B1 Preliminary (PET) Writing Part 2: Choosing Between the Article and the Story

The B1 Preliminary (PET) Writing paper lasts 45 minutes and has two parts. Part 1 is a reply to an email, and every candidate answers it. Part 2 is a choice: candidates write either an article or a story. The official exam format page describes Part 2 as “Write about 100 words, answering the question of their choosing.” Candidates choose one question from two, and it is worth a maximum of 20 marks. Part 1 is also about 100 words and 20 marks, so the Writing paper totals 40 marks.
The whole exam and an order of study are in How to Prepare for B1 Preliminary (PET). This post looks only at Part 2 and sets out how the two tasks differ, using the explanations and the sample answer comments in the B1 Preliminary handbook for teachers.
How Part 2 differs from Part 1
The handbook calls Part 1 a “Compulsory task” and Part 2 a “Choice of two tasks”. In Part 1, candidates get an email and four notes linked by lines to parts of it, and they must include all four content points in a reply of around 100 words. Part 2 has no set of four notes. What the task gives you depends on whether you pick the article or the story.
What the article task gives you
For the article, candidates read an announcement from a magazine or website. In the handbook’s words: “This gives the topic that they must write about. For example, there may be a couple of questions that they should respond to.”
The sample paper in the handbook follows this pattern: a notice on an English-language website asks two questions about films and invites readers to write an article.
The handbook’s comments on the two sample articles give both of them 5 for Content. In each case the target reader is fully informed about what sort of films the writer enjoys, where they like watching them, and why.
What the story task gives you
For the story, candidates are given the first sentence. The handbook says: “They must continue the story with clear links to the opening sentence.” Its glossary calls this the “Prompt sentence”, defined as “the complete sentence given as the opening line of a story in B1 Preliminary Writing Part 2.”
The handbook also tells candidates to pay close attention to any names or pronouns in the opening sentence and to keep to the same pattern. Its example is a story that begins in the third person: it should continue that way.
In the sample paper, the candidate’s English teacher has asked for a story, and the opening sentence names a character. Both sample stories receive 5 for Content, and the comments note that each story “follows on logically from the prompt sentence”.
The same four subscales for both tasks
Whichever task you choose, Part 2 is marked on the same four subscales as Part 1: Content, Communicative Achievement, Organisation and Language, each from 0 to 5. On the B1 Preliminary scale, band 5 for Content reads “All content is relevant to the task.” and “Target reader is fully informed”. The glossary defines the target reader as “the hypothetical reader set up in the task, e.g. a magazine’s readership, your English teacher”, and says the reader is informed “if content points and/or task requirements are addressed and appropriately developed.” The descriptors for each band, and how they shift between exams, are in Cambridge English Writing Assessment: Four Subscales and Bands 0 to 5.
The subscales are the same, but the “conventions of the communicative task” that Communicative Achievement looks at (genre, format, register and function) are not. These are the conventions the sample comments name:
| Task | Conventions named in the comments |
|---|---|
| Article | Describing personal experiences and expressing opinions; an engaging tone |
| Story | Narrative tenses, surprising elements, descriptive language, direct speech |
The comments also show Content and Communicative Achievement scoring differently on the same answer. One sample article gets 5 for Content and 2 for Communicative Achievement: the conventions of article writing are used generally appropriately, but to communicate simple ideas. One sample story gets the same pair of marks. Its comment says direct speech adds interest to the narrative, but the limited control of language affects the overall communicative achievement. Answering the task and writing in the way the genre expects are marked on separate subscales.
Choosing a task
The handbook’s advice is: “Candidates should choose the task which best suits them and their interests.” It adds that they should consider both the topic and the language demands, such as vocabulary, of the two questions before choosing.
Putting the handbook’s explanations and comments side by side:
| Article | Story | |
|---|---|---|
| What you are given | An announcement from a magazine or website | The first sentence of the story |
| What you write | About the topic in the announcement, responding to its questions | A continuation with clear links to the opening sentence, keeping its names and pronouns |
| Conventions in the comments | Personal experiences and opinions; an engaging tone | Narrative tenses, surprising elements, description, direct speech |
About 100 words
Part 2 asks for “around 100 words”, and the handbook calls the word length “a guide which learners should aim for.” Writing roughly the required number of words means candidates neither leave out important information nor make their message unclear with irrelevant material. The assessment section adds that answers which are too short may lack range and required information, while answers which are too long may contain irrelevant content and have a negative effect on the reader.
In the digital exam the words are counted on the screen. For the paper-based exam, the handbook suggests practising writing approximately the right amount so that candidates do not waste time counting words. Paper-based answers go in a separate booklet with lined pages. What matters most is clear handwriting: upper or lower case are both fine, and it does not matter whether the writing is joined up.
Preparing for Part 2
For Part 2, the handbook lists practice in planning answers before writing, writing timed answers within the recommended word length, and evaluating one’s own and others’ answers against the question. For each task it adds:
- Article: plan and write short article-like texts regularly, on subjects that interest the learner, and read articles in magazines and on websites to see how article-like texts are organised and what other language features they have.
- Story: plan and write short stories regularly, at home and in class, and read short stories, for example simplified readers in English, to see how stories start, develop and end.
The two articles and two stories mentioned here are printed in the handbook with marks for each subscale and the examiners’ comments.
About AlphaGeorge
AlphaGeorge, which I make for iPhone and iPad, is an app for Cambridge English exam preparation. The course has six levels from A1 to C2 and 66 units in all, and the A2 to C2 levels are aimed at KET through CPE. A Diagnostic Test of about five minutes decides which level you start at. How to begin is in Getting Started with AlphaGeorge, and the formats are described in AlphaGeorge’s 18 Exercise Formats. The app’s screens are in English, Japanese and Simplified Chinese, and outside the Japanese screens the explanations are in English.
AlphaGeorge is free to start, with ads and a limit of hearts. AlphaGeorge Premium, a monthly or yearly subscription, removes ads, makes hearts unlimited and lets you replay finished lessons.
AlphaGeorgeCambridge English exam prepSee the app →