← StudyX Devlog

Minuet in G Was Not Written by Bach

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperKinder PianoHow-To
Minuet in G Was Not Written by Bach

The Minuet in G often called “Bach’s Minuet” carries the number BWV Anh. 114. BWV is the catalogue of Bach’s works, and Anh. stands for Anhang, the appendix. The piece sits in the appendix, not in the main catalogue.

Its composer was Christian Petzold, court organist in Dresden. The evidence was published by the Leipzig Bach scholar Hans-Joachim Schulze in an article in the Bach-Jahrbuch for 1979, written in German. This post goes through what that article says.

The 1725 notebook

The minuet is copied into the second notebook for Anna Magdalena Bach, Bach’s second wife. The year 1725 is stamped on its cover. Schulze notes that older scholarship read that year as the point by which the entries were finished, while since Georg von Dadelsen’s work it has been read as the point at which they began.

The notebook holds a number of short keyboard pieces with no composer named. Schulze writes that for about a dozen of the best known, the real composer had still not been identified, and that Bach himself is now ruled out as their author. The Minuet in G and the G minor minuet that follows it (BWV Anh. 115) were among them.

A minuet inside a harpsichord suite

The answer came from a manuscript collection of keyboard music from Saxony. Its title page names Heinrich Raphael Krause, along with Johann Benjamin Tzschirich, who owned and copied it, and the year 1726. The musicologist Max Seiffert mentioned the manuscript in 1904, after which it could no longer be traced. It turned up again a few years before Schulze’s article.

Near the end, among the latest entries, is a “Suite de Clavecin par C. Pezold.” Schulze dates the entry to around 1735 or 1736, and no other copy of the suite seems to be known.

The suite runs Prelude, Allemande, Courante, Sarabande, Bourrée, Menuet, Menuet 2, Gigue, and Passepied with Trio. The opening bars printed in the article show the first minuet in G major, 16 bars plus 16 bars. The second minuet is in G minor and ends with “On reprend le premier Menuet,” go back to the first minuet.

These were the two minuets from the notebook. In Schulze’s words: according to this source, the minuet pair BWV Anh. 114/115, among the best known pieces in all of music, was taken from a harpsichord suite by the Dresden court organist Christian Petzold.

The idea that the two belonged together was not new. Dadelsen had suggested it in his critical report for the New Bach Edition, and Schulze notes that this now proved correct. He adds that comparing Petzold’s other keyboard works gave no reason to doubt that the suite is his.

Who Petzold was

According to the biography in the article, Petzold was born in Weißig in Saxony in 1677 and baptized in Königstein on 1 January 1678. He appears as organist of the Sophienkirche in Dresden in 1697, and in 1709 the court budget lists him as “Kammercompositeur und Organist,” chamber composer and organist.

He died in May 1733. One of the applicants for his post was Bach’s eldest son, Wilhelm Friedemann Bach. The letter of application, dated 7 June 1733, was written by his father. Friedemann passed the audition and held the post until 1746.

When did the minuets enter the notebook?

In the notebook the two minuets are numbers 4 and 5. Schulze cites the critical report’s view that the numbering appears to follow the order in which the pieces were entered.

He then sets out a scenario, built on several assumptions. The notebook was begun in the second half of 1725, as a gift for Anna Magdalena’s birthday (22 September) or their wedding anniversary (3 December). That September Bach played the organ in Dresden, and Petzold gladly gave up his place at the newest and finest organ in the city. The minuets would then be a keepsake from that trip. The article presents this as a line of thought resting on assumptions, not as an established fact.

The copies of the two minuets in the notebook are in Anna Magdalena’s hand.

How the opening plays

What follows comes from the opening bars printed in the article. The piece is in triple time.

The right hand holds D for one beat, climbs G, A, B, C in eighth notes, then plays D, G, G in the next bar. The first two bars stay within the five white keys from G up to D. In bar 3 the hand plays E, then runs from C up to F sharp, reaching the high G in bar 4. That is where the first black key appears and the hand has to move.

From bar 2 to bar 5 the left hand holds one long note per bar: B, C, B, A. While the right hand moves in eighth notes, the left hand stays down.

The order for putting the hands together is in Playing Piano Hands Together, and hand shape in Piano Hand Position and Posture. Another piece with an unsettled backstory is covered in The Story of Für Elise.

Source

  • Schulze, Hans-Joachim (1980). Ein „Dresdner Menuett“ im zweiten Klavierbüchlein der Anna Magdalena Bach. Nebst Hinweisen zur Überlieferung einiger Kammermusikwerke Bachs. Bach-Jahrbuch 65 (1979), pp. 45-64.

Minuet in G in Kinder Piano

Kinder Piano has the Minuet in G among its classical pieces, with Petzold named as the composer on the song card. It is marked Hard and runs the full 32 bars.

You can choose the melody, the accompaniment, or both hands. In Slow mode the app waits for each key, so a child can check the F sharp one note at a time. Rhythm mode then has the child play along with a moving score.

Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces, including the Minuet in G, and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.

The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PianoA first piano for little hands