How to Reduce Calculation Mistakes: Fixes by Type of Mistake

Japan’s national curriculum for second-grade mathematics asks children to understand how addition and subtraction relate, and to use that to “check their calculations”. The notes for third grade add that teachers should also touch on “estimating the result of a calculation” (MEXT, Course of Study for Elementary Schools, 2017, in Japanese). Checking an answer is taught as part of calculating, not as an extra.
Even so, a test often comes back with points lost on problems the child knew how to do. These are usually called careless mistakes. In this post I split them into types and look at a fix for each.
Stop calling them careless
One place to start is to stop lumping these errors together as “careless”.
Calling a mistake careless makes the cause “not paying attention”, and the only fix left is “be more careful”. That is hard for a child to act on. What exactly should they do differently?
Mistakes come in types, and each type happens in a particular place. Once you know the place, you can work on that place alone.
Types of mistakes
Most calculation mistakes in elementary school fall into one of these.
1. Copying the problem wrong. When copying a problem into a notebook, a digit or sign changes. 38 becomes 83, a plus is read as a minus. The arithmetic is right, but it is a different problem.
2. Misreading your own handwriting. A digit written along the way is later read as a different digit. 0 and 6, 1 and 7, 4 and 9, 5 and 6 look alike when written quickly.
3. Misaligned columns. In column arithmetic, the ones and tens are not lined up. In long multiplication, the second row is not shifted one place to the left.
4. Forgetting a carry or a borrow. The small carried 1 is not written, or it is written and then not added. In subtraction, the tens digit is not reduced after borrowing.
5. A wrong fact. The child has 7 × 8 stored as 54, or answers 8 + 6 with 13. The mistake happens only with certain pairs, and always the same way.
6. A skipped step. In long division, the next digit is not brought down. A place where the quotient should be 0 is skipped.
7. Copying the final answer. Everything is right until the answer is copied into the answer box. Leaving off the unit belongs here too.
Telling the types apart
The best way to sort mistakes is to go through a returned test or worksheet with the child, one error at a time.
Look at the working, not only the answer. If the numbers in the working differ from the problem, it is type 1. If digits in the working are hard to read, type 2. If the columns lean, type 3. If there is no small carried 1, or there is one and it did not reach the answer, type 4. If the same pair goes wrong every time, type 5.
Do this a few times and you will probably see that each child leans towards certain types. There is no need to worry about all seven equally. Start with the most common one.
A fix for each type
For copying errors, compare once with a finger before starting. Before calculating, trace the copied numbers against the problem, one digit at a time. Checking before you start costs less than checking after you finish.
For misread digits, agree on how to write them. Close the top of the 0 and make it tall. Give the 6 a clear upward stroke. Write 1 as a single line and give the 7 a clear top bar. Decide on an open 4. Writing digits you can read back later can end up faster than writing quickly.
For misaligned columns, use squared paper. One digit per square, and the columns line up on their own. For the second row of long multiplication, a small 0 in the shifted square also helps.
For forgotten carries, fix where the 1 goes. Above the column or below the line, always in the same spot. When the place is fixed, the eye goes there when adding. If carrying itself is still shaky, going back to the pairs that make 10, as in How to Teach Carrying and Borrowing, is the better route.
For wrong facts, pull out just those pairs. Put the 7 × 8 that keeps going wrong on a card and practise it for a few days. There is no need to redo every table. More on that in How to Learn Times Tables: Say Them, Write Them, Use Them.
For skipped steps, put the steps into words. For long division, have the child say “divide, multiply, subtract, bring down” out loud while solving one problem. Which step was skipped becomes clear to the child as well.
For copying the final answer, compare the box with the working. This takes one look during checking time.
How to check work
Some ways of checking are said to work better than others.
The weak way is to follow the same calculation in the same order a second time. A mistake that looked right once tends to look right again.
The strong way is to check by a different route.
- Use the opposite operation. For 52 − 17 = 35, see whether 35 + 17 makes 52. This is the “checking” in Japan’s second-grade curriculum. For division, see whether quotient × divisor + remainder gives the number you started with.
- Estimate the size. 48 × 21 is roughly 50 × 20 = 1,000. An answer of 1,008 is close enough to trust. 10,080 or 108 means a place value slipped somewhere.
- Look only at the ones digit. The ones digit of 47 × 38 must be the ones digit of 7 × 8 = 56, which is 6. If the answer does not end in 6, something is off.
When time is short, one option is to check the column problems and the ones with many carries first, rather than every problem.
Where MathCal fits
MathCal is a math drill app I make, where children write their answers on the screen by hand.
In the Column Arithmetic Drill, and its multiplication and division versions, children write one digit per cell. Because answers go into cells, the columns cannot drift. A cell the app cannot read is highlighted, and Check answer stays unavailable until every cell has been read. The digit the app read is shown small at the left edge of each cell, so children can see what their handwriting was taken to be. For a child whose mistakes are mostly misread digits, that shows how their own writing reads. The problem area can be written on freely, separate from the answer cells, so the small carried 1 and other working can go there. Only the answer cells are marked.
Settings include Recognizes 5 with 2 strokes and Left-handed interface, so children who write 5 in two strokes, or who write with the left hand, can set the app to suit them.
Today’s Challenge on the home screen is sometimes Focus Challenge, which counts how many questions in a row a child gets right. It looks at staying accurate, not at speed.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads.
For what to look at when a child is slow rather than inaccurate, see When Your Child Is Slow at Math Facts: What to Check Before Speed.
Calculation mistakes look like a matter of attention, but most of them happen in a particular place. Give that place a name, and the fix becomes much more concrete than “be careful”.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →