Two-Digit Long Multiplication: Where Children Go Wrong

In Japan, children learn to multiply two- and three-digit numbers by two-digit numbers in written columns in grade 3. The commentary on Japan’s elementary school curriculum guidelines for mathematics (MEXT, 2017, in Japanese) places it there, and in grade 2 children only meet simple cases of a two-digit number times a one-digit number.
Other countries reach the same point at different ages. England’s national curriculum has children multiply by a one-digit number using a formal written layout in Year 4, and use “long multiplication for two-digit numbers” in Year 5. In the United States, the Common Core standards for grade 4 have children multiply two two-digit numbers using strategies based on place value, and the grade 5 standards ask them to “fluently multiply multi-digit whole numbers using the standard algorithm”.
This post goes through the steps with one example, then the places where children tend to make mistakes.
The steps: split the second number by place
The MEXT commentary explains 23 × 45 by reading 45 as 40 + 5, and splitting the problem into 23 × 40 and 23 × 5. When the second number has one digit, the first number is split by place. When it has two digits, the second number is split by place. The written method is those two multiplications stacked up, then added.
Here is 37 × 58. 58 is 50 + 8.
3 7
× 5 8
_________
2 9 6 ← 37 × 8
1 8 5 ← 37 × 50
_________
2 1 4 6
First row: 37 × 8. 7 × 8 = 56. Write 6 in the ones place and carry 5. 3 × 8 = 24, plus the 5 makes 29. The first row is 296.
Second row: 37 × 5. 7 × 5 = 35. Write 5 and carry 3. 3 × 5 = 15, plus 3 makes 18. The second row is 185, and it starts in the tens place, one step to the left.
Add the rows. Ones: 6. Tens: 9 + 5 = 14, write 4 and carry 1. Hundreds: 2 + 8 + 1 = 11, write 1 and carry 1. Thousands: 1 + 1 = 2. The answer is 2146.
That is two multiplications and one addition, with times tables and carrying (also called regrouping) in all of them. A mistake can happen at any of those points.
Why the second row moves left
One common mistake is lining the second row up on the right, under the first.
3 7
× 5 8
_________
2 9 6
1 8 5
_________
4 8 1
This gives 481.
The 185 in the second row is not 37 × 5. It is 37 × 50, which is 1850, so it really ends in a 0. Moving it one place left does the same job as writing that 0.
So the shift is not just a rule of layout. The 5 is really 50. Asking a child “what is this 5 really worth?” is one way in. Another is to work out 37 × 50 on a separate line first, so the child sees the 0 at the end of 1850. If the rows keep drifting, squared paper with a small 0 written in the empty ones box is another option, covered in How to Reduce Calculation Mistakes.
Carries that get mixed up
If the 5 carried in the first row is written down small, it is still sitting there when the child works on the second row.
Adding that old 5 to 3 × 5 = 15 gives 20, so the second row becomes 205 and the answer becomes 296 + 2050 = 2346. The carry for the second row is the 3 from 7 × 5 = 35, which makes 18.
One way to avoid this is to cross out the first row’s carries before starting the second row. Another is to write the second row’s carries in a different place from the first row’s.
The final addition
Even with both multiplications right, the addition can go wrong. In 296 + 1850, forgetting both carries gives 1046.
How to teach carrying in column addition is in How to Teach Carrying and Borrowing.
Zeros
A zero in the middle of the first number needs care with carrying. Take 307 × 24.
For the first row, 307 × 4: 7 × 4 = 28, write 8 and carry 2. 0 × 4 = 0, plus the carried 2 makes 2. 3 × 4 = 12. The first row is 1228. A child who writes 0 for “zero times anything is zero” and forgets the carried 2 gets 1208 for the first row, and 7348 for the answer. The right answer is 1228 + 6140 = 7368.
Zero times four is zero, but the carry still has to be added after it.
Sometimes the ones digit of the second number is 0. The Japanese guidelines include multiplying by 0 in grade 3, and the commentary says this is used in problems such as 30 × 86 and 54 × 60. For 54 × 60, work out 54 × 6 = 324 and add a 0 at the end: 3240.
Checking with an estimate
The Japanese guidelines also ask that grade 3 touch on estimating the answer. The commentary gives the example that 19 × 6 is less than 120, because 20 × 6 is 120.
For 37 × 58, 40 × 60 = 2400, so the answer should be somewhere around 2000 to 2500. The unshifted 481 is out by a whole place value, so it stands out at once. The 1046 from the missed carries is less than half the estimate.
A small slip such as 2346 does not show up in an estimate. Estimating catches answers that are the wrong size. Small slips mean going back over each times table fact and each carry.
Children who do it in their heads
Some children work out the two-digit by one-digit parts in their heads.
The Japanese guidelines for grade 3 ask that simple calculations can be done mentally. The commentary says “simple” here means about as far as a two-digit number times a one-digit number, and that mental arithmetic should be put to use in written calculation and estimating.
A child who can say 37 × 8 = 296 without writing is within that range. With two two-digit numbers, though, the rows need to be written down, or there is no way to find out later where a mistake happened. Doing each row mentally and writing each row’s answer is one way to split it.
When the times tables are the problem
Looking closely at the mistakes sometimes shows a times table fact remembered wrong, such as 7 × 8 or 6 × 7. A two-digit by two-digit problem uses the tables four times. If the tables are shaky, going back to them comes first. That is in How to Learn Times Tables.
The MEXT commentary notes that what children learn in grade 3 multiplication is used again in grade 4 long division. That is in Long Division Steps.
How it is written in different countries
The steps are the same everywhere, but the layout varies. England’s Department for Education publishes Mathematics Appendix 1, a page of examples of formal written methods. Its long multiplication examples differ from the layout above in two ways.
- The 0 is written. For 124 × 26, the row for 124 × 20 is written as 2480, not 248 shifted left.
- The order of the rows can change. In its 24 × 16 example, 240 (24 × 10) comes first and 144 (24 × 6) second. Another 124 × 26 example puts 744 first and 2480 second.
The appendix also says the position of carried digits varies by method, and that some pupils write a plus sign when adding the rows. None of these change the answer. If a parent learned one layout and the school teaches another, following the school’s layout at home is simplest.
What you can do in MathCal
MathCal is an arithmetic drill app I make, where children write their answers by hand on the screen.
Long multiplication is practised in the Column Arithmetic Drill (Multiplication). In the settings, X digits and Y digits set the number of digits in each number, from 1 to 3, or you can choose Randomize digit count. For two two-digit numbers, set both to 2. The rows can be written freely on the grid on the problem screen. The answer goes in the boxes at the bottom, one digit per box, and when every box has been read, the child presses Check answer. Only the answer is marked.
To look at the steps themselves, there is the Column Multiplication lesson. Tapping through, the child multiplies a one- to three-digit number by a one-digit number from the ones place, adding the carries along the way. As I said in my developer interview, “I think it is good to turn understanding and practice together, like two wheels.” A child can see one row worked out in the lesson, then write two-digit problems in the drill.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. Other grade 3 arithmetic is listed in What Kids Learn in Arithmetic, Grade by Grade.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →