Bent Four in the Corner: A Shape the Japanese Rules Call Dead

The Japanese Rules of Go (in Japanese) were set by the Nihon Ki-in and the Kansai Ki-in on 10 April 1989. After the articles and a commentary on each one, the rules give a set of worked examples for confirming life and death. Example 7-1 is titled 隅の曲り四目, bent four in the corner. Example 7-1 (in Japanese) gives its conclusion in one line:
黒三子は「活き石」であり、白七子は「死に石」である。
The three Black stones are living stones, and the seven White stones are dead stones.
Black has only three stones inside White’s corner, yet the rules call Black alive and White’s seven stones dead. This post redraws the example’s diagrams in text and follows its moves one by one. The ko shape and the rule against taking back at once are in The Ko Rule in Go, and another example from the same list, the mannen ko, is in Mannen Ko.
The shape
● is Black, ○ is White, and ・ is an empty point. The letters a and b are labels for this post. The top row is the edge of the board, and so is the left column, so the top left is the corner.
●●●a○●
b○○○○●
○○●●●●
●●●・・・
The outer Black stones are treated as alive here. Inside are:
- three Black stones in the corner, with liberties a and b;
- seven White stones around them, with the same two liberties, a and b.
Diagram 1: Black lets the corner stones be captured
Diagrams 1 and 2 of the example show why the seven White stones are dead.
Black 1 is at b. The corner Black group is now four stones with one liberty, a. The seven White stones also have only a.
White 2 is at a and captures the four Black stones. With White 2, White has eight stones, and the board looks like this:
cde○○●
b○○○○●
○○●●●●
●●●・・・
Four empty points are left inside White: c in the corner, d and e along the edge, and b below the corner. Three lie along the edge and one turns down from the corner. White’s eight stones have three liberties: b, d and e.
Diagram 2: a ko White cannot take back
Diagram 2 carries the note “White 6 pass”.
Black 3 is at d. Black 3 has liberties c and e, and White’s eight stones have b and e.
White 4 is at c. Black 3 now has only e, but White 4 itself has only b.
Black 5 is at b and captures White 4. Black 5’s only liberty is c, where White 4 was, so White could take it back by playing c. That is the ko. White’s eight stones now have one liberty, e.
White 6 is a pass. Article 7, paragraph 2 says that when life and death are confirmed after play has stopped, a stone may not be taken back in the same ko. White cannot play c.
Black 7 is at e and captures the eight White stones.
The commentary on Article 7, paragraph 2 (in Japanese) adds that when play stops, taking back a ko stops too, and that even an endless supply of ko threats, such as a double ko seki, cannot be used to take the ko back. The ko is still there, but it cannot be fought with ko threats.
Why the seven White stones are dead
Article 7, paragraph 1 defines living and dead stones:
Stones that cannot be captured by the opponent’s moves, or stones that, even if captured, can produce new stones that the opponent cannot capture, are called living stones. Stones other than living stones are called dead stones.
In the moves of Diagrams 1 and 2, Black plays first, and in the end the seven White stones are captured together with White 2. The rules give this as the reason the seven White stones are dead, and they call the three Black stones alive.
Article 9, paragraph 1 says that play stops when one player passes and the opponent then passes too. The list of examples opens with a note: each verdict is the result of confirming life and death when play stops in the position shown, and it does not prevent the players from settling the position in actual play before the game ends. The verdict of dead applies when play is stopped with the shape as it is.
Next to a mannen ko
The next example, 7-2, is titled “bent four in the corner and mannen ko side by side”. Example 7-2 (in Japanese) concludes:
両図が併存している場合でも、「隅の曲り四目」である上図の白七子は「死に石」である。(「両劫ゼキ」との併存の場合も同じ)
Even when both shapes are on the board, the seven White stones in the upper diagram, the bent four in the corner, are dead stones. (The same holds when it is on the board together with a double ko seki.)
A mannen ko or a double ko seki elsewhere on the board does not change the verdict. The seven White stones are still dead.
Its place in the 1989 revision
The Japanese Rules of Go replaced the Nihon Ki-in rules set in October 1949. The Nihon Ki-in’s summary of the revision (in Japanese) lists as the first effect of the revision that the theoretical basis for “bent four in the corner is dead” was made clear. Its list of main changes also includes “bent four in the corner (basis put into theory)”.
Where to go next
The ko rule and ko threats are in The Ko Rule in Go, a ko that ends as seki is in Mannen Ko, ko in tsumego answers is in Ko in Tsumego, and eye space and life and death are in Eye Space and Life and Death.
Solving tsumego in Go365
Go365 contains tsumego from 1 move to 7 moves, with 1,000 problems for each length, 4,000 in total. You play Black on the board, and White replies automatically. The goal, “Black to play: kill White” or “Black to play and live”, is shown above the board. Moves are counted for both sides together, and winning a ko does not count as a correct answer.
All problems are free to solve. The app shows ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. Ads you choose to watch for a hint or to refill retries are still offered after the purchase.
Go365A Go life-and-death problem every daySee the app →