised and coherent, using a variety of cohesive devices and organisational patterns to generally good effect.
  • C2: Text is a well-organised, coherent whole, using a variety of cohesive devices and organisational patterns with flexibility.

So a band 5 for Organisation in B2 First means writing that matches the C1 row, not the B2 row. The same goes for Language: the B2 row reads “Uses a range of everyday vocabulary appropriately, with occasional inappropriate use of less common lexis.”, while the C1 row reads “Uses a range of vocabulary, including less common lexis, appropriately.”

What the words in the descriptors mean

The B2 First handbook has a glossary of the terms in the mark scheme. These are the ones that come up most when reading the bands:

  • Generally: “not in every way or instance”. Generally appropriately is a step below appropriately.
  • Conventions of the communicative task: “genre, format, register and function”. The example given is that a personal email should not be written as a formal report.
  • Straightforward and complex ideas: straightforward ideas relate to relatively limited, usually concrete subject matter; complex ideas are more abstract or cover a wider subject area.
  • Linking words, cohesive devices and organisational patterns: linking words are explicit links such as and, but, because and first of all. Cohesive devices include moreover and as a result, and also reference pronouns, substitution, ellipsis and repetition. Organisational patterns are less explicit, such as arranging sentences in climactic order or using a rhetorical question to set up a new paragraph.
  • Less common lexis: words that appear less often in the relevant domain and often help to express ideas more succinctly and precisely.
  • Errors and slips: errors are systematic mistakes; slips are non-systematic mistakes on something the candidate has learned.
  • Impede communication: getting in the way of meaning. “Meaning can still be determined” indicates that some effort is required from the reader.

Length and variety of English

The handbook says length and variety of English are taken into account during marking:

  • Each task has a guideline on length. Answers that are too short may lack range and leave out required information; answers that are too long may contain irrelevant content. Either can affect the marks on the relevant subscales.
  • Candidates are expected to use one variety of English consistently, for example not switching between British and American spelling of the same word.
  • Non-impeding errors in spelling, grammar or punctuation will not necessarily be penalised. Errors that interfere with communication are treated more severely.

The A2 Key scale

The marking scale in the A2 Key handbook for teachers has three columns, Content, Organisation and Language, with no Communicative Achievement column. In A2 Key, Writing is Parts 6 and 7 of the Reading and Writing paper: Part 6 is a message of 25 words or more, such as a note or email, and Part 7 is a short story of 35 words or more based on three pictures.

At band 5, the Organisation and Language descriptors are the B1 row of the general table, and at band 3 they are the A2 row. Band 1 is written for A2 Key alone. For Organisation it reads “Production unlikely to be connected, though punctuation and simple connectors (i.e. ‘and’) may on occasion be used.”, and for Language “Produces basic vocabulary of isolated words and phrases.” and “Produces few simple grammatical forms with only limited control.”

Sample answers and examiner comments

Each handbook includes real candidate answers with a mark and a comment for every subscale. In the B2 First handbook, for example, one essay gets Content 4 because all the content is relevant but the target reader is “on the whole informed”. The B2 First for Schools guide also explains each subscale and follows it with a real task, a response and the comments given.

How the Writing score feeds into the overall result is in What Is the Cambridge English Scale?, and how to read the results is in Cambridge English Results and Certificates.

About AlphaGeorge

AlphaGeorge, which I make for iPhone and iPad, is an app for Cambridge English exam preparation. The course has six levels from A1 to C2 and 66 units in all, and the A2 to C2 levels are aimed at KET through CPE. A Diagnostic Test of about five minutes decides which level you start at. How to begin is in Getting Started with AlphaGeorge, and the formats are described in AlphaGeorge’s 18 Exercise Formats. The app’s screens are in English, Japanese and Simplified Chinese, and outside the Japanese screens the explanations are in English.

AlphaGeorge is free to start, with ads and a limit of hearts. AlphaGeorge Premium, a monthly or yearly subscription, removes ads, makes hearts unlimited and lets you replay finished lessons.

Download on the App Store

AlphaGeorgeCambridge English exam prep