How to Make Fewer Careless Mistakes at Work

The UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE) defines a human error at work as āan action or decision which was not intendedā (Managing human failures). It then splits errors into kinds. Slips (pressing the wrong button, reading the wrong gauge) and lapses (forgetting a step in a procedure) happen during familiar tasks. Mistakes are when we do the wrong thing believing it to be right.
Most of what we call careless mistakes are slips and lapses. Picking the wrong recipient, forgetting the attachment, typing a number with one digit off. None of these happen because we donāt know how to do the job. They happen in the middle of work we know well.
In this post I look at when careless mistakes at work tend to happen and how to reduce them, from the angle of how we use our attention.
āJust be more carefulā often isnāt enough
HSE writes that slips and lapses ācannot be eliminated by training, but improved design can reduce their likelihoodā. Mistakes, on the other hand, are prevented by training based on good procedures.
After a mistake we tend to say, āIāll be more careful next time.ā But the more familiar a task, the more the mind runs it half on autopilot. Deciding to be more careful does not last long against that. One view is that careless mistakes are easier to reduce when we treat them not as a matter of willpower but as a matter of where attention breaks off.
Tell the kinds apart
First, work out which kind your mistake is.
- You knew what to do, but your hand or eye did something else. The wrong recipient, pasting the wrong text, mistyping a number. That is a slip.
- You forgot to do something. An attachment, updating a date, a reply. That is a lapse.
- You misunderstood how to do it. How a deadline is counted, the order of steps. That is a mistake.
For a mistake, the shortcut is to check the procedure again or ask someone. For slips and lapses, the kind of systems I describe below, ones that catch you when attention lapses, help more.
When careless mistakes are likely
Among the factors that make errors more likely, HSE lists the design of interfaces, distraction, time pressure, workload, noise and communication systems. At work, three situations are common examples.
A familiar task where you skip a check. Routine work is where checking steps drop out. You email the same person every week, pick the top suggestion in the address field, and it turns out to be someone else.
Switching between tasks. Answer a chat message in the middle of something and come back, and you are no longer sure where you were. I covered research on how interruptions and switching affect attention in Canāt Stay Focused? A 10-Minute Daily Practice for Adults.
Being tired or rushed. Late in the day or just before a deadline, skipping checks is tempting. Looking back at whether your mistakes cluster at certain times can reveal a pattern.
Pointing and calling
Japanese workplaces have a checking method called shisa kanko, or pointing and calling. You point at the thing you are checking and say it aloud, often with a short āyoshiā (OK). According to the Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfareās workplace safety site, an experiment by the Railway Technical Research Institute in 1994 found a button-pressing error rate of 2.38% when doing nothing, against 0.38% with both pointing and calling, about one sixth (Shisa kanko, in Japanese).
The idea works in office jobs too. Before sending an email, point at the recipientās name and read it quietly. After typing an amount, point back and forth between the figure on the source document and the one on screen. Where speaking aloud is awkward, just pointing still makes your eyes stop properly on the thing.
Reduce them with design
For lapses, and for slips caused by a skipped check, systems that donāt rely on attention are a good fit.
- Make a checklist. Write down the checks for a task you do every time, briefly. If it is too long you will stop reading it, so the places where you have actually slipped before are enough.
- Make mistakes harder. Add the recipient last, put dates in file names, keep templates for messages you send often. Leave less room for an error.
- Wait a little before sending. Donāt send an important email or document the moment you finish. Do something else, then read it again. Right after writing, we tend to read what we meant to write.
- Make time to finish one thing at a time. Turn notifications off while doing work that needs checking. The point is to cut the number of switches.
HSE also says investigations āshould seek to identify why individuals have failed rather than stopping at āoperator errorāā.
Donāt be too hard on yourself
When mistakes pile up, it is easy to decide you just have poor attention. But as above, most careless mistakes come from conditions everyone has: familiar tasks, switching, fatigue.
In my developer interview I said, āWorking adults have many situations, at work and elsewhere, where they canāt afford mistakes.ā Because there are so many such situations, one approach is to spend the effort on building one thing that makes the next mistake less likely rather than on blaming yourself for the last one.
Practicing attention with BrainDojo
BrainDojo is an iPhone and iPad app for keeping up a daily brain training habit with short mini games. Trainings are grouped into lanes such as Calculation Boost, Memory Boost, Attention Boost and Handwriting Training.
The Attention Boost lane includes trainings like these:
- Min or Max: decide quickly whether it is the minimum or the maximum, and touch.
- Arrow Flow: arrows glide across the screen, and you tap only when an arrow points the same way it is moving. It is practice in holding back the urge to tap.
- Dual Task: jump over holes while solving math problems.
- Triple Task: drive to dodge obstacles, solve math, and remember what you passed.
Try Dual Task or Triple Task and you feel clearly how one thing slips when attention is split two or three ways. I think of brain training as a habit of using the brain, like strength training for muscles. Fixing work procedures is the job of the systems in this post. The trainings can be a place to learn, in a few minutes and through your own hands, when your attention tends to break down. The Brain Dojo Check, once a day, measures processing speed, inhibitory control and short-term memory.
Every training except the newest ones is free to play, and so are Todayās Training, the Brain Dojo Check and a calendar where you stamp the days you trained. The free version shows ads. BrainDojo Plus removes them and opens the new trainings anytime.
Getting Started with BrainDojo walks through the first session, and Does Brain Training Work? covers the research on brain training.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app ā