← StudyX Devlog

What Are Executive Functions? The Three Skills Behind Planning, Switching and Self-Control

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrainDojoHow-To
What Are Executive Functions? The Three Skills Behind Planning, Switching and Self-Control

In 2000, Miyake and colleagues published a study of 137 college students in Cognitive Psychology. They looked at three executive functions that researchers often name: shifting between mental sets, updating and monitoring information, and inhibiting responses that would otherwise come out on their own. The question was whether these three are really separate abilities.

“Executive function” turns up often in books on psychology and education. This post explains what the term covers, using that study and Adele Diamond’s 2013 review “Executive Functions” in the Annual Review of Psychology.

What executive functions are

Diamond describes executive functions, also called executive control or cognitive control, as “a family of top-down mental processes.” They are needed when you have to concentrate and pay attention: when going on automatic, or relying on instinct or intuition, would be ill-advised, insufficient or impossible.

According to the review’s abstract, executive functions let us play with ideas in our heads, take time to think before acting, meet new and unexpected challenges, resist temptations and stay focused.

The review also notes: “Using EFs is effortful; it is easier to continue doing what you have been doing than to change.”

The three core functions

Diamond writes that there is general agreement on three core executive functions, and cites Miyake’s study among the sources. The three are inhibition, working memory and cognitive flexibility.

Inhibition. Controlling your attention, behavior, thoughts or emotions so that you can override a strong inner pull or an outside lure. The review splits it in two. Self-control is control over your behavior and emotions: resisting temptations and not acting on impulse. Interference control lets you attend to what you choose and suppress attention to everything else.

Working memory. Holding information in mind and working with it. The review separates it from short-term memory, which is only holding information in mind. There is more on working memory itself in What Is Working Memory?

Cognitive flexibility. Changing your perspective or your approach to a problem, and adjusting to new demands, rules or priorities. The review says researchers usually study it with task-switching and set-shifting tasks, and that adults are slower on trials where the relevant dimension switches than on trials where it stays the same.

The three are not independent. Diamond writes that working memory and inhibitory control support one another, and that one is rarely, if ever, needed without the other. Cognitive flexibility builds on both, and it develops much later.

Planning sits on top of the three

Planning is not one of the three. In Diamond’s review, reasoning, problem solving and planning are higher-order executive functions built from the core ones.

Are the three really separate?

Back to Miyake’s study. The 137 students did simple tasks thought to rely mainly on one of the three functions, and also a set of complex tasks often used to study executive function: the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test, the Tower of Hanoi, random number generation, operation span and dual tasking.

According to the abstract, the three functions were moderately correlated with one another but clearly separable. They also related to the complex tasks in different ways. Card sorting was linked most strongly to shifting, the Tower of Hanoi to inhibition, random number generation to inhibition and updating, and operation span to updating. Dual-task performance was not related to any of the three.

The authors concluded that executive functions show both unity and diversity.

Where they show up in daily life

Diamond’s review gives everyday examples for each function.

For self-control, the examples are not eating sweets when you are trying to lose weight, not blurting out the first thing that comes to mind, not jumping to a conclusion before you have all the facts, and giving up an immediate pleasure for a greater reward later. The review also lists staying on task despite distractions and finishing a task despite the temptation to give up. For interference control, the example is a cocktail party, where you want to screen out every voice but one.

Working memory, the review says, is critical for making sense of anything that unfolds over time, such as spoken or written language, whether a sentence, a paragraph or something longer. Other examples are doing math in your head, reorganizing a to-do list in your mind, turning instructions into an action plan, fitting new information into your thinking or plans, and considering alternatives.

For cognitive flexibility, the examples are seeing something from another person’s point of view, finding a new way to attack a problem when the first one is not working, admitting you were wrong, and taking advantage of sudden, unexpected opportunities.

The cost of moving your attention from one task to another is covered in Can People Really Multitask?, and the task where you name an ink color while ignoring the word in What Is the Stroop Effect?

References

BrainDojo is a brain training app with 40+ trainings covering handwriting, reading aloud, arithmetic, memory and attention. A session can start at about ten seconds, and Today’s Training is picked for you each day. You answer by writing with your finger, reading aloud, or tapping. On iPad you can write with your finger or with Apple Pencil. The Brain Dojo Check runs once a day, gives one test each for Processing Speed, Inhibitory Control and Working Memory, and returns your result as a radar chart and a rank.

BrainDojo works without an internet connection.

Every training except the newest ones is free to play, and the free version shows ads. BrainDojo Plus removes the ads and lets you play the new trainings at any time. Your first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits