Ten Ways to Protect Your Focus: Research on Sound, Breaks, Switching and Interruptions

In one experiment, people working through a task made of steps were interrupted for an average of 2.8 seconds. Right after the interruption, errors in the order of the steps doubled. With interruptions averaging 4.4 seconds, they tripled. That is from a study by Altmann and colleagues, published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General in 2014. The 2.8 seconds was about the time it took to perform one step of the task.
Brain Mondo has published a video that picks ten studies on focus like this one and puts them in order: sound, breaks, and switching and interruptions. Each tip has one paper as its source. In this post I go through the ten papers from the video, together with the conditions of each experiment and some cautions for reading them.
Video: Ten ways to protect your focus I wish I had known before studying for exams (Japanese)
There is also a short video with just three of them: Three things that get in the way of focus while studying (Japanese)
The video is in Japanese.
Sound
1. Study music without lyrics
College students did four tasks, verbal memory, visual memory, reading comprehension and arithmetic, under three conditions: silence, music without lyrics, and music with lyrics (Souza and Leal Barbosa, 2023, Journal of Cognition). With lyrics, scores on verbal memory, visual memory and reading comprehension went down, by about 0.3 of a standard deviation. For arithmetic, the drop was not clear enough to count.
The music without lyrics was hip-hop lo-fi. It did not clearly lower or raise scores. The participants were aware that lyrics hurt their performance, but they sometimes felt the music without lyrics was helping.
2. Read where you cannot hear words
One analysis combined 65 studies on sound during reading (Vasilev and colleagues, 2018). Background noise, speech and music all had a small but reliable harmful effect on reading. How much reading comprehension was disrupted did not generally differ between adults and children.
The biggest distraction came from speech you can understand and from music with lyrics. Noise, though, also caused reliable disruption. Sound while reading on a train is also covered in the post on brain training on a commuter train.
3. Sit where you cannot make out what people are saying
Thirty-seven students took part in a four-hour experiment in a laboratory made to resemble an open-plan office (Haka and colleagues, 2009, Indoor Air). The speech they heard was at the same level, 48 dBA, in every condition. What changed was how easy it was to understand, in three steps matching a private office, an open office with excellent acoustics, and an open office with poor acoustics.
Scores dropped only in the condition where speech was easiest to understand. The tasks that suffered were one that combines remembering and thinking, recalling items in order, and calling up what you already know. In the questionnaires, however, the sense of being disturbed rose with each of the three steps. The authors write that comfort was disturbed more easily than performance.
Breaks
4. Take breaks on a fixed schedule
Eighty-seven students at a Dutch university were split into three groups during one day of self-study (Biwer and colleagues, 2023, British Journal of Educational Psychology). One group took a 6-minute break after every 24 minutes of study, one took a 3-minute break after every 12 minutes, and one decided for themselves when to take a break. The 24 and 6 group is what is called the “Pomodoro technique”.
The students who chose their own breaks had longer study sessions and longer breaks. They also had higher levels of fatigue and distractedness, and lower concentration and motivation. There was no difference between the groups in mental effort invested or in tasks completed. The authors conclude that fixed breaks had benefits for mood, and appeared to be more efficient, with similar work completed in a shorter time.
5. Actually rest during a break
In one experiment, people doing a task of watching a screen for targets were randomly assigned to different ways of spending an interruption (Helton and Russell, 2015, Cognition). In the first experiment there were three: complete rest, a different watching task with letters, or carrying on with the main task. The second experiment added groups that did a task of remembering shapes or letters.
After the interruption, the rest group did best and the group that carried on did worst. For the groups that did another task, the results depended on the task. The authors suggest that when activities during a break use the same resources as the main task, they may get in the way even more.
Switching and interruptions
6. Step away briefly now and then during long tasks
Participants kept some digits in memory while they did a task of watching a screen (Ariga and Lleras, 2011, Cognition). Those who reported the digits at the end saw their watching performance fall steeply over time. But those who were asked to recall the digits now and then during the task did not show that fall.
The authors write that this directly challenges the widely held view that performance falls because attention gets used up. Their idea is that the system that keeps us on task gets used to the same goal over a long time, and that switching to another goal for a moment prevents it. This experiment is also in the post on a 10-minute daily practice for adults.
7. Group similar tasks together
In four experiments, participants either alternated between two tasks or did the same task again and again (Rubinstein and colleagues, 2001). Two of the experiments used sorting shapes by rules, and the other two used arithmetic problems. Alternating cost extra time for each switch.
That time got longer as the rules got more complex, and shorter when there was a cue showing which task to do next. Switching from a familiar task to an unfamiliar one also took longer. This study is covered in more detail in the post on multitasking.
8. Even a few seconds of interruption add errors in steps
This is the Altmann experiment from the start of this post. Participants did a task in which each step had its own rules, while keeping track of where they were. Interruptions averaging 4.4 seconds tripled the rate of errors in the order of the steps right after the interruption, and interruptions averaging 2.8 seconds doubled it.
Only errors in order went up. Other errors did not. The authors explain that attention as a whole was not disrupted. A short interruption shifts the focus of attention and cuts off the flow through the steps. An experiment in which notifications alone increased errors in an attention task is in the post on phone notifications.
9. Pause for 15 seconds before a reading interruption
Earlier research suggested that being interrupted while reading does not hurt the later recognition or recall of what was in the text (Foroughi and colleagues, 2015, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General). This study measured reading with questions that can only be answered by connecting information across the whole passage.
In the first and second experiments, interruptions lowered reading comprehension scores. Recognition of what was in the text did not go down. In the third experiment, adding a 15-second pause before the interruption removed these harmful effects.
10. Question your confidence in multitasking
Students at the University of Utah answered questions about how much they multitask and how good they think they are at it, and took a test of the ability to remember while thinking (Sanbonmatsu and colleagues, 2013, PLoS One).
The more people multitasked, the lower their actual ability was. The same was true of people who said they used a mobile phone while driving. People who multitasked more also thought they were better at it, and that self-rating was greatly inflated. The authors suggest that people who are less able to block out distractions are the ones more likely to multitask. Because this study looked at relationships, it cannot show that multitasking lowers ability.
Cautions for reading
The studies are not equally strong. The second is an analysis of 65 studies, but the effect it found is small. The only numbers of participants given in the abstracts are 37 for the third and 87 for the fourth, and the fourth looked at one day of self-study. The tenth looked at relationships, so it does not tell us about causes.
Only the fourth was done during real self-study. The fifth to eighth are results from laboratory tasks, such as watching a screen, sorting shapes and following set steps.
All of them are results under the conditions of an experiment.
Using it in daily life
The video suggests trying just one of them in today’s study. Written to match the conditions the studies tested, they look like this.
- If you play music, choose music without lyrics. In the first study, music without lyrics did not lower scores, but it did not raise them either.
- Take breaks on a schedule, and step away from the task during them. The groups in the fourth study took 6 minutes every 24 minutes, or 3 minutes every 12. In the fifth study, the group that rested completely did best.
- Put a cue for the next task where you can see it. In the seventh study, a cue shortened the time each switch took.
- If someone speaks to you while you are reading, wait 15 seconds before you stop. This is the condition in the ninth study that removed the harmful effect.
Brain Mondo introduces research-based stories about the brain, in top-ten videos and short videos. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day.
References
- Souza AS, Leal Barbosa LC. Should we turn off the music? Music with lyrics interferes with cognitive tasks. J Cogn. 2023;6(1):24.
- Vasilev MR, Kirkby JA, Angele B. Auditory distraction during reading: A Bayesian meta-analysis of a continuing controversy. Perspect Psychol Sci. 2018;13(5):567-597.
- Haka M, Haapakangas A, Keränen J, Hakala J, Keskinen E, Hongisto V. Performance effects and subjective disturbance of speech in acoustically different office types: a laboratory experiment. Indoor Air. 2009;19(6):454-467.
- Biwer F, Wiradhany W, Oude Egbrink MGA, de Bruin ABH. Understanding effort regulation: Comparing ‘Pomodoro’ breaks and self-regulated breaks. Br J Educ Psychol. 2023;93 Suppl 2:353-367.
- Helton WS, Russell PN. Rest is best: the role of rest and task interruptions on vigilance. Cognition. 2015;134:165-173.
- Ariga A, Lleras A. Brief and rare mental “breaks” keep you focused: deactivation and reactivation of task goals preempt vigilance decrements. Cognition. 2011;118(3):439-443.
- Rubinstein JS, Meyer DE, Evans JE. Executive control of cognitive processes in task switching. J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform. 2001;27(4):763-797.
- Altmann EM, Trafton JG, Hambrick DZ. Momentary interruptions can derail the train of thought. J Exp Psychol Gen. 2014;143(1):215-226.
- Foroughi CK, Werner NE, Barragán D, Boehm-Davis DA. Interruptions disrupt reading comprehension. J Exp Psychol Gen. 2015;144(3):704-709.
- Sanbonmatsu DM, Strayer DL, Medeiros-Ward N, Watson JM. Who multi-tasks and why? Multi-tasking ability, perceived multi-tasking ability, impulsivity, and sensation seeking. PLoS One. 2013;8(1):e54402.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →