← StudyX Devlog

Ten Facts About Phones and the Brain: Research on Attention and Memory for Students

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 22 of 23

Ten Facts About Phones and the Brain: Research on Attention and Memory for Students

619 smartphone users in Germany were split into three groups. One group gave up the phone for 7 days, one cut daily use by 1 hour, and one used the phone as usual. In both the quitting group and the cutting group, depressive and anxiety symptoms went down and life satisfaction went up. Most effects were stronger in the group that cut down, and stayed more stable over 4 months, than in the group that quit. That is from an experiment by Brailovskaia and colleagues, published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied in 2023.

Brain Mondo has published a video that picks ten studies like this one on phones and the brain and puts them in order: beliefs about use, memory and study, social media, and cutting down. Each point has one paper as its source. The list includes a study whose result wavered in replication and an experiment that found no difference between groups. In this post I go through the ten papers from the video, together with the conditions of each study and some cautions for reading them.

Video: New facts about phones and the brain that exam students should know: ten picks (Japanese)

There is also a short video with just three studies on phones, memory and reading: Three new facts on phones, memory and reading (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

Beliefs about use

1. Your sense of how often you check your phone is unreliable

One study recorded the phone use of 23 people for two weeks and compared it with their own estimates (Andrews and colleagues, 2015, PLoS One). Estimates of time spent on the phone were a fair measure of use. But estimates of how many times a day people used their phone did not correlate with actual use.

Neither the estimated time nor the estimated number of uses correlated with scores on a questionnaire about problem phone use. The authors conclude that self-estimated phone use should be interpreted with caution. This is a small study of 23 people.

2. The idea that multitaskers have worse attention wavered in replication

A 2009 study by Ophir and colleagues in PNAS compared people who often use several media at the same time with people who rarely do. The heavy multitaskers were more easily distracted by irrelevant things around them and by irrelevant information in memory, and they scored lower on a test of switching between tasks.

In a later replication by Wiradhany and Nieuwenstein (2017), however, only five of 14 tests showed a clear difference in the same direction. Only two held up in a stricter analysis. In their analysis of earlier studies, a weak association disappeared after correcting for bias from small studies, and the authors question whether the association exists at all. I wrote more about this study and its replication in the post on whether heavy phone use hurts focus. An experiment in which mistakes increased just because a notification arrived, without anyone touching the phone, is in the post on phone notifications. A study in which people who multitask more rated their own skill far too highly is in the post on ten ways to protect your focus.

Memory and study

These are four studies by Sparrow and colleagues, published in Science in 2011. When people faced difficult questions, they were primed to think of computers. And when they expected to be able to look the information up again later, they recalled the information itself less well, and recalled where to find it better instead.

The authors write that the Internet has become a form of memory outside ourselves, where information is stored collectively.

4. Look closely before you take a photo of something you want to remember

In one study, people on a guided tour of an art museum were asked to only look at some objects and to photograph others (Henkel, 2014, Psychological Science). When they photographed a whole object, they remembered fewer objects than when they only looked, and remembered fewer details and fewer locations in the museum.

When they zoomed in to photograph one part of an object, however, memory was not impaired. Memory for the parts they did not zoom in on was as strong as for the parts they did. The author suggests that the extra attention and thinking involved in this focused photo removed the memory loss. This study, and the Sparrow study in the third point, are also covered in the post on whether taking photos makes you forget.

5. People who rely on map apps had weaker memory for routes

One study asked 50 regular drivers about their lifetime experience with GPS, and tested their memory for routes in a virtual town (Dahmani and Bohbot, 2020, Scientific Reports). The more GPS experience people had, the weaker their route memory was when they had to find their own way without GPS.

Three years later, 13 of them were tested again. Those who had used GPS more in between showed a steeper decline in hippocampus-dependent route memory. Because the people who used GPS more had not done so out of a feeling that their sense of direction was poor, the authors think GPS use led to the decline. Still, the first result looks at an association at one point in time, and the follow-up was a small one of 13 people. The video says it cannot be called a cause.

