When Fractions Don't Click: What to Show After the Pizza Picture

In Japanese elementary schools, children meet simple fractions like 1/2 and 1/3 in grade 2. In grade 3 they learn what a fraction means and do simple addition and subtraction with the same denominator. Grade 4 brings equivalent fractions, grade 5 adding and subtracting fractions with different denominators (finding a common denominator), and grade 6 multiplying and dividing fractions (Ministry of Education, Elementary School Course of Study, 2017, in Japanese). The full picture by grade is in What Kids Learn in Arithmetic, Grade by Grade.
Fractions are usually introduced with a picture of a pizza or a cake. Cut a circle into four, and one slice is 1/4. It is a clear picture. But somewhere between grades 3 and 5, some children reach the point where this picture is no longer enough. In this post I write about what to show after the pizza.
Where children get stuck
There are four common sticking points.
The first is comparing size. With 1/3 and 1/4, the 4 is bigger, so the child decides 1/4 must be bigger.
The second is comparing fractions like 2/3 and 3/4, where both the top and bottom numbers differ.
The third is fractions bigger than 1, like 5/4. “Five of the four pieces you cut” makes no sense.
The fourth is common denominators and simplifying. The steps can be memorised, but if it never sinks in why you may multiply the top and bottom by the same number, the mistakes keep coming.
Why the pizza is not enough
A circle is good at showing “so many parts of a whole cut into equal parts”. For 1/2 or 1/4, even a child’s own drawing comes out about right.
But it has some weak spots.
First, nobody, not even an adult, can draw a circle cut into exact thirds or fifths. A child’s drawing of 1/3 tends to have pieces of different sizes.
Second, if you draw two circles to compare 2/3 and 3/4, the difference between the slices is hard to see.
Third, a circle has no place for “more than 1”. To draw 5/4 you need two circles, and it becomes hard to see it as a single number.
The circle does not have to be dropped. It stays as the way in. On top of it, two more pictures can help: a paper strip and a number line.
The next picture, part 1: a paper strip
A long thin strip of paper is easier to divide equally than a circle, and two strips can be laid side by side.
Take two paper strips of the same length. Fold one into three equal parts and the other into four. Colour two parts of the first and three parts of the second. Line them up, and you get this:
2/3 |#######|#######|.......|
3/4 |#####|#####|#####|.....|
The # marks show the coloured parts. Both strips have the same total length. Look at where the colouring ends, and you can see that 3/4 is a little longer. The difference is one twelfth of the strip.
This picture is also an explanation of common denominators. Split each part of the top strip into four, and each part of the bottom strip into three, and both strips are now in twelfths. 2/3 is 8/12, and 3/4 is 9/12. Multiplying the top and bottom by the same number only makes the marks on the strip finer. The coloured length does not change. Once a child sees that, the steps of finding a common denominator have a meaning.
Comparing 1/3 and 1/4 is also obvious with strips. One of three parts of a strip, against one of four parts of the same strip. The more parts you cut, the shorter each part.
The next picture, part 2: the number line
Once the strips feel familiar, show the number line as a strip shrunk to a thin line.
0 1/4 2/4 3/4 1 5/4
|.........|.........|.........|.........|.........|
Divide the stretch from 0 to 1 into four, and the marks go 1/4, 2/4, 3/4, with 4/4 landing on 1. Carry on with the same spacing, and the next mark is 5/4.
On a number line, a fraction is no longer a piece of something that was cut. It is a single number that says how far you have gone from 0. 5/4 is a point a little past 1. For a child confused by fractions bigger than 1, this view can help.
Mark 2/3 and 3/4 on the same line, and which is bigger is just which is further to the right. The number line can also show that the decimal 0.75 sits on the same point as 3/4.
An order to try at home
Here is one order:
- Fold a paper strip to make 1/2 and 1/4. A check on the circle picture
- Fold strips of the same length into thirds and quarters, and compare 1/3 with 1/4
- Colour 2/3 and 3/4, line them up and see which is longer
- Draw a number line under the strip and write fractions at the marks
- Extend the number line past 1 and find where 5/4 and 3/2 go
In my interview, I said that what drew me to Montessori education was “the idea that children deepen their understanding intuitively while playing with their hands”. Fractions are a topic where that idea is easy to try.
Fraction lessons and drills in MathCal
MathCal is a calculation drill app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it. For fractions, it has lessons and a drill.
The Fraction Circles lesson teaches fractions by dropping pieces into a circle. The circle is divided into as many equal parts as the denominator, the numerator counts up as you add pieces, and a celebration appears when you reach the target fraction. In other words, MathCal’s way in is also the circle. Fraction + and Fraction − continue with the same circle picture. Reduce & Common Denom. reveals, one step at a time, how to find the greatest common factor or least common multiple and line up the tops and bottoms. Fraction ↔ Decimal brings the denominator to 10 or 100 and reads the result as a decimal on a grid.
The paper strip and number line in this post are not in the app at the moment. That part is best done on paper. As I said in the interview, I hope people will use the two together well.
For practice there is the Fraction Drill, where children solve fraction addition, subtraction, multiplication and division by hand. It is aimed at grades 5 and 6. I think understanding and practice should turn together, like two wheels. The idea is that what a child understands with strips and number lines becomes second nature through the drill.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →