← StudyX Devlog

Songs You Can Play on Only the Black Keys: Fun with the Pentatonic Scale

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara ¡ DeveloperKinder PianoHow-To
Songs You Can Play on Only the Black Keys: Fun with the Pentatonic Scale

In every octave of a piano keyboard there are seven white keys and five black keys. Those five black keys alone give you do, re, mi, so and la: a pentatonic scale, which simply means a scale with five notes per octave. Wikipedia’s “Pentatonic scale” notes that the black keys make up a G-flat (or F-sharp) major pentatonic scale.

A pentatonic scale has almost no pairs of notes that grind against each other. So on the black keys alone, a child can press them in almost any order and it still sounds like music. In this post I write about songs that can be played on the black keys only, and about games for children who can’t read music yet. How the black keys are grouped and how to find C are in How to Find C on the Piano, which is a good companion to this one.

The five black keys are do, re, mi, so, la

The black keys come in groups of two and three. If you call the leftmost key of the group of three “do”, the rest fall into place:

  • do: left key of the three
  • re: middle key of the three
  • mi: right key of the three
  • so: left key of the two
  • la: right key of the two

The left key of the next group of three is do again, an octave higher.

In letter names, the left key of the three is F-sharp, so this is the major pentatonic scale starting on F-sharp. The same key is also G-flat, which is why you will also see it called G-flat pentatonic. There is no need to bother a child with letter names. “The left key of the three is do” is enough.

Why it rarely sounds wrong

Of the seven notes do, re, mi, fa, so, la, ti, two pairs are only a half step apart: mi and fa, and ti and do. Play two notes a half step apart together and you get a sharp, clashing sound.

The pentatonic scale leaves out fa and ti, the notes that make those half steps. Between any two neighbors in do, re, mi, so, la, the gap is a whole step or wider. In Japan the same scale is called the “yonanuki” scale, which means “without the fourth and seventh”.

With no half steps, pressing two or three black keys at once rarely gives a harsh clash. Even random notes come out sounding a little like a folk tune. Pentatonic scales turn up in folk music all over the world, from Scotland to China, Japan and West Africa.

Songs you can play on the black keys

All the songs here are old and in the public domain. A tune can be played on black keys only when its melody never uses fa or ti.

Three notes: Hot Cross Buns

This English nursery rhyme uses only mi, re and do. On the group of three, that is right, middle, left. It can serve as a very first song.

Four notes: Mary Had a Little Lamb

A 19th-century American song that uses do, re, mi and so. The opening “Mary had a little lamb” is right, middle, left, middle, right, right, right on the group of three. Only once, at “mi so so”, does the hand reach over to the left key of the group of two for so.

All five notes: Auld Lang Syne and Amazing Grace

The Scottish “Auld Lang Syne” and “Amazing Grace”, an 18th-century hymn text set to a 19th-century tune, are both well known as melodies built only from the pentatonic scale. They cover a wider range and dip down to the so and la below do, so they are a bit long for a small child, but they are good songs for a parent to play while the child listens.

The Flea Waltz

The Flea Waltz, known as “Flohwalzer” in Germany and “Neko Funjatta” (“I stepped on the cat”) in Japan, is an old piece by an unknown composer. It is famous for using a lot of black keys, but it is not black keys only. White keys turn up too. It can serve as a goal once the black keys feel familiar.

Chopin’s “Black Key” Étude

This one is for adults, but Chopin’s Étude Op. 10 No. 5 is called the “Black Key” Étude because the right hand plays almost nothing but black keys. Listening to a recording together is a nice way to show how much music those five keys can hold.

Songs that won’t work

“Twinkle, Twinkle, Little Star” uses fa in its second phrase, “How I wonder what you are”. On the black keys alone, one note is missing. Many other children’s songs also use fa. Finding a song that won’t work is a good way to see what the white keys are for.

Games that don’t need sheet music

Improvising together

The parent plays low notes, the left key of the three (do) and the left key of the two (so), slowly and over and over. On top of that the child presses any black keys higher up. Because it is a pentatonic scale, almost anything the child plays fits with the parent’s notes, and it feels like playing one piece together. Before learning any set song, this can build the feeling that “on the black keys, anything is fine”.

How to split the keyboard between parent and child is also covered in Piano Duets: How a Parent and Child Can Split the Parts.

Copy me

The parent plays two or three black keys, and the child plays them back in the same order. With only five notes, they are easy for a child to find. Later the child can be the one who sets the puzzle.

A hand shape

Black keys are higher and narrower than white keys, so the fingers have to stand up a little to press them. Pressing the group of two with the index and middle fingers, and the group of three with the index, middle and ring fingers together, is also practice at moving fingers as a unit.

From black keys to white keys

Black-key play fits the time before a child reads music, because the keyboard can be learned by the shapes of the groups without knowing any note names.

When it is time for the white keys, the link “C is just left of the two black keys” carries the black-key games straight over. A child who can play “Mary Had a Little Lamb” on the black keys can try it on the white keys as E, D, C, D, E, E, E and hear that it is the same song at a different height. That is a first step toward the idea of transposing.

In free play

Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of primary school. I made it for my 4-year-old daughter.

For black-key games, Free play, opened from the song selection screen, is the right place. The child can play freely with a grand piano sound, and the name of the chord being held appears on screen. Pressing two or three black keys together and seeing what the chord is called is a game in itself. The record button keeps a record of the keys played, not a microphone recording, and plays it back with the built-in piano sound.

On the practice screen, the app follows real sheet music with treble and bass clefs, highlights the next note, shows the finger number and lights up the key to press. The nursery songs include “Mary Had a Little Lamb” and the Flea Waltz, listed as “Flohwalzer (Cat Walk)”. Bluetooth and USB MIDI keyboards can be connected too.

All 21 nursery songs are free, the first classical piece and the first ear training level are free, and free play and MIDI connection are free too. A one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.

Starting to read music is covered in How Kids Learn to Read Sheet Music, and finger numbers in Piano Finger Numbers.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PianoA first piano for little hands