6. Read explanatory texts on paper when you need to understand them well

One analysis combined experiments comparing reading on paper and on screens (Clinton, 2019, Journal of Research in Reading). It covers 33 experiments with random assignment, published between 2008 and 2018, with 2,799 people. Comprehension was somewhat lower when people read on screens than on paper.

The difference appeared for explanatory texts, and there was almost none for stories. There was no reliable difference in reading time. People’s judgement of how well they had read was more accurate on paper. On screens, that judgement was more likely to be off.

Social media

7. Aim for about 30 minutes of social media a day

143 undergraduates at the University of Pennsylvania recorded their usual use for a week and were then randomly split into two groups (Hunt and colleagues, 2018, Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology). One group limited Facebook, Instagram and Snapchat to 10 minutes each per day, and the other used social media as usual, for three weeks.

Compared with the usual-use group, the limited group showed clear reductions in loneliness and depression. Anxiety and fear of missing out went down in both groups. The authors suggest that recording one’s own use may itself have had a good effect, and write that limiting social media to about 30 minutes a day may lead to a significant improvement in well-being.

8. Quitting social media does not fix everything

In one experiment, participants were randomly split into two groups, and one group stopped using social media for 14 days (de Hesselle and Montag, 2024, BMC Psychology). They answered questionnaires every day for 14 days, and again 14 days after it ended.

In the group that quit, screen time and dissatisfaction with body image went down. Depressive and anxiety symptoms, loneliness and fear of missing out did go down during the period, but no difference between the groups was found. They went down in both groups alike. The authors write that future studies need to look at why such interventions work better for some people.

Cutting down

9. Cut your phone use by one hour a day instead of quitting

This is the Brailovskaia experiment from the opening. 200 people quit for 7 days, 226 cut their use by 1 hour a day, and 193 used the phone as usual. They were surveyed online four times: before, right after, 1 month later and 4 months later.

Both groups showed lower intensity of use, fewer problematic use tendencies, and fewer depressive and anxiety symptoms, along with higher life satisfaction and more physical activity. Most effects were stronger in the cutting group and stayed more stable over 4 months. Only in the cutting group did the number of cigarettes smoked per day go down. The authors conclude that complete abstinence from the phone is not necessary.

10. Screen time alone does not decide mental well-being

One study analysed three large, nationally representative data sets from Ireland, the United States and the United Kingdom (Orben and Przybylski, 2019, Psychological Science). After data exclusions it covered 17,247 teenagers. Screen time was measured with time-use diaries, in which people write down what they did at what time.

The study found little evidence for substantial negative associations between screen time and well-being. This held whether screen time was measured throughout the day or just before bed. The authors point out that most earlier studies came from a single country and relied on inaccurate self-reports. That links back to the first study.

Cautions for reading

The ten studies are not equally strong. The first had 23 people and the fifth 50, with a follow-up of 13. The fifth and tenth look at associations, so they cannot show a cause. The second is an example where the original result was barely confirmed in replication.

The seventh, eighth and ninth are experiments with random assignment, but their results differ a little. In the seventh, cutting each of three apps to 10 minutes a day reduced loneliness and depression. In the eighth, quitting for 14 days made a difference between groups only for screen time and body image dissatisfaction. The participants were American university students, German phone users and so on. None of the studies looked at exam students as such.

All of them are results under the conditions of each study.

Using it in daily life

The video suggests trying just one of them first. Following the conditions the studies tested, it looks like this.

  • Check how often you use your phone from a record, not from a feeling. In the first study, estimates of the number of uses were unrelated to actual use.
  • Cut one hour a day instead of quitting. In the ninth study, this was the group where most effects were stronger and lasted longer.
  • About 10 minutes a day for each social media app. This is the condition in the seventh study, with three apps limited to 10 minutes each per day.
  • Recall first, before you search. Read textbooks and explanations on paper. These follow the third and sixth studies.

Brain Mondo introduces research-based stories about the brain, in top-ten videos and short videos. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits