← StudyX Devlog

Do Habits Run on Situations, Not Willpower? The Stale Popcorn Experiment

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 16 of 23

Do Habits Run on Situations, Not Willpower? The Stale Popcorn Experiment

People who usually eat popcorn at the cinema ate the same share of stale, seven-day-old popcorn as of freshly made popcorn. That is the result of a study by Neal, Wood and colleagues at the University of Southern California, published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin in 2011.

In a Brain Mondo short video, I introduced this study in about 40 seconds. In this post I write about the procedure and numbers of the two experiments, and about what the authors suggest for changing habits.

Video: Habit facts: Stale popcorn (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

What the researchers wanted to know

A habit forms when you repeat the same action in the same situation, until the situation and the action become linked in memory. Once the link is strong, just seeing the situation brings the action to mind.

The team wanted to know how much a habitual action is swayed by how you feel and what you like at that moment. They chose eating to test it. People believe they eat things because they taste good. In a pilot survey, when asked why they ate popcorn at the cinema, 17 of 22 people answered “it tastes good” or something close to it.

If people eat bad popcorn just as they always do, then that behaviour is not really running on “it tastes good”.

Study 1: cinema or meeting room

The first experiment took place at a cinema on a university campus. Participants were 98 people recruited just before a regular film showing. As a comparison, 60 people took part in a meeting room near the cinema. Each was paid $6.

People at the cinema were told the study was about personality and taste in films, and that they would rate some movie trailers. They first answered questions about how hungry they were and so on, then received a bottle of water and a box of popcorn. The popcorn was randomly either fresh, made an hour before the session, or stale, made seven days earlier. Each box was weighed before and after to record how much was eaten.

Participants sat as far from each other as possible and watched six movie trailers over 15 minutes. The meeting room group watched music videos for the same 15 minutes, in a setting with no link to cinema snacking. Lighting, the boxes, the number of people and other conditions were matched to the cinema.

At the end, they rated how much they liked the popcorn they had been given and how often they had eaten popcorn at the cinema in the past. That frequency was the measure of “habit strength”.

Result: strong-habit eaters ate regardless of taste

First, the stale popcorn really was judged worse. On a seven-point scale, fresh averaged 3.56 and stale 2.72. And these ratings were the same whether people had strong or weak habits. Those with strong habits did not have any special liking for old popcorn.

Even so, at the cinema, people with strong habits ate about 63% of the box, fresh or stale. How hungry they were also made little difference to how much the strong-habit eaters ate.

People with weak or moderate habits, on the other hand, ate clearly less of the stale popcorn, even at the cinema. They were deciding how much to eat by how good it tasted.

And in the meeting room, even the strong-habit eaters did not eat much of the stale popcorn. According to the authors, in the meeting room they behaved like the weak-habit eaters and ate only about half as much stale popcorn as fresh. Take away the cinema, and the habit did not kick in. They ate according to taste.

Study 2: eating with the other hand

In the second experiment, everyone took part at the cinema. There were 89 participants. This time the team changed not the setting but the way of eating.

They made a special popcorn box with a handle on one side. Participants were told to slide one hand between the handle and the box and hold the box that way for the whole session. Each session was assigned the right or left hand, and a handedness questionnaire afterwards sorted people into those who had eaten with their dominant hand and those who had used their non-dominant hand. The instruction was tucked in among several other procedural details. 90% of participants said they had used the instructed hand the entire time.

The result had the same shape as Study 1. Eating with their dominant hand, people with strong or moderate habits ate as much stale popcorn as fresh. But eating with the non-dominant hand, even the strong-habit eaters ate less of the stale popcorn. This is the result behind the line in the video that the habit broke down when people ate with the other hand.

The team also checked other explanations. Perhaps eating with the other hand simply draws attention to the popcorn, so people notice the taste. To test this, they asked nine quiz questions about details of the trailers, but the hand used did not seem to change where people’s attention went. How people saw the social norm, “eating popcorn at the cinema is normal”, did not explain how much they ate either.

What is surprising, and the limits

The strong-habit eaters also found the stale popcorn unpleasant. They knew it was bad, and their hands kept moving anyway. It shows clearly that a habit can start straight from the situation without passing through your thoughts or preferences.

There are limits, too. The participants were people who came to a campus cinema, and eating was measured for only 15 minutes. In Study 2, the drop in stale popcorn eaten by strong-habit participants using the other hand was only marginal statistically. It is also not known what exactly about the cinema was the trigger. It could be the place itself, or the evening showtime, the authors write. Since the same boxes and the same popcorn were used everywhere, the one thing we can say is that the box and the popcorn themselves were not the trigger.

That the setting holds a habit up has been shown in other research as well. In 2005, Wood and colleagues looked at the exercise, newspaper reading and TV watching habits of students transferring to a new university. Habits survived the move only when some part of the setting stayed the same, for example when someone kept reading the paper with other people, as before. When a changed setting broke a habit, people sometimes started acting on the intentions they held at the time.

So what do you do when you cannot change the setting? A 2010 study by Quinn and colleagues used two diary studies and found that the most effective way to hold back a bad habit was vigilant monitoring: thinking “don’t do it” and watching carefully for slip-ups. Other strategies were of little use against strong habits. An experiment then showed that this monitoring works not by weakening the habit itself but by strengthening the processes that hold back a response.

Using it in daily life

Here is what can be taken from this study.

  • To drop a habit, change the place. If you keep scrolling your phone on the sofa, decide that you only use your phone at a desk away from the sofa. A change of setting alone makes it easier for behaviour to come back under your own choice.
  • If you cannot change the place, change the way. The authors suggest that people who want to eat less might eat with their non-dominant hand, a small change that could interrupt the smooth flow of a habit. Holding your phone in the other hand or moving where you keep it follows the same idea.
  • Tie a habit you want to build to a fixed moment. If habits run on situations, one way is to place a new habit right after a moment that comes every day, such as “after I make my morning coffee”.

Brain Mondo is a series of daily short videos about the brain, each based on a research paper. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day. Open Today’s Training on the home screen and the day’s menu is already decided. You can give it a fixed moment in your day, such as after brushing your teeth or on the train to work.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits