← StudyX Devlog

When Kids Cry After Losing a Board Game: Living with a Sore Loser

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperStudyX MindsportsHow-To
When Kids Cry After Losing a Board Game: Living with a Sore Loser

In 2022 the journal Early Child Development and Care published a study that watched 14 kindergarten children play competitive games (abstract of the paper by Emen Parlatan and Dikici Sigirtmaç). When they won, the children showed their feelings in appropriate ways. When they lost, some turned aggressive. The same group also developed strategies for coping with a loss and for not losing again.

With 14 children in a qualitative study, there is no way to say how common this is. But the angry child and the child learning to cope were observed in the same study.

This post covers what has been studied about children who lose, the views on letting them win, how to separate feelings from behavior, and what a handicap changes.

Where children put the blame

For a 2024 doctoral thesis at the University of Waterloo, Nicole Gevaux had 143 children ages 4 to 9 play an online game, clicking targets faster than an opponent. The opponents were simulated and the results were set in advance.

Afterward, the children were asked why they thought they had won or lost.

  • After a win, they more often gave reasons about themselves, such as their own ability.
  • After a loss, they more often gave reasons outside themselves, such as the opponent or the situation.
  • Older children gave outside reasons more often than younger ones.

So in this experiment, blaming the opponent or the circumstances after a loss was not unusual.

Letting them win

An article from the parenting program Triple P lists four responses: letting the child win, refusing to play, making them sit out until calm, and playing only cooperative games. Each can sometimes build confidence, teach consequences or give a break from competition. Used too often without teaching sportsmanship, the article says, they can do more harm than good.

There is also the view that the goal is neither throwing every game nor winning every game, but making some of them close.

Feelings and behavior

The Triple P article treats feelings and behavior separately. Crying, sadness, frustration and even anger are fine. Name-calling, storming off and aggression are not. Instead of dismissing a feeling or rushing to fix it, it suggests accepting it.

It also describes what adults can show: saying “good game” and shaking hands afterward, or taking deep breaths when frustrated.

A guide for families from the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry is about sports, but the sentence carries over to a board: “Remember, success is not the same thing as winning, and failure is not the same thing as losing.” For disappointment after a loss, it recommends praising effort and progress in skills.

Changing the terms with a handicap

Mind sports have ways of changing the terms: piece handicaps in shogi, handicap stones in Go, and removing some of the stronger player’s pieces in chess. The adult can play properly and the child still has a chance. On one view, a win under a handicap is not a win someone handed over.

In games with dice or cards, the roll or the deal moves the result even when strengths differ. Backgammon, Daifugo and mahjong are of this kind.

How to set a handicap is in Two Players on One Device. Teaching order is in Teaching Shogi to Kids and Teaching Chess to Kids.

About Mindsports

Mindsports is an app with 12 mind sports, including chess, shogi, Go, mahjong and bridge, for iPhone, iPad and Android. The CPU runs from Lv.1 to Lv.50, one level up per win and one down per loss. Two-player games on one device offer handicaps such as shogi piece handicaps and Go handicap stones, and Review lets you go back through the moves after a game. The games and beginner lessons are free, with ads. A one-time “Unlock All” purchase opens all advanced lessons and removes the ads.

How to use the app is in Getting Started with StudyX Mindsports, and how the level moves is in How the CPU Level Works.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

StudyX MindsportsMind games for families