Zugzwang Explained: When Having to Move Is the Problem

In chess you must make a move when it is your turn. Article 1.2 of FIDE’s Laws of Chess, in force since 1 January 2023, says White makes the first move and then the players move alternately. There is no option to pass.
Usually having the move is an advantage, because you get to choose what to do. In the endgame, though, there are positions where every move makes things worse and you would rather pass. That is zugzwang.
What the word means
According to English Wikipedia’s Zugzwang, the word comes from German Zug (move) and Zwang (compulsion), and means being forced to make a move. The article describes zugzwang as a situation where a player is put at a disadvantage by the obligation to move, and says a player is “in zugzwang” when any legal move will worsen their position.
The same article sorts positions into three types:
- Neither player would be worse off having to move. Most positions are like this.
- One player would be worse off having to move. This is what is usually called zugzwang.
- Both players would be worse off having to move. This is called reciprocal or mutual zugzwang.
Zugzwang is not stalemate
Under Article 5.2.1 of the Laws, the game is drawn by stalemate when the player to move has no legal move and their king is not in check.
In zugzwang there are legal moves. You can move, you just do not want to. If there is no legal move at all, it is stalemate and the game is over. Stalemate Explained covers that side in more detail.
The two often sit right next to each other, as in the first position below.
The smallest example
Position 1: White king e6, pawn f7. Black king f8.
With Black to move, White wins. The black king can only go to g7: the white king covers e7, and the f7 pawn covers e8 and g8.
1… Kg7 2. Ke7
The white king now covers f8, and wherever the black king goes, 3. f8=Q follows. Ke7 is the only winning second move. Playing 2. f8=Q+ at once runs into Kxf8 and a draw.
With White to move, it is a draw. The pawn cannot move, so the king has to. 1. Kf6 leaves Black with no legal move, which is stalemate. Any other king move leaves the f7 pawn unprotected, and Black takes it with Kxf7.
Black to move loses, White to move only draws. Both sides suffer from having the move, so this is reciprocal zugzwang.
Whoever moves loses
Position 2: White king d5, pawn e4. Black king f4, pawn e5.
The pawns block each other and neither can advance. The white king attacks the e5 pawn and the black king attacks the e4 pawn, but each pawn is guarded by its own king, so neither can be taken yet.
Whoever has the move loses. Only the kings can move, and a king that moves stops guarding its pawn.
With White to move, 1. Kc5 Kxe4 is one example, and Black wins the pawn. All five of White’s moves lose.
With Black to move, 1… Kg4 2. Kxe5 is one example, and White wins the pawn. All five of Black’s moves lose too.
Wikipedia’s Zugzwang article calls this kind of reciprocal zugzwang, where the side to move loses outright, a trébuchet.
In both Position 1 and Position 2, nothing on the board changes; only the side to move decides the result. The positions in Opposition in Pawn Endgames showed the same thing: in king and pawn endings, whose turn it is can turn a win into a draw.
Waiting moves in mate puzzles
The Wikipedia article says zugzwang comes up fairly often in king and pawn endings and in basic checkmates such as king and rook against king. It also says that, unlike reciprocal zugzwang, in ordinary zugzwang the stronger side usually has a waiting move.
Position 3: White king e6, rook c4. Black king d8. White to move and mate in 2.
If it were Black’s move, the black king could only go to e8: the rook covers c7 and c8, and the white king covers d7 and e7. Then 2. Rc8# would be mate.
White to move has no mate at once. So the rook moves along the c-file and hands the move to Black.
- Rc2 Ke8
- Rc8#
Any of Rc1, Rc2, Rc3, Rc5 and Rc6 mates in 2. 1. Rc7 can simply be taken by the king, and 1. Rc8+ is a check but is also met by Kxc8.
The first rook move is neither a check nor a capture. White plays it only to pass the turn to Black. Black still has one legal move, so it is not stalemate.
The “waiting move” in How to Checkmate with King and Rook is the same idea. As in Position 3 of Checks, Captures, Threats, the answer to a mate puzzle can be a quiet move like this.
Sources
- FIDE, “FIDE Laws of Chess taking effect from 1 January 2023” (FIDE Handbook)
- English Wikipedia, “Zugzwang”
Practising with Chess365
Chess365 is a checkmate puzzle app with 1,000 puzzles each of mate in 2, 3, 4 and 5. You always play White, you can make any legal move, and Black replies automatically. If the line ends without mate, the app tells you the king got away and you start again from the beginning. If you stalemate Black, the app shows a separate message explaining that it is a draw.
A hint lights up the piece to move and its destination, and you play the move yourself. After solving, “Review moves” lets you step back and forward through the moves, so you can see which squares the black king had left.
All the puzzles are free, and a one-time “Remove Ads” purchase removes the ads. How to start with mate puzzles is in Chess checkmate puzzles for beginners, and how to use the app is in Getting Started with Chess365.
Chess365A chess mate puzzle every daySee the app →