← StudyX Devlog

Do You Need Maths for Sudoku? Numbers Used as Symbols

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperSudoku365How-To
Do You Need Maths for Sudoku? Numbers Used as Symbols

Suggest Sudoku to people and you sometimes hear, “That’s a number puzzle, and I was never good at maths.” A grid packed with digits does look a lot like an arithmetic worksheet.

But you never calculate anything in Sudoku. There is no adding, no subtracting, no multiplying. This post checks that claim a little more carefully, then looks at the kind of thinking Sudoku really asks for. The rules themselves are in Sudoku Rules: What First-Timers Need to Know.

Swap the digits for letters

The rule of Sudoku is that every row, every column and every 3×3 box contains 1 to 9 exactly once. Nothing in that rule depends on how big a number is. You never use the fact that 5 is more than 4, or that 3 and 6 make 9.

Try replacing 1 to 9 with the letters A to I. Say 1 is A, 2 is B, and so on, and rewrite every digit in the puzzle. The rule becomes “every row, column and box contains A to I exactly once”. It is exactly the same puzzle. The way you solve it and the shape of the answer don’t change.

Nine colours or nine pictures of fruit would work just as well. Digits are nine symbols everyone can tell apart at a glance, and they are quick to write. Here, a digit is just a name tag.

Finding the one that’s missing

Let’s check this with the most basic situation. Say a row has eight digits filled in and one empty cell:

3, blank, 7, 1, 9, 4, 6, 2, 8

The empty cell is 5. Finding that takes no calculation. Is there a 1? Yes. Is there a 2? Yes. Go through 1 to 9 in order, and 5 is the only one not there.

Write the same row in letters: C, blank, G, A, I, D, F, B, H. Go through A to I, and E is missing. It is the same job.

Since 1 to 9 adds up to 45, you could add the eight digits and subtract from 45. But that is the long way round. Checking which one is missing is faster, and harder to get wrong.

It is like taking a register. In a class of nine, you read down the list and look for the name nobody answers to. The core of Sudoku is doing that “who’s missing?” check over and over, across rows, columns and boxes.

What you really need is elimination

Further into a puzzle, the thinking stays the same.

Say you want to know where 7 goes in a box. If the box has four empty cells, any of them that shares a row or column with a 7 elsewhere is ruled out. Rule them out one by one, and if only one cell is left, that is where the 7 goes.

That is elimination: not here, not here, so it must be there. In everyday life it is like trying the keys on a ring of nine, setting each one aside when it doesn’t fit. You don’t need to calculate anything.

What Sudoku asks of you is something like this:

  • telling nine symbols apart
  • looking at each row, column and box without skipping any
  • keeping notes of what you have ruled out
  • waiting, rather than guessing, when nothing is certain yet

None of these has anything to do with being good or bad at arithmetic. The basic techniques are in How to Solve Sudoku, and how to keep notes is in How to Write Sudoku Pencil Marks.

So is it maths at all?

That isn’t to say Sudoku has nothing to do with mathematics. A finished Sudoku grid is a kind of table mathematicians call a Latin square, which Euler studied in the 18th century. That a puzzle needs at least 17 clues to have a single answer was also settled by mathematical research. I wrote about these in Sudoku vs Nanpure and Every Sudoku Has One Answer.

But that is maths about Sudoku, done by people who study it. Solving one asks for step-by-step reasoning. “This row already has a 5, so this cell isn’t 5” is closer to logic than to arithmetic.

When people say they are bad at maths, they may mean they struggle with calculation, or that they freeze up when they see an equation. Sudoku has neither. One view is that people who think of themselves as bad at maths sometimes find, through Sudoku, that careful step-by-step thinking was never the problem.

Some variants do use arithmetic

To be fair, some of Sudoku’s relatives do involve calculation.

The best known is Killer Sudoku. The grid is split into cages marked with dotted lines, each with a number in it. The extra rule is that the digits in a cage add up to that number. Here you really are adding.

Then there is KenKen, where each cage shows a target number and an operation such as addition or multiplication. According to English Wikipedia’s KenKen, it was invented in 2004 by a Japanese maths teacher, Tetsuya Miyamoto.

These are separate puzzles that add arithmetic rules on top of Sudoku. If a newspaper or an app just says “Sudoku”, there is no calculation in it. If maths isn’t your thing, you can start with plain Sudoku.

Starting with Sudoku365

Sudoku365 is a Sudoku app I make. It runs on iPhone, iPad and Android. It has 1,200 puzzles, 300 at each of four difficulty levels, and every puzzle has exactly one answer.

For someone who says they are bad at maths, there are three things worth pointing out.

First, you can start on Easy. Easy puzzles can be solved with the basic techniques only, the kind of elimination described above.

Second, the app does the counting. With “Hide placed number buttons” (on by default), a number’s button disappears once that number is on the board nine times, so you don’t have to count which numbers are used up. When you select a cell, the same row, column and box, and the cells with the same number, are highlighted, which also cuts down on missed cells.

Third, you find out about mistakes right away. A wrong number turns red as soon as you place it. A third mistake ends the game. You won’t get to the end only to find everything was off from an early error.

Notes are switched on with the NOTES button, and UNDO takes you back one step at a time. You start with 10 hints, and you get one more each time you clear a puzzle or watch an ad.

The app is free with ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. For your first puzzle, see Getting Started with Sudoku365.

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play

Sudoku365Daily sudoku, alone or with two