← StudyX Devlog

Where Children Get Stuck with Decimals: The Decimal Point

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperMathCalHow-To
Where Children Get Stuck with Decimals: The Decimal Point

Japan’s education ministry publishes a commentary on its national math curriculum (in Japanese), and in a few places it names the mistakes children make. For adding decimals in grade 4, it says many children line up the last digits instead of the place values. For dividing decimals in grade 5, it says mistakes are common in where the point goes in the remainder. Also in grade 5, it says many children find it hard to understand what happens when the divisor is smaller than 1.

All three concern the position of the point or the size of a decimal. This post shows, with worked examples, that the rule for the point changes with the operation. The examples are my own unless a source is given.

When decimals are taught in Japan

Your own school system may place these differently. In Japan’s Course of Study for Elementary Schools, 2017 (in Japanese), the calculations sit in these grades:

  • Grade 3: decimals to the tenths place, and adding and subtracting them
  • Grade 4: adding and subtracting decimals (the commentary extends this to hundredths and beyond). Multiplying and dividing a decimal by a whole number. Whole-number division with a decimal quotient
  • Grade 5: multiplying and dividing by a decimal, and the size of the remainder

The full sequence is in what Japanese children learn in each grade.

Three rules for the point

The same decimals call for different steps depending on the operation.

Adding and subtracting. Line up the points vertically, and bring the point straight down into the answer.

Multiplying. Calculate as if the points were not there. Add up the decimal places in both numbers, then count that many places from the right of the answer and put the point there.

Dividing. Move the point in the divisor and in the number being divided by the same number of places to the right, until the divisor is a whole number. The point in the answer goes directly above the moved point of the number being divided.

Adding and subtracting: line up the points

The commentary’s example is 3.7 + 2.48. The answer is 6.18.

Correct

   3.7 0
 + 2.4 8
 _______
   6.1 8

In column addition with whole numbers, the right-hand edges line up. Written the same way, decimals look like this.

Wrong

     3.7
 + 2.4 8
 _______
   2.8 5

With the right edges lined up, the 7 in 3.7 sits on top of the 8 in 2.48. The 7 is seven tenths and the 8 is eight hundredths, so they are different units and cannot be added as they stand.

Money makes this easy to see. $3.70 and $2.48 come to $6.18. Lining up the right edges treats 70 cents as 7 cents. The wrong answer, 2.85, is also smaller than 3.7. Adding cannot do that, so this is one place to catch it.

The commentary says that if an empty place is treated as 0, the calculation can go place by place. That is the 3.70 in the correct version above.

Subtraction has the same issue when a whole number is involved. The 5 in 5 − 1.37 has no visible point, but it is the same as 5.00.

   5.0 0
 - 1.3 7
 _______
   3.6 3

The answer is 3.63. To check, 3.63 + 1.37 = 5.

Multiplying: count the places instead

The commentary’s grade 4 example is 1.2 × 4. Since 1.2 is 12 tenths, 12 × 4 gives 48 tenths, which is 4.8.

The same idea of switching to whole numbers carries over when both numbers are decimals. Take 2.3 × 1.4.

     2.3
 x   1.4
 _______
     9 2
   2 3
 _______
   3.2 2

Without the points, 23 × 14 = 322. Both 2.3 and 1.4 have one decimal place, which makes two in all. Counting two places from the right of 322 gives 3.22.

The reason for counting comes from size. 2.3 times 10 is 23, and 1.4 times 10 is 14. So 23 × 14 is 100 times the real answer, and dividing by 100 brings it back. The commentary shows the same approach, treating 12 × 4.3 as 12 × 43 ÷ 10. Because the work is now in whole numbers, the points do not need to line up, and the right edges can.

Zeros add two more spots to get stuck.

Too few digits. For 0.2 × 0.3, 2 × 3 = 6. You need to count two places, but there is only one digit. Add a 0 on the left to get 0.06. The answer 0.6 would have only one decimal place. On a 10 by 10 grid standing for 1, 0.2 × 0.3 covers 6 squares and each square is 0.01, so you can see the 0.06.

