Does a Black Drawing Show a Child's Feelings? What Research on Color Has Found

A research group at the University of Otago in New Zealand published a paper on color and feeling in childrenās drawings in Infant and Child Development (2012). Children aged 3 to 10 drew pictures about their own happy and sad experiences. Children in hospital drew about being worried or scared there, and about their positive experiences.
Hospitalized or not, and whether the event was good or bad, the children primarily used colors they preferred. The authors concluded that clinicians should exercise extreme caution when interpreting the meaning of color in childrenās drawings.
Is the black in a childās drawing a sign of how the child feels? This post goes through what studies of color and feeling have found.
A long habit of reading feelings into color
Clinicians and art therapists have often linked the colors in childrenās drawings to feelings. In a 2004 paper, the British researcher Esther Burkitt and her colleagues pointed out that these claims are usually based on professional observation and not on formal experiments. The problems they list are that the childrenās feelings were usually not checked independently, rigorous controls were typically missing, and ad hoc selections of drawings were often used as evidence.
Children choose black for ānastyā figures
In a 2003 experiment, Burkittās group worked with 330 children aged 4 to 11. The children rated and ranked ten colors. In another session they colored in three identical outlines of a man, a dog or a tree. One was described neutrally, one as nice and one as nasty.
In all age groups and for all topics, children used colors they preferred for the nice figure and colors they preferred least for the nasty one. Black tended to be the most frequently chosen color for the nasty figure. Primary colors were mostly chosen for the neutral figure, and a wide range of mainly primary and secondary colors for the nice one.
In a 2004 experiment, 253 children aged 4 to 11 drew the figures themselves instead of coloring outlines. The same pattern appeared. Black was the color most closely tied to nasty figures, along with brown and white. The authors suggest that using a disliked color is most likely a way of communicating dislike.
A 2009 study of 1,307 primary school children in Lithuania, aged 6 to 12, found the strongest links between yellow and nice figures and between black and nasty figures. Boys and girls alike named black as their least liked color. Color choice was also related to the childrenās own preferences, and the authors say color should be interpreted with caution in psychological assessment.
What these experiments can and cannot say
These experiments show that even young children can use color symbolically. Burkittās 2004 paper says that the color used for an object in a drawing may indicate what that object means to the child.
But what was tested is a child drawing something an adult has described as nasty. In the 2004 experiment, each drawing could use only one color. The authors themselves urge caution about practical use, since the topics and the drawing conditions were restricted, and they call for further research on topics closer to childrenās lives, such as family members, and on naturally emotional topics.
These studies did not look at the mood of children who habitually draw in black.
Drawing their own experiences, children use favorite colors
The Otago study at the top of this post goes a step further.
When coloring outlines, children used more preferred colors for the nice figure. They were more likely to use non-preferred colors for the nasty one, but tended to use a mix of both.
With free drawings about their own experiences, the result was different. There was no relation between color choices and color preferences, and children primarily used preferred colors. That held for hospitalized children drawing about being worried or scared as well.
What the reviews say
Some reviews have looked more broadly. In 1998, the British researchers Thomas and Jolley published a review of the grounds for evaluating children psychologically from their drawings.
The review found drawings inaccurate and unreliable as assessments of personality or state. Drawings can be influenced by childrenās feelings about what they depict, but the form this takes may be personal and idiosyncratic, and at best the reported effects are small. A given feature can support several very different interpretations. The conclusion is that childrenās drawings on their own are too ambiguous to be reliable sole indicators of a childās emotional experiences.
In 2000, Lilienfeld and colleagues published a review of projective tests. It found that most indexes from the Rorschach and the Thematic Apperception Test lack empirical support, and that the validity evidence for human figure drawings is even more limited.
Summary
Here is what these studies show:
- Children tend to choose black when drawing something described as nasty
- A childās own color preferences are part of how colors get chosen
- Children drawing their own hard experiences still mainly used preferred colors
- A drawing on its own is not a reliable indicator of a childās feelings
For more on color and drawing, see At What Age Do Kids Learn Color Names? and Stages of Drawing in Young Children.
Sources
- Crawford, E., Gross, J., Patterson, T., Hayne, H. (2012). āDoes Childrenās Colour Use Reflect the Emotional Content of their Drawings?ā Infant and Child Development 21(2)
- Burkitt, E., Barrett, M., Davis, A. (2003). āChildrenās colour choices for completing drawings of affectively characterised topics.ā Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 44(3)
- Burkitt, E., Barrett, M., Davis, A. (2004). āThe effect of affective characterizations on the use of size and colour in drawings produced by children in the absence of a model.ā Educational Psychology 24(3)
- PranckeviÄienÄ, A., ŽardeckaitÄ-MatulaitienÄ, K., SoikinaitÄ, I. (2009). āChildrenās color preferences and color choices for completing drawings of human figures in primary school.ā Psichologija 39
- Thomas, G. V., Jolley, R. P. (1998). āDrawing conclusions: A re-examination of empirical and conceptual bases for psychological evaluation of children from their drawings.ā British Journal of Clinical Psychology 37
- Lilienfeld, S. O., Wood, J. M., Garb, H. N. (2000). āThe Scientific Status of Projective Techniques.ā Psychological Science in the Public Interest 1(2)
Color in Kinder Paint
Kinder Paint is a drawing app for iPhone and iPad, made for children ages 2 to 6 under the supervision of an AMI Montessori teacher.
The line color is black by default. There are 48 colors across three palettes, and you can add colors of your own. On the Sketch canvas, you choose pencil hardness instead of a color. Artwork saves to your photos.
The basic drawing features are free, and the free plan saves up to three canvases. The Manga and Dot canvases, the Paint Academy tracing lessons and unlimited canvases come with the paid Kinder Paint Pro. There are no ads and no account. For a first session, see Getting Started with Kinder Paint.
Kinder PaintCreative drawing for kidsSee the app ā