Ear Training at Home for Kids: Listen, Echo, Compare

In a 2015 study, Steven Demorest and Peter Pfordresher compared 77 American kindergartners, 55 sixth graders and 78 college students who heard pitches and sang them back. Across the three tasks, the share of sung notes more than half a semitone off was about 49% for the kindergartners, 21% for the sixth graders and 42% for the college students.
The college students were closer to the kindergartners than to the sixth graders. These were separate groups measured at different times, not the same people followed over the years. Even so, the authors suggest that singing accuracy may have more to do with singing experience than with general development, and that it could decline when it is not used.
If this is a skill tied to experience, there is a lot a family can do at home. This post covers games that need no special materials, grouped into three kinds: listening, echoing and comparing.
Ear training here means hearing how notes relate to each other. Perfect pitch is a separate subject, covered in Perfect Pitch and Relative Pitch.
Listening: noticing high and low
The first game needs only a voice and a hand. As you slide your voice up on “ah,” raise your hand. As you slide down, lower it. Your child does the same.
A lesson from Oak National Academy, the UK’s public classroom resource, also uses actions like this, on the grounds that they help children feel how the melody moves.
Loud and high are two different things. If your child calls a loud sound “high,” sing a high note and a low note at the same volume and listen together.
If you have a keyboard, start with a very low note and a very high one. With eyes closed, your child points up or down to answer. Then bring the two notes closer. Once C and G are easy, try C and E, then C and D. The closer they are, the harder it gets.
Echoing: singing short phrases back
Next is echo singing. You sing a short phrase, and your child sings it back.
Two notes are enough at first, like a singsong “yoo-hoo.” Moving between a high note and a low note already sounds like a song. You can also sing everyday calls, like “dinner’s ready,” and have your child sing the answer. The Oak lesson also names singing questions and answers on the same melody as a good way to practice matching pitch.
The thing to watch here is the height of the adult’s voice.
In a study by Georgia Green, 282 children in grades 1 to 6 matched pitches sung by an adult woman, an adult man and a child. They got the most correct with the child’s voice, then the woman’s, and the fewest with the man’s.
A paper by Janice Killian and Jeremy Buckner also reviews earlier work in which adults started songs lower than children did. It notes that some textbooks give a child’s suitable range as the D above middle C up to an octave higher.
At home, some ways to work with this:
- Copy the pitch your child is already singing, and sing it back.
- Start a little higher than is comfortable for you.
- When your child struggles to match your voice, play the notes on a keyboard.
Comparing: the same or different?
The third kind of game compares two notes or two melodies.
- Same or different. Play two notes in a row, and your child says whether they are the same.
- Up or down. Use the same two notes, but ask about direction. Pointing up or down works for a child who doesn’t have many words yet.
- Make a mistake on purpose. Sing the start of “Twinkle, Twinkle” as Do Do So So La La “Fa.” If your child notices and laughs, that is already hearing the difference. The better a child knows the song, the better this works. The song’s history is in Where Twinkle, Twinkle Comes From.
- Change the height. Sing the same song high and then low, and notice that it is still the same song.
With a keyboard, you can also play a search game. Play C, then another note, and your child looks for that note. A clue like “it was above C” is fine. Finding C is covered in How to Find C on the Piano. Picking out the first few notes of a familiar song by ear is the same game, just continued.
Keeping it going
Short, and on the side. These games need no set practice time. One song in the bath, or two or three questions while waiting for dinner, is enough.
Listening over getting it right. After a wrong answer, play it again and listen together. Hearing the sound again suits the purpose of the game better than being told the answer.
Don’t say “tone deaf.” The paper at the top cites research showing that this label can seriously damage how children see themselves musically, and that adults can vividly remember such experiences. The Oak lesson also lists “if I can’t match the pitch, it means I am a bad singer” as a misconception, and says matching pitch is a skill that improves with practice. If your child is off, keep singing together.
If you don’t sing well yourself. In a Northwestern article, Demorest points out that nobody expects a beginner on violin to sound good right away, yet everyone is supposed to be able to sing. You can do all of this without confidence in your own pitch. Let a keyboard or an app give the notes, and you guess along with your child.
Stop on days your child doesn’t want to. Singing and rhythm games are also in What to Do at Home Before Piano Lessons Start.
The ear games in Kinder Piano
The Ear tab in Kinder Piano has nine levels of ear training games. The three kinds of game above match what is in them.
- Listening. Press the key that matches the note you hear. It starts with C, E and G, then widens to the five notes from C to G, then a full octave.
- Echoing. Play back two or three notes you heard, in the same order.
- Comparing. After a starting C, find the note that follows. You can press the C key as often as you like, so you can compare as you search.
The final levels ask you to pick out notes played together as a chord. On every level, “Listen again” plays the question as many times as you need, and the keys you press sound too. After a wrong note, you just listen again and press again. As with the games at home, a few questions at a time is fine.
Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.
The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.
Kinder PianoA first piano for little handsSee the app →