Teaching Elapsed Time: Where Kids Get Stuck on Minutes Later and Hours Before

In the United States, the Common Core standards for grade 3 include standard 3.MD.A.1: “Tell and write time to the nearest minute and measure time intervals in minutes. Solve word problems involving addition and subtraction of time intervals in minutes, e.g., by representing the problem on a number line diagram.” Before that, children learn to read hours and half-hours in grade 1, and in grade 2 to “Tell and write time from analog and digital clocks to the nearest five minutes, using a.m. and p.m.” So grade 3 is where reading the clock turns into calculating with it.
Many children who can read a clock perfectly well still freeze at “What time is it 35 minutes after 7:50?” In this post I write about where children get stuck with elapsed time, and how to teach it at home. I wrote about reading the clock itself in How to Teach Kids to Tell Time, so here I keep to the calculating that comes after.
A time and an amount of time are different things
The first stumbling block can come before any calculation. It is telling two ideas apart.
Japan’s teaching guide for arithmetic (in Japanese), which covers the same topic in grades 2 and 3, puts it clearly. Time, it says, is a quantity that shows the size of the interval from one point in time to another, and because everyday speech often blurs the two, children need to learn to distinguish “a time” from “an amount of time”.
“8 o’clock” is a time, a single point on the clock. “8 hours” is an amount of time, the length between two points. Adults hear the difference from context, but to a child both are clock words. Just getting into the habit of checking whether a problem asks “What time is it?” or “How long did it take?” cuts down on answers in the wrong form.
At home, it can help to ask, “Is this about a time, or about how long?” “What time do we leave?” is a time. “How many minutes to the park?” is how long.
Regrouping by 60
The other big stumbling block is the group of 60.
In the addition and subtraction children have done so far, a new place starts at 10. On a clock, the minutes roll over into the next hour at 60. Treating 7:50 plus 35 minutes like ordinary addition, 50 + 35 = 85, and writing “7:85” is a very natural mistake. When finding how long something took, a child may work out 10:15 minus 8:45 as 1015 − 845 = 170 and answer “1 hour 70 minutes”. The correct answer is 1 hour 30 minutes.
How do you separate this from regrouping by 10? One option is to hold off on lining up the numbers in columns for a while. Getting used first to thinking on the clock, using the next o’clock as a stopping point, can lead to fewer mistakes.
Stop at the hour
Here is the stopping-point method in three examples.
What time it will be. For 35 minutes after 7:50, first go to 8:00, which is 10 minutes. That uses 10 of the 35 minutes, leaving 25. Go 25 minutes past 8:00 and you reach 8:25.
What time it was. For 1 hour 40 minutes before 10:20, first go back 1 hour to 9:20. Then go back 40 minutes. Back to 9:00 is 20 minutes, which leaves 20 more. Go back 20 minutes from 9:00 and you reach 8:40.
How long it took. From 8:45 to 10:15: 8:45 to 9:00 is 15 minutes, 9:00 to 10:00 is 1 hour, and 10:00 to 10:15 is 15 minutes. Together that makes 1 hour 30 minutes.
Crossing from a.m. to p.m. works the same way. From 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. is 2 hours to noon, then 2 hours after noon, so 4 hours in all.
What these share is that you do not calculate straight away. You go to the o’clock first. It looks a lot like thinking of 8 + 5 as “8 and 2 more makes 10, then 3 left”, which I wrote about in How to Teach the Making Ten Strategy. The difference is that the stopping point is 60, not 10.
This is also what the number line in 3.MD.A.1 is for. Mark the o’clocks on the line, and the stopping-point method becomes a picture.
Lining up hours and minutes
Once a child is comfortable stopping at the hour, they can also calculate with amounts of time. To work out 3 hours 15 minutes minus 1 hour 40 minutes, write the hours and minutes in separate columns. You cannot take 40 from 15, so turn 1 hour into 60 minutes and move it to the minutes: 75 − 40 = 35 minutes. In the hours, 2 − 1 = 1. The answer is 1 hour 35 minutes.
This is the same move as borrowing in ordinary subtraction, where you take 1 from the next place and make it 10. Only here, what you take is 60, not 10. If your child borrows 10 and gets stuck on “25 − 40 minutes”, ask “How many minutes are in an hour?” I wrote about borrowing itself in How to Teach Carrying and Borrowing.
The Japanese guide also warns against needlessly complicated unit conversions, and says that calculation should be taught through situations from daily life. At home too, you can practice with the times in your own day rather than piling up hard worksheet problems.
Tools to use at home
A model clock with hands that move. The Japanese guide recommends having children actually move the hands of a model clock and count how many marks they pass. When the long hand passes 12, the short hand moves on to the next number. Turning the hands with their own fingers lets children see the roll-over at 60. A model with gears that move both hands together is even better.
A time number line. Draw one line on paper and mark the o’clocks, 7:00, 8:00, 9:00, in large writing, then divide the space between them into 10-minute steps. Mark the start and end times, and add up the lengths, stopping at each o’clock. The stopping-point method turns into a drawing.
The clock at home and your daily routine. Make problems out of real times: “Bath starts at 7:30. If you’re in for 20 minutes, what time is it then?” or “We left at 8:10 and got there at 8:35. How long did it take?” A good thing about elapsed time is that you can check the answer on the clock on the wall.
A stopwatch for seconds. In the Common Core, seconds appear in grade 4, when children convert between hours, minutes and seconds. Measuring “How many seconds can you stand on one foot?” with a stopwatch makes 60 seconds to a minute something a child can feel.
In my developer interview for MathCal, I said of the lessons on screen, “Because it is a digital app, it cannot fully reproduce the feel in the hand or the three-dimensional texture. That is where I feel the real thing is still needed.” A model clock is a tool you move by hand.
What MathCal offers
MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it. For time, there are three lessons and one drill.
In the Time lesson, the child drags the long hand of a clock to set a target time. The short hand moves along little by little as the long hand turns. The lesson goes in steps: o’clock, half past, quarter hours, then five-minute steps.
Time Units teaches 60 s = 1 min and 60 min = 1 h. The child drops 10-second pieces onto a clock, and when six pieces are in, they turn into 1 minute. Later steps have six 10-minute pieces making 1 hour, and twenty-four 1-hour pieces making 1 day. It is a way to collect the group of 60 by hand and check it.
Time Math is a lesson on adding and subtracting time. On the clock, moving clockwise from the starting amount is addition, and moving back the other way is subtraction. It works in steps of 10 seconds or 10 minutes, within one turn of the clock.
The Units & Time Drill includes time conversion problems such as “2 h 15 min = □ min”. Length, capacity and weight conversions are mixed in too, but in the drill settings you can keep only Time.
One way to divide it is to practice calculations that cross the hour with a model clock and a number line at home, and use MathCal for what sits underneath them: the group of 60 and converting between units of time.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →