How to Choose Educational Apps for Kids: Ads, Purchases and Data

Guideline 1.3 of Apple’s App Store Review Guidelines sets the rules for apps in the App Store’s Kids Category. These apps “must not include links out of the app, purchasing opportunities, or other distractions to kids unless reserved for a designated area behind a parental gate.” The same guideline says they should not include third-party analytics or third-party advertising, apart from limited cases.
The rules for children’s apps are built mostly around three things: ads, purchases and data. This guide goes through what a parent can check on each of them when choosing an educational app, using official pages from Apple, Google and the US Federal Trade Commission.
Ads
Two of Apple’s guidelines deal with ads.
- 1.3 (Kids Category): apps in this category should not include third-party analytics or third-party advertising. Third-party contextual advertising may be permitted in limited cases, provided the ad service has publicly documented practices and policies for Kids Category apps that include human review of ad creatives for age appropriateness.
- 5.1.4 (Kids): “Apps intended primarily for kids should not include third-party analytics or third-party advertising.”
Google Play’s Families Policies say that ads shown to children or users of unknown age must not involve interest-based advertising or remarketing. Interest-based ads are chosen from a person’s browsing behavior, and remarketing targets people based on their earlier use of an app or website.
Google also runs a Teacher Approved program. According to Google’s Teacher Approved page, teachers and specialists rate apps on design, appeal, enrichment, age appropriateness, appropriateness of ads, in-app purchases and cross-promotion, and look at how ads, in-app purchases and cross-promotion affect the overall quality of the experience for a child under 13. Apps that pass display the Teacher Approved badge and can appear on the Kids tab on Google Play.
On the App Store, the place to look is App Privacy on the product page. One of the purposes it can list for collected data is “Third-Party Advertising”, which Apple’s developer guidance defines as “displaying third-party ads in your app, or sharing data with entities who display third-party ads.” What happens when a child taps an ad is covered in When Kids Tap Ads by Mistake.
Purchases
Guideline 1.3 allows purchasing opportunities only behind a parental gate. Apple’s page on designing safe experiences for kids describes parental gates as adult-level tasks and gives their purpose:
Parental gates aim to prevent kids from engaging in certain activities without their parent’s knowledge
The examples it gives are buying Apple In-App Purchases without permission and following links to content outside the app, such as external websites, social networks or other apps. The same page suggests that apps for children who cannot read yet consider a voiceover prompt to tell them they need to involve a parent.
Google Play’s Families Policies list “not providing a distinction between the use of virtual game coins versus real-life money to make in-app purchases” among the things an app must not do.
The App Store product page shows what an app sells. Under In-App Purchases, each item is listed with its price. To stop a child buying things on an iPad, see How to Stop Kids Making In-App Purchases on an iPad.
Data
App Privacy on the App Store product page shows the types of data an app may collect, whether that data is linked to the user and whether it is used for tracking. The information is self-reported by the developer. How to read it is covered in How to Read App Store Privacy Labels.
Apple’s guideline 5.1.4 adds these rules for children’s data:
- Apps may ask for a birthdate and parental contact information only to comply with children’s privacy laws, and must still offer some useful functionality or entertainment value regardless of a person’s age.
- Kids Category apps, and apps that can collect, transmit or share personal information from a minor (such as name, address, email, location, photos, videos or drawings), must include a privacy policy.
- The parental gate required in the Kids Category is generally not the same as getting parental consent to collect personal data under privacy laws.
In the United States, the law behind that consent is the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. The FTC’s COPPA FAQ explains that operators covered by the rule must post a clear and comprehensive online privacy policy, give parents direct notice and obtain verifiable parental consent before collecting personal information from children under 13, with limited exceptions, and let parents review their child’s personal information and have it deleted. The rule’s definition of personal information includes a child’s name, home address, online contact information, a persistent identifier that can recognize a user over time and across services, and a photo, video or audio file that contains a child’s image or voice.
Google Play’s Families Policies require an app that collects personal and sensitive information from children, including through APIs and SDKs it uses, to disclose that collection.
The link to an app’s privacy policy is in the App Privacy section of its App Store product page.
About BrainDojo Kids
BrainDojo Kids is an iPhone and iPad app I make for ages 3 to 6, where children write on the screen with a finger or a pen to practice letters and numbers.
There are no ads and no account to create. Game and player records are saved on the device. On the App Store, App Privacy lists Purchases, Identifiers (Device ID) and Diagnostics (Other Diagnostic Data) as Data Not Linked to You.
What the app sells is Premium, monthly or yearly. When a child taps something that needs Premium, the app shows “Play with Premium” and “Please ask a grown-up to help.” The purchase screen sits behind a parent check: “Press and hold inside the circle with two fingers for 3 seconds.” The three games in Today’s Training and the four Recommended games change every day and are free, as is the family board game, and Premium opens all courses and games. The first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo Kids.
BrainDojo KidsFocus, one handwritten letter at a timeSee the app →