← StudyX Devlog

Smothered Mate: The Knight Checkmate and Philidor's Legacy

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperChess365How-To
Smothered Mate: The Knight Checkmate and Philidor's Legacy

Every square next to the king is filled by the king’s own pieces, and a knight gives check. That is a smothered mate. The English Wikipedia article Smothered mate describes it as a checkmate delivered by a knight in which the mated king cannot move because it is completely surrounded by its own pieces.

A knight check cannot be blocked. The only ways out are to move the king or to capture the knight. If the king has no square and nothing can take the knight, it is mate. Why a knight check cannot be blocked, with the wording of the rules, is in How the Knight Moves.

This post looks at the mate in the corner, at “Philidor’s legacy”, which finishes with a queen sacrifice, at an example away from the corner, and at where the name comes from. Position 1 is an example I set up. The notation is explained in Reading Chess Notation.

Why it usually happens in the corner

The Smothered mate article says the mate is usually seen in a corner of the board, because only three pieces are needed to surround the king there, fewer than anywhere else.

A king on h8 has only three neighbouring squares: g8, g7 and h7. With its own rook on g8 and its own pawns on g7 and h7, the box is already built. A knight landing on f7 with check then mates, as long as nothing can capture it.

After Black castles kingside, the king sits on g8 behind pawns on f7, g7 and h7. Ways to attack that king are in Attacking the Castled King, and mates with a rook or queen against a king on the last rank are in Back-Rank Mate.

Philidor’s legacy

The Smothered mate article describes Philidor’s mate, also known as Philidor’s legacy, as a checkmating pattern that ends in smothered mate. In the article’s description it has four stages:

  • the knight checks and forces the king out of the corner
  • the knight moves away to give a double check with the queen
  • the queen is sacrificed to force the rook next to the king
  • the knight mates

Position 1: White: king g1, queen d1, knight g5, pawns a2, b2, f2, g2, h2. Black: king g8, rook e8, pawns a7, b7, g7, h7. White to move.

White mates in five moves here, and there is no mate in four or fewer.

  1. Qb3+. Black has three replies. After 1…Kf8, 2. Qf7# ends it. After 1…Re6, blocking with the rook, 2. Qxe6+ mates on the third move. That leaves 1…Kh8
  2. Nf7+. Black’s only move is Kg8. The knight has driven the king out of the corner
  3. Nh6+. With the knight gone from f7, the queen on b3 sees all the way to g8 along the diagonal. Both the knight and the queen give check: a double check. Black can play Kh8 or Kf8, and Kf8 runs into 4. Qf7#
  4. Qg8+. The knight on h6 covers g8, so the king cannot take. Black must play Rxg8
  5. Nf7#. Checkmate

In the final position, g8 is blocked by Black’s own rook and g7 and h7 by Black’s own pawns. No black piece can capture the knight on f7.

Moves 2 and 3 each have a job. If White sacrifices at once with 2. Qg8+ after 1…Kh8, Black can take with the king as well as the rook, because the knight on g5 does not cover g8. Bringing the knight round to h6 means the king can no longer take the queen on g8, so the rook has to.

Because 3. Nh6+ is a double check, Black cannot capture either checking piece and must move the king. How double check works is in Discovered Check and Double Check. The last two moves on their own, the queen sacrifice followed by the knight mate, appear as a position in Sacrificing to Checkmate.

Starting with 1. Qd5+ instead leads to the same five-move mate, since the diagonal from d5 to g8 also runs through f7.

A smothered mate away from the corner

Away from the corner, more pieces are needed to box the king in. It can still happen in the opening. The Smothered mate article gives this line as a trap in the Caro-Kann Defence:

  1. e4 c6 2. d4 d5 3. Nc3 dxe4 4. Nxe4 Nd7 5. Qe2 Ngf6 6. Nd6#

Position 2: the position after those moves, with White’s 6. Nd6# just played.

The black king on e8 has five neighbouring squares, and all of them hold black pieces: the queen on d8, the knight on d7, pawns on e7 and f7, and the bishop on f8. The pawn on e7 attacks d6 but cannot take. When the knight left e4 for d6, the e-file opened from the white queen on e2 to the king on e8, and the e7 pawn stands on that line. If it moved, its own king would be in check from the queen, so it cannot move. It is a pinned pawn.

After 5. Qe2, White is threatening 6. Nd6#. 5…Ngf6 does not stop it. After 5…Ndf6 or 5…e6, Nd6 is not mate.

The name and its history

Philidor is François-André Danican Philidor. According to the English Wikipedia article François-André Danican Philidor, he was a French composer and chess master, born in 1726 in France and died in London in 1795, and was widely regarded as the best chess player of his age. In 1749 he published Analyse du jeu des Échecs.

The pattern is older than Philidor, though. The Smothered mate article calls the name something of a misnomer, because the technique is already described in Luis Ramírez de Lucena’s 1497 text on chess, several hundred years before Philidor.

The English Wikipedia article Luis Ramírez de Lucena gives the book’s title as Repetición de Amores y Arte de Ajedrez con CL Juegos de Partido, “Repetition of Love and the Art of Playing Chess with 150 Games”, published in Salamanca around 1497. The article says that the smothered mate later named Philidor’s legacy is in the book.

Sources

  • Wikipedia, “Smothered mate” (English)
  • Wikipedia, “François-André Danican Philidor” (English)
  • Wikipedia, “Luis Ramírez de Lucena” (English)

Practising with Chess365

Chess365 is a checkmate puzzle app with 1,000 puzzles each of mate in 2, 3, 4 and 5. You always play White, you can make any legal move, and Black replies automatically. If the line ends without mate, the app tells you the king got away and you start again from the beginning. If you stalemate Black, the app shows a separate message explaining that it is a draw.

A hint lights up the piece to move and its destination, and you play the move yourself. After solving, “Review moves” lets you step back and forward through the moves to check the line.

All the puzzles are free, and a one-time “Remove Ads” purchase removes the ads. How to start with mate puzzles is in Chess checkmate puzzles for beginners, and how to use the app is in Getting Started with Chess365.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Chess365A chess mate puzzle every day