When "Five More Minutes" Means Nothing: Helping Kids Feel How Long Time Is

Children use words like “minute” and “hour” early. That does not mean they know how long a minute or an hour is. This post looks at what research has found about how children learn time words, and then at ways of making a length of time something a child can follow.
An hour is longer than a minute, and that is about all
Tillman and Barner at the University of California, San Diego, tested how children interpret seven time words: second, minute, hour, day, week, month and year. They reported the results in a 2015 paper in Cognitive Psychology.
According to the abstract, preschoolers knew the order of the words, for example that an hour is longer than a minute. But they had little to no knowledge of the actual durations the words stand for. That knowledge came much later, many years after children first start using time words in speech, and in many children it did not appear until they had learned the formal definitions. The authors concluded that linking words with the felt length of time does not come naturally to children, and that their early meanings rest on relative order, which they may pick up from how the words are used around them.
Yesterday and tomorrow
The same research group also studied words such as “yesterday”, “tomorrow” and “last week”. In a 2017 paper, they asked 3- to 8-year-olds to place these words on a left-to-right timeline running from infancy to adulthood.
The abstract notes that children say these words as early as age 2 or 3, but do not use them as adults do for several more years. Knowing whether a word points to the past or the future, and knowing the order of the words, both came in between ages 4 and 6. Knowing how far away each one is from now (for example, that last week was about seven times further back than yesterday) came later, after age 7.
Where it sits in school
In Japan, the national kindergarten curriculum guidelines (in Japanese) list, among the aims for health, that children gain the habits needed for a safe daily life and act with a sense of what comes next. Units of time come later, in elementary arithmetic: days, hours and minutes and how they relate in grade 2, and working out times and lengths of time needed in daily life in grade 3. Reading the clock is covered in How to Teach Kids to Tell Time, and working out elapsed time in Teaching Elapsed Time.
Use limits a child can see
The Mount Sinai Parenting Center at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai has a page for parents of 4- and 5-year-olds, Handling Transitions, on moving a child from one activity to the next. These are the points that deal with time.
Use time frames your child understands. The page suggests easy, concrete time examples and counting along with the child. Its example is “five more pushes on the swing”.
Give a warning before the change. The example is “This is our last book tonight. When I’m finished reading this, it will be time to get in your bed.” Here too the limit is one book, not a number of minutes.
Try a timer. Explain that the timer keeps track of when it is time to switch. Give the child a signal that time is almost up, so they are not surprised or rushed when it rings.
Be consistent. Use the same words, timing methods and warning signals every time, so they become part of the child’s routine.
Use natural endings. The page notes that letting a child finish a show can be better than turning it off 15 minutes before the end and causing a meltdown.
Compare and measure
The Illinois Early Learning Project at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign has a tip sheet for teachers of children aged 3 to 5, Time for Preschoolers: Duration.
It starts by saying that most preschool-age children are not ready to fully grasp abstract time ideas such as duration, the amount of time an event lasts. Even so, preschoolers already deal with duration, for instance when they have to wait for something they want.
One activity it suggests is guessing which takes longer, with questions like “Which do you think takes you a longer time: eating a cracker or drinking a glass of water?” It also suggests showing children how to use timers, stopwatches and hourglasses, and leaving them out so children can explore them.
In physical play, a child predicts how many times she can jump in 10 seconds, then jumps while other children count, and everyone compares the guess with the result. In cooking, children guess how many minutes the oven will take to heat up. The sheet adds that counting to 10 or 20 may be hard for preschoolers. Its stated aim is to help older preschoolers use prediction and estimation to learn how time goes by.
About BrainDojo Kids
BrainDojo Kids is an iPhone and iPad app I make for ages 3 to 6, where children write on the screen with a finger or a pen to practice letters and numbers.
The parent settings have a Daily time limit, on by default at 10 minutes. It can be set from 5 to 60 minutes in 5-minute steps. At the top of the Home, Training and Courses screens, a timer icon shows the time left for the day. When it reaches zero, a screen says that today’s training is done and shows how long the child played.
The three games in Today’s Training and the four Recommended games change every day and are free, and a Premium subscription (monthly or yearly) opens all courses and games. There are no ads and no account to create. The first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo Kids, and how long young children can stay with one activity in How Long Can Preschoolers Focus?.
BrainDojo KidsFocus, one handwritten letter at a timeSee the app →