← StudyX Devlog

Sudoku in a Book vs in an App: How Solving Feels Different

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperSudoku365How-To
Sudoku in a Book vs in an App: How Solving Feels Different

You can solve Sudoku in a paper book or in an app on your phone. The rules are the same either way. You fill a 9×9 grid so that every row, every column and every 3×3 box contains each digit from 1 to 9 exactly once.

Even with the same puzzle, though, solving on paper and solving in an app feel quite different. In this post I compare that feel in this order: pencil marks, erasing, finding mistakes, seeing the grid, and carrying and pausing. I make an app called Sudoku365, but I’ll write about where paper is better just as plainly.

Cost, number of puzzles and how other apps and websites compare are in Sudoku365 vs Other Ways to Play Sudoku, so here I’ll stick to the differences you notice while your hands are busy.

Writing pencil marks

In Sudoku you write small digits in undecided cells to show which numbers could still go there. These are called pencil marks, notes or candidates. This is a big difference between paper and apps.

On paper, you can write them any way you like. Some people write small digits in the corners of a cell, others line them up in the middle. Some only mark digits that can go in just two cells, some use dots or circles, some use coloured pencils. Being able to invent your own notation is a real strength of paper. On the other hand, in a book with small cells, fitting nine digits into one is cramped. If your handwriting gets sloppy, you may not be able to read your own notes.

In an app, the format is fixed. In Sudoku365, you tap NOTES OFF so it turns to NOTES ON, then tap a number button, and that digit is added as a note in the selected cell. The notes sit in fixed positions, as if the cell were a small 3×3 grid, with 1 at the top left and 9 at the bottom right. Tapping the same digit again removes it. The digits never get messy, and since each digit is always in the same place in every cell, it is easy to scan the whole grid for one digit’s notes. On the other hand, there is only one kind of note. You can’t switch between different kinds of marks the way you can on paper.

Forgetting to clear notes is less likely in the app. On paper, once you place a digit, you have to cross that digit out of the notes in the same row, column and box yourself. Miss one, and it can lead you into a wrong deduction later. In Sudoku365, with “Remove numbers from notes” switched on in Settings (it is on by default), placing a correct number clears that digit from the notes of the related cells automatically.

Sudoku365 has no feature that fills in every cell’s candidates for you. As on paper, you write the notes yourself. How to write notes in the first place is in How to Write Sudoku Pencil Marks.

Erasing

On paper, you use an eraser. With a pencil you can rewrite as often as you like, but a cell you have erased many times gets rough and keeps faint marks. When you rub out a tiny note, you sometimes take the one next to it too. People who solve in pen can’t erase at all, so they check carefully before writing. Some enjoy that tension.

The app has two ways to remove things. In Sudoku365, ERASE clears the notes and any wrong number in the selected cell. A number you placed correctly stays put when you tap ERASE. UNDO takes back your actions one at a time. It also restores notes you wrote and notes that were removed automatically when you placed a number. However often you erase, the grid stays clean.

On paper, when you suspect everything after a certain point was wrong, deciding how far back to go and erasing your way there is a lot of work. In the app, you go back one step for each tap of UNDO. The app takes less work here.

When you notice mistakes

This is where tastes differ.

On paper, nobody tells you about a mistake. If you place one wrong digit early, you usually notice much later, when the same digit appears twice in a column. Then you trace back to find where it went wrong. The answers are at the back of the book, but looking at the answer page can show you other cells’ answers too. Some people consider finding their own mistakes part of the fun of Sudoku.

In Sudoku365, you see a wrong number right away. A number that doesn’t match the solution turns red and counts as a mistake. A third mistake ends the game. If you watch a rewarded ad and choose Recover, the mistake count is reset and you can carry on.

The good side of knowing at once is that you never build deductions on top of a wrong digit. You won’t solve to the end only to find one early error ruined everything. The other side is that you learn the result before you have checked the digit yourself. If you make a habit of being able to give one reason before placing each number, the app still trains you to think for yourself.

Seeing the grid

On paper, you can see the whole grid at once. A grid in a book is usually larger than a phone screen, so you can think while looking at all of it. Turning the book, or tracing a row or column with your finger, is something paper does well.

The app lights up where to look. In Sudoku365, when you select a cell, the cells in the same row, column and box are shaded. If you select a cell with a digit in it, the other cells with that digit are shaded too. The app helps with what your eyes would have to search for on paper. And with “Hide placed number buttons” on (the default), the button for a digit disappears once all nine of it are on the grid, so you can see at a glance which digits remain.

That help is handy, but solving on paper needs the skill of checking rows, columns and boxes in order yourself. If you solve both ways, it’s worth noticing, when you’re on paper, what you had been leaving to the app. How to look again when you’re stuck is in Stuck on a Sudoku?

If screen brightness bothers you, Sudoku365 has a Dark theme. Still, before bed, or when you want a break from screens, paper is another option.

Carrying and pausing

Paper needs no battery. With a book and a pencil you can solve anywhere, and no notification will distract you. But you do need to carry a pencil, and ideally an eraser. Writing tiny notes on your knee on a train is a little awkward.

An app only needs your phone. You can solve for a few minutes and close it, then pick up from the same grid with CONTINUE on the home screen. The timer carries on from where it was too. For solving bit by bit while you wait, the app is a good fit. You can also use hints: you start with 10, and get one more each time you clear a puzzle and each time you watch an ad. A paper book has nothing that shows you just the next step.

Which to choose

Which is better depends on what you enjoy about Sudoku.

If you want to develop your own way of writing notes, find your mistakes yourself, or solve away from a screen, a paper book may suit you.

If you want to solve a little at a time, redo things as often as you like without eraser marks, and know about mistakes straight away, an app may suit you.

Using both is another approach. For example, one puzzle a day in the app, and a slower session with a book on days when you have time. On paper you have to take care yourself of what the app was helping with, such as checking rows and columns in order and clearing notes. That makes good practice.

About Sudoku365

Sudoku365 is a Sudoku app for iPhone, iPad and Android. It has four difficulties, Easy, Medium, Hard and Expert, with 300 puzzles each, 1,200 in total. There is a Daily Challenge with one puzzle a day, a streak, and stats per difficulty for puzzles cleared and times. Besides solving alone, two people can play head to head or together over Bluetooth.

The app is free with ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. For your first puzzle, see Getting Started with Sudoku365.

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play

Sudoku365Daily sudoku, alone or with two