A 0 at the right end. For 0.6 × 0.5, 6 × 5 = 30. Put the point in first to get 0.30, then drop the last 0 to get 0.3. Dropping the 0 first leaves 3, and counting two places from that gives 0.03.

Once the point is in, look at the size. 2.3 × 1.4 lies between 2 × 1 and 3 × 2, so between 2 and 6. It cannot be 32.2 or 0.322.

Dividing: move the point

The commentary uses the property that multiplying the divisor and the number being divided by the same number leaves the quotient unchanged. Its example is 7.2 ÷ 2.4, which becomes 72 ÷ 24 when both are multiplied by 10. The answer is 3.

For 4.56 ÷ 1.2, multiply by 10 to make the divisor 12. The number being divided also gets multiplied by 10, giving 45.6.

       3.8
 12 ) 45.6
      36
      ____
       9 6
       9 6
      ____
         0

The point in the answer sits directly above the point in 45.6. The answer is 3.8, and 1.2 × 3.8 = 4.56 confirms it.

Moving only the point in the divisor gives 4.56 ÷ 12 = 0.38, which is a tenth of the real answer.

The remainder keeps the original point

Take 5.3 ÷ 1.2, stopping when the quotient is a whole number. Moving the points gives 53 ÷ 12, which is 4 remainder 5.

A remainder of 5 would be larger than the divisor, 1.2. Moving the points does not change the quotient, but the remainder is still 10 times too big. The point in the remainder goes where the point was in the original 5.3.

         4
 1.2 ) 5.3
       4.8
       ___
       0.5

The remainder is 0.5. Cut a 5.3 m string into 1.2 m pieces and you get 4 pieces with 0.5 m left over.

The commentary gives two ways to check. The remainder must be smaller than the divisor. And the number being divided equals the divisor times the quotient plus the remainder. Here, 1.2 × 4 + 0.5 = 5.3.

When answers shrink and grow

With whole numbers of 2 or more, multiplying makes an answer larger and dividing makes it smaller. Decimals can reverse this.

1.5 × 0.4 = 0.6 is smaller than 1.5, even though it is a multiplication. 0.4 of a 1.5 m length is shorter than 1.5 m.

3 ÷ 0.5 = 6 is larger than 3, even though it is a division. Pouring 3 L of water into 0.5 L bottles fills 6 of them. The commentary says children should be able to explain why this happens when the divisor is less than 1, using a number line or something similar.

Checking whether the number you multiply or divide by is more or less than 1 tells you which way the answer should go.

Sorting the mistakes

Put the wrong answer next to the right one and mistakes fall into two groups.

The digits are right, and only the point is wrong. For example, 32.2 instead of 3.22. This goes back to the rules above: was the sum lined up by the point, were the places counted in the multiplication, was the point moved in the number being divided?

The digits are wrong. This is a whole-number calculation mistake. For division, see long division step by step. For carrying and copying slips, see reducing calculation mistakes.

When the rules themselves are not making sense, thinking in tenths is a place to go back to. The commentary says it is important in grade 3 to explain that counting in tenths lets a decimal be seen the same way as a whole number.

Where MathCal fits

MathCal is a math app I make, where children write their answers on the screen by hand.

The Decimal Drill practices adding, subtracting, multiplying and dividing decimals, and each operation can be turned on or off. The point is already on the screen. Children write the whole-number part to its left and the decimal part to its right. For 0.06, that is 0 on the left and 06 on the right. For an answer of exactly 3, it is 3 on the left and 0 on the right. The question count starts at 10.

The lessons show how it works. Decimal Bars builds decimals by collecting tenths. Decimal + and Decimal − move tenth pieces around, and Decimal × also uses a grid where each square is 0.01. Decimal ÷ shares tenths out equally. Decimal Column Math goes through adding, subtracting, multiplying and dividing in order as you tap, showing how to line up, count and move the point. Related Lessons under the Decimal Drill’s settings also opens the decimal lessons.

The developer interview says: “I think it is good to turn understanding and practice together, like two wheels.” In the app, that can mean seeing a lesson first and then writing answers in the drill.

Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.

Download on the App Store

MathCalHandwriting game for mental math