Brain Training on a Commuter Train: Phone Etiquette, Motion and Background Noise

Kintetsu Railway in Japan asks passengers to switch off their mobile phones near the priority seats when the train is crowded. Its page defines crowded as the point where standing passengers’ bodies are touching each other.
This post covers three things that matter when you use a brain training app on a commuter train: what Japanese railways ask of phone users, what research says about train motion and motion sickness, and what it says about background noise and reading.
What Japanese railways ask
Kintetsu’s manners page (in Japanese) says this about phones on board:
- Phones should be on silent mode so that they do not disturb the people around you.
- Calls are not to be made on ordinary trains. On limited express trains, calls are made in the vestibule.
- When watching TV or videos on a phone or tablet, passengers are asked to keep the sound from leaking to the people around them.
- With headphones or earphones, passengers are asked to mind the volume.
In stations, it asks passengers to switch to silent mode before boarding and not to walk while using a smartphone, because it is dangerous.
Tokyu Railways gives the same rules on its manners page (in Japanese): silent mode on board, no calls, and phones off near the priority seats when crowded. Tokyu explains that it set these phone rules because many passengers asked for better manners, such as refraining from calls on trains.
Train motion and motion sickness
In 2005, Suzuki and colleagues at Japan’s Railway Technical Research Institute (RTRI) reported a poll of about 4,000 passengers on commercial trains, together with vibration measurements on each train.
A higher proportion of passengers felt motion sick on tilting trains, which lean into curves, than on non-tilting trains. The degree of motion sickness was strongly affected by low-frequency lateral motion of 0.25 to 0.32 Hz, a slow side-to-side sway in which one cycle takes about three to four seconds. Unlike seasickness, vertical motion had no clear effect. Susceptibility varied widely between people, and the data showed women and young people to be more susceptible.
Screens and motion sickness have been tested in a car. In a 2018 study in Applied Ergonomics, Kuiper and colleagues explain that carsickness is associated with a mismatch between actual and anticipated sensory signals. They note that such mismatches, as when below deck at sea or when reading a book in a car, can make motion sickness worse, and that passengers become motion sick more than drivers.
Eighteen people aged 19 to 33 took part, all of whom had had motion sickness at some point in the previous five years. Sitting in the front passenger seat, they were driven on a 15-minute slalom twice while doing a continuous search task on a 7-inch tablet: spotting whether an upward arrow was present among other arrows. Once the tablet was mounted at eye height in front of the windscreen, with much of the outside world visible around it. Once it was at the height of the glove compartment.
Participants rated their sickness every minute on a scale from 0 to 10. After 15 minutes, the average was 2.0 with the screen at eye height and 2.8 with it at glove compartment height. The authors attribute the difference to the view out of the window in peripheral vision, which reduces the mismatch between what is seen and what is felt. This was a car study and did not test trains.
Background noise and reading
A 2018 meta-analysis by Vasilev and colleagues in Perspectives on Psychological Science opens its abstract by noting that everyday reading happens in many settings, “such as on the train to work, in a busy cafeteria, or at home while listening to music,” where readers hear nearby noise, speech or music.
The authors pooled 65 studies of auditory distraction during reading. Background noise, speech and music all had a small but reliably negative effect on reading performance. For reading comprehension, the effect sizes (Hedges’s g) were −0.21 for all sounds, −0.26 for speech, −0.17 for noise and −0.19 for music. The authors use 0.20 as the guideline for a small effect.
Intelligible speech was more distracting than unintelligible speech, with an estimated probability of 99%. Music with lyrics was more distracting than music without, with a probability of 95%, and music without lyrics was not found to be distracting. The degree of disruption to comprehension did not generally differ between adults and children.
Research on how much phone use affects attention is covered in Does Too Much Smartphone Use Hurt Your Focus?
References
- Kintetsu Railway. Manners for comfortable use of trains and stations (in Japanese).
- Tokyu Railways. Request for better manners (in Japanese).
- Suzuki H, Shiroto H, Tezuka K. Effects of low frequency vibration on train motion sickness. Quarterly Report of RTRI. 2005;46(1):35-39.
- Kuiper OX, Bos JE, Diels C. Looking forward: In-vehicle auxiliary display positioning affects carsickness. Applied Ergonomics. 2018;68:169-175.
- Vasilev MR, Kirkby JA, Angele B. Auditory distraction during reading: A Bayesian meta-analysis of a continuing controversy. Perspectives on Psychological Science. 2018;13(5):567-597.
BrainDojo is a brain training app with 40+ trainings covering handwriting, reading aloud, arithmetic, memory and attention. A session can start at about ten seconds, and Today’s Training is picked for you each day. You answer by writing with your finger, reading aloud, or tapping. The Brain Dojo Check runs once a day, gives one test each for Processing Speed, Inhibitory Control and Working Memory, and returns your result as a radar chart and a rank.
BrainDojo works without an internet connection.
Every training except the newest ones is free to play, and the free version shows ads. BrainDojo Plus removes the ads and lets you play the new trainings at any time. Your first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →