← StudyX Devlog

Does Taking Photos Make You Forget? What a Museum Experiment Found

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 17 of 23

Does Taking Photos Make You Forget? What a Museum Experiment Found

When people photographed objects in an art museum, they remembered fewer of them than the objects they only looked at. Their memory for the objects’ details, and for where in the museum they were, was weaker too. That is the result of a study by the psychologist Henkel of Fairfield University in the United States, published in Psychological Science in 2014.

In a Brain Mondo short video, I introduced this study in about 40 seconds. In this post I look at the study a little more carefully, then at what later research has found, and at how to get along well with photos.

Video: Phone facts: Taking photos makes you forget (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

What the experiment was

In two studies, Henkel looked at whether photographing an object affects what you remember about it.

Participants were taken on a guided tour of an art museum. Along the way, they were told to simply look at some objects and to photograph others. Which objects were only observed and which were photographed was decided by the researcher, not chosen by the participant. Since each person experienced both kinds of object, memory could be compared within the same person.

After the tour, participants took a memory test: whether they remembered which objects they had seen, whether they remembered the objects’ details, and whether they remembered where in the museum each object had been.

Result: they forgot what they photographed

The result was clear. When participants took one photo of each object as a whole, they remembered fewer objects than the ones they had only looked at, and they remembered fewer details about them and less about where they were in the museum.

Henkel called this the “photo-taking-impairment effect”. It is the name I mentioned in the video.

Taking a photo is usually something we do “to remember”. So it is ironic that it weakened the memory in the photographer’s own head. Perhaps the reassurance that the camera will remember for you saves you the effort of remembering yourself. The paper’s conclusion also points to the difference between people’s memory and the camera’s “memory”.

Zooming in kept memory intact

The important part of this study comes next. When participants zoomed in to photograph a specific part of an object rather than the whole thing, their later recognition (judging whether they had seen it) and their memory for details were not impaired.

What is even more interesting is that memory for the parts they did not zoom in on was just as strong as for the parts they did. Memory for the whole object was protected, not only for the photographed part.

Henkel suggests that zooming in adds extra attention and thinking to the act, and that this cancelled out the memory impairment. To decide what to photograph, you have to look at the object carefully. The idea is that this “looking carefully” protected memory.

Some research shows that taking photos does not always make memory worse. A 2017 study by Barasch and colleagues, also in Psychological Science, used one field study and three lab studies to look at what happens when people are free to take photos.

Those who could take photos recognised more of what they saw, and less of what they heard, than those who could not. This was without looking back at any of the photos. Just taking “mental photos” had a similar effect.

The authors think that taking photos shifts attention towards what you see and away from what you hear. People with a camera remembered the parts they photographed better than parts they did not, and they also remembered even the unphotographed parts better than people without a camera.

In Henkel’s study, the objects to photograph were assigned. Here, people took photos by their own choice. If looking around to decide “what shall I shoot?” raises attention to what you see, that fits with the zoom result as well.

At the same time, the impairment itself seems to be a solid effect. In a 2022 study, Soares and Storm compared photographing images of paintings once, five times, or not at all. Even with multiple photos, memory for details was weaker than with no photos. The same was true when people were told to take five different photos.

A 2025 study by Lurie and colleagues looked at why memory drops. A common explanation is that operating the camera takes attention away from looking at the art. But making the task more complex did not make the impairment larger, and screenshots, the least effortful way of saving, caused a particularly large drop. Results were the same with participants’ own smartphones and with an unfamiliar camera provided by the experimenters. The authors conclude that divided attention alone cannot explain the effect.

Perhaps the very fact of having saved something loosens the effort to remember it. This is still being studied.

Beyond photos, research has long shown that storing information outside yourself makes it harder to remember on your own. In four studies by Sparrow and colleagues, published in Science in 2011, people who expected to be able to access information later recalled the information itself less, and instead recalled better where to find it. The authors write that the internet has become one form of memory outside ourselves.

But storing things outside is not all bad. In a 2015 study by Storm and Stone, saving one file before studying a new one improved memory for the new file. The effect did not appear when people were led to believe the saving was unreliable. The explanation is that when old information can safely be put outside, it does not get in the way of new information in your head.

Forgetting what you photograph may be the flip side of the same mechanism. Whatever the mind judges to be stored in the camera is treated as something you need not remember yourself. Seen this way, there is a view that what matters more than whether to take a photo is deciding what you want to keep in your own memory.

Easy to misread

This is not a story about photos making you less intelligent. What dropped was memory of the experience on the spot, for the objects that were photographed. The photo itself remains, and looking at it later can be a cue for recalling.

Also, Henkel’s study was in a museum, and the researcher decided which objects to photograph. That is a different situation from photos you take because you want to, on a trip or at a family event. As the study by Barasch and colleagues shows, when you choose your own shots, memory for what you saw can even improve.

Using it in daily life

Here is what can be taken from this study.

  • Look carefully before you shoot. This is how the video ends. Take a few seconds to look with your own eyes before pressing the shutter.
  • Shoot the detail that caught your eye, not just one picture of the whole. Deciding what to photograph is itself a way of looking closely. For a building on a trip, try moving in on a window or ornament you like, not only the full view.
  • Do not use “I’ll look at it later” as an excuse. One finding was that screenshots hurt memory most. For information you want to remember, one option is to save it and then write it out once in your own words.

Brain Mondo is a series of daily short videos about the brain, each based on a research paper. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day. It can also be a way to set aside a little time each day to use “remembering” and “looking closely” in your own head, things we tend to hand over to our phones.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits