Exercise and Brain Training: How the Evidence for Each Differs

In 2019 the World Health Organization published Risk reduction of cognitive decline and dementia: WHO guidelines. Physical activity and cognitive training are assessed in it as two separate interventions, and they come out differently.
Physical activity “should be recommended to adults with normal cognition to reduce the risk of cognitive decline.” That is a strong recommendation, based on evidence of moderate quality. Cognitive training “may be offered to older adults with normal cognition and with mild cognitive impairment.” That is a conditional recommendation, based on evidence of very low to low quality.
This post looks at what the guidelines say about each, and at three studies that are often cited on either side: a year of walking in older adults, an online brain training experiment with more than 11,000 people, and the ACTIVE trial. It ends with cognicise, a Japanese program that does both at once.
What the WHO guidelines say
For physical activity, the guidelines report moderate quality evidence that it has a positive effect on cognition in adults with normal cognition. The effect size is larger for aerobic training than for resistance training, and the effect “seems to be mostly due to aerobic exercise.” The benefits are not consistent across all cognitive domains, and there is low to moderate quality evidence suggesting that physical activity does not affect the risk of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) or dementia. The overall summary is that physical activity has “a small but beneficial effect on cognition.” The guidelines say the strong recommendation for healthy adults, and the conditional one for adults with MCI, were based on the quality of the evidence.
For cognitive training, a meta-analysis in healthy older adults showed a moderate positive effect on overall cognitive functioning, with the quality of evidence rated low. In adults with MCI, low quality evidence showed a small positive effect on cognition. The guidelines note that the evidence for cognitive interventions comes mainly from studies with older adults.
Exercise: a year of walking and the hippocampus
The exercise study cited most often in this area is a randomized controlled trial by Erickson and colleagues, published in PNAS in 2011.
It enrolled 120 adults aged 55 to 80 without dementia, 60 in each group. The aerobic group walked three days a week. Sessions started at 10 minutes, went up by 5 minutes at a time, and stayed at 40 minutes from week 7. Intensity was 50 to 60% of heart rate reserve for the first seven weeks and 60 to 75% after that. The control group did stretching and toning: exercises with dumbbells or resistance bands, balance work and yoga.
After a year, hippocampal volume in the walking group had risen by 2.12% on the left and 1.97% on the right. In the stretching group it had fallen by 1.40% and 1.43%. In the abstract the authors describe the 2% increase as “effectively reversing age-related loss in volume by 1 to 2 y.” Larger hippocampal volume was associated with higher serum levels of BDNF, which the authors describe as a mediator of new neuron growth in the dentate gyrus.
The memory result needs a careful reading. Spatial memory improved in both groups, and the walking group did not improve more than the stretching group. Within the walking group, people whose hippocampus grew more also showed larger memory gains.
A single short bout of exercise and its effect on memory is covered in Does Light Exercise Help Memory?, and changes in the adult brain with use in Can Adult Brains Change With Use?.
Brain training: does it reach beyond the trained tasks?
The main question in brain training research is transfer: whether gains on the practised tasks carry over to tasks that were not practised.
In a study published in Nature in 2010, Owen and colleagues had 11,430 participants train online several times a week for six weeks, on tasks covering reasoning, memory, planning, visuospatial skills and attention. Performance improved on every task that was trained. No transfer was found to untrained tasks, “even when those tasks were cognitively closely related.”
The ACTIVE trial is a large randomized controlled trial in older adults in the United States. Its first report, in JAMA in 2002, covered 2,832 people aged 65 to 94 in six metropolitan areas. They were assigned to one of four groups: ten sessions of group training in verbal memory, in reasoning, or in speed of processing, or a no-contact control group. Eleven months later, 60% of the trained participants were offered four booster sessions.
Each kind of training improved the ability it targeted, and the gains lasted to two years. Right after training, 87% of the speed group, 74% of the reasoning group and 26% of the memory group showed reliable improvement. No effects on everyday functioning were found at two years. The authors note that everyday function declined very little in any group, so longer follow-up would probably be needed to see such effects. The later ten-year follow-up and other brain training research are covered in Does Brain Training Work?.
Cognicise: moving and thinking at the same time
Exercise and brain training can also be done together. Japan’s National Center for Geriatrics and Gerontology (NCGG) developed a program for this called cognicise, a word made from “cognition” and “exercise.”
According to the NCGG, cognicise is a general name for activities that combine exercise with cognitive tasks such as arithmetic or shiritori (a Japanese word-chain game), aimed at preventing dementia. Depending on the kind of movement, there are versions based on stepping, dancing, walking and cycling.
The NCGG gives a guide for each half. The exercise should use the whole body at moderate intensity, enough to raise the pulse and make you slightly out of breath. The cognitive task done at the same time should be hard enough that you occasionally get either the movement or the task itself wrong.
The stated aim is to support physical health through exercise while giving the brain more chances to be active, and so to delay the onset of dementia. Getting good at the tasks is not the aim. The NCGG explains that doing a task well means it puts less load on the brain, so once a task becomes familiar it should be changed, and thinking up new tasks is itself an important task. It also encourages doing cognicise together with others, laughing at mistakes and enjoying the trial and error.
What to keep in mind when comparing them
Each of these studies asked a different question. Erickson’s trial compared the hippocampal volume of older adults after a year of walking with that of people who did stretching. Owen’s study asked whether six weeks of practice transferred to untrained tasks. ACTIVE looked at trained abilities and everyday functioning in older adults. The WHO guidelines pool many studies to assess the risk of cognitive decline and dementia.
Judged by the strength of the WHO recommendations, exercise is the more strongly recommended of the two, and the reason the guidelines give is the quality of the evidence. In the brain training studies, improvement on the trained tasks themselves was found consistently, in Owen’s study and in ACTIVE alike.
References
- World Health Organization. Risk reduction of cognitive decline and dementia: WHO guidelines. Geneva: WHO; 2019.
- Erickson KI, Voss MW, Prakash RS, et al. Exercise training increases size of hippocampus and improves memory. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011;108(7):3017-3022.
- Owen AM, Hampshire A, Grahn JA, et al. Putting brain training to the test. Nature. 2010;465(7299):775-778.
- Ball K, Berch DB, Helmers KF, et al. Effects of cognitive training interventions with older adults: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 2002;288(18):2271-2281.
- National Center for Geriatrics and Gerontology. Cognicise, a dementia prevention exercise program (in Japanese).
BrainDojo is a brain training app with 40+ trainings covering handwriting, reading aloud, arithmetic, memory and attention. A session can start at about ten seconds, and Today’s Training is picked for you each day. The Brain Dojo Check runs once a day, gives one test each for Processing Speed, Inhibitory Control and Working Memory, and returns your result as a radar chart and a rank.
Every training except the newest ones is free to play, and the free version shows ads. BrainDojo Plus removes the ads and lets you play the new trainings at any time. Your first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →