When Rhythm Is Hard for Your Child: Practicing Piano in Time

A piano score tells you two things: which key to press, and when to press it. When a child plays the right notes and it still does not sound like the song, it is usually the second part that has gone wrong.
This post is about that second part: what research has found about children and the beat, and some ways to practice playing in time at home. How to teach the note values themselves is in Teaching Note Values to Kids. Here the subject is keeping a steady speed through a piece.
What happens when the rhythm falls apart
The beat keeps going even when the player stops. While a child looks for the next key or checks a finger number, the beat does not wait. In the stage where each note is found one at a time, the gaps between notes stretch and shrink with the time spent searching.
There are other ways it comes apart. A half note or whole note gets released early. A rest feels like the end of the piece, and the child stops. The familiar bars speed up. In each case the keys come in the right order, but at the wrong moments.
Young children’s natural tempo is fast
Some studies have looked at how children’s ability to tap along with a beat changes with age.
A study by Drake, Jones and Baruch, published in Cognition in 2000, compared children aged 4, 6, 8 and 10 with adults. The tasks included tapping freely at a comfortable speed and tapping along with simple sequences and with music. With age and musical training, free tapping became slower, synchronizing became more accurate, and the range of speeds people could tap at widened toward the slower end.
A study by McAuley and colleagues in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General in 2006 tested 305 people aged 4 to 95. Preferred tapping speed slowed with age. The range of speeds at which people could keep time well was narrower in childhood and in late adulthood than in the years between.
Put together, the range of speeds a young child can follow is narrower than an adult’s, and it sits toward the fast end.
Keeping a beat is easier with a person
Another study found that who you play with makes a difference.
In a 2009 study by Kirschner and Tomasello in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 36 children aged 2½, 3½ and 4½ drummed along with one of three partners: a person drumming with them, a drumming machine, or a drum sound from a speaker. With a person, even 2½-year-olds adjusted their drumming to a beat outside the range of their own natural tempo. At every age, children drummed in time more accurately with a person than in the other two conditions.
Ways to practice at home
What follows is one way to go about it.
Clap before you play
Before playing a piece, the child can clap just its rhythm. Without pitch to think about, all the attention goes to when each note sounds. Saying the note values out loud while clapping is covered in Teaching Note Values to Kids.
In line with the study above, one way to start is for a parent to sit facing the child and clap together. Another is for the parent to sing the melody while the child claps along.
A person’s beat before the metronome
A metronome keeps a perfectly even beat. In the study above, though, children kept time better with a person than with a machine. One approach is to begin with a parent counting “1, 2, 3, 4” or clapping beside the child, and move to the metronome once that feels steady.
Choosing the speed
Slowing down is one way to practice. Both of the tempo studies above found, though, that the range of speeds children can follow is narrower than adults’, and widens toward the slow end only with age. Some see this as a reason not to slow down too far, since a very slow beat can be harder for a young child to feel. In practice that means watching whether the child is with the beat and adjusting the speed a little at a time.
Keep going past mistakes
If a child stops to fix a wrong note, the beat breaks at that point. One method is to agree that during rhythm practice only, a mistake does not stop the music: the next note comes on the next beat. Getting each pitch right is practiced at a different time, one note at a time. The idea is to keep practice for pitch and practice for keeping the beat separate.
Work in short sections
If the rhythm always breaks at the same place, another method is to take only the bar or two around it and build back up: clapping, then one hand, then both hands. Breaking a two-hand passage into pieces is covered in Playing Piano Hands Together, and splitting the parts with a parent in Piano Duets: How a Parent and Child Can Split the Parts.
Sources
- Drake, C., Jones, M. R., & Baruch, C. (2000). The development of rhythmic attending in auditory sequences. Cognition.
- McAuley, J. D., Jones, M. R., Holub, S., Johnston, H. M., & Miller, N. S. (2006). The time of our lives: Life span development of timing and event tracking. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General.
- Kirschner, S., & Tomasello, M. (2009). Joint drumming: Social context facilitates synchronization in preschool children. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology.
Playing in Rhythm mode in Kinder Piano
In Kinder Piano, after choosing a song the app asks “How will you practice?” and offers Slow and Rhythm. Slow waits until the right key is pressed. In Rhythm, the child plays along with a moving score. Four soft count-in clicks sound first, and then the score keeps moving without stopping.
In Rhythm mode, if you choose Melody or Accompaniment, the app plays the other part. The child plays one hand and hears the other part to keep the beat. At the end the app shows how many of the notes were played on the beat. The Demo plays at the same tempo as Rhythm mode, so the child can clap along with it before playing. When to move from Slow to Rhythm is covered in Practical Tips for Using Kinder Piano Every Day.
Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.
The path to the first song is in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.
Kinder PianoA first piano for little handsSee the app →