← StudyX Devlog

Crayons, Colored Pencils or Markers: Choosing a Young Child's First Art Supplies

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperKinder PaintHow-To
Crayons, Colored Pencils or Markers: Choosing a Young Child's First Art Supplies

Crayons, colored pencils and water-based markers all put color on paper, but from a young child’s hand they are quite different. The biggest difference is how much pressure it takes to get color out.

A crayon leaves color with a light rub. A marker makes a line as soon as it touches the paper. A colored pencil gives only a pale line unless you press fairly hard. For a child whose hands are still weak, that difference is not small.

In this post I go through how the three differ, roughly when each becomes easy to use, and what to check when choosing them. I don’t name particular products, only the types.

Crayons

Crayons are wax or oil formed into a stick with pigment. Many are thick and hard to break, and a child can draw while gripping one with the whole hand.

  • Good points: Color comes out with little pressure. They are good at filling large areas, and colors can be layered on the paper.
  • Drawbacks: Fine lines are hard. Color gets on hands, tables and clothes, and broken pieces turn up.

Oil pastels, which are softer and spread more easily, are also sold for children. Pastels are better for spreading color and crayons for drawing lines. For a first set, either is fine.

Colored pencils

Colored pencils are a thin core wrapped in wood or paper.

  • Good points: They draw fine lines. They don’t dirty hands or clothes much, and they are easy to carry.
  • Drawbacks: Strong color takes pressure. The core breaks easily and needs sharpening. The tip is pointed, so use them where an adult can see.

To use colored pencils well, a child needs to hold them with the fingertips, the same way as a pencil. While the child still grips with the whole hand, it is hard to get the color they want.

Water-based markers

These are felt-tip pens and markers with water-based ink.

  • Good points: A clear, bright line appears just by touching the paper. Even a child with little strength can see their own line.
  • Drawbacks: The cap needs handling. Pressing hard flattens the tip, and without the cap they dry out quickly. Ink can soak through the paper onto the table.

If you are worried about clothes, markers labeled “washable” make life easier.

Rough ages

There is no fixed age for any of these. What follows is a guide based on hand strength and grip.

  • From about 18 months to 2 years: thick crayons. When a child grips with the whole hand and scribbles, choose something that gives color with little pressure.
  • From about 2 to 3: add markers. It helps if an adult keeps the caps and takes them off only for drawing.
  • From about 3 to 4: add colored pencils. Once the grip moves toward the fingertips, children can enjoy drawing fine lines.

There is no need to choose only one. You can start with crayons and add materials as you watch the child’s hands develop. I wrote about getting ready at age two in Drawing with a 2-Year-Old, and about how grip develops in How to Teach Pencil Grip.

Thickness and grip

For young children, thicker materials are easier to hold. Triangular barrels split the fingers naturally across three sides, which is also good practice for grip.

On the other hand, if the barrel is too thick, moving to a fingertip grip can be harder. You can start with thick ones and switch to normal thickness as the child begins to hold with the fingertips.

Labels worth checking

I wrote about safety in more detail in Drawing with a 2-Year-Old, so here are only the main points.

  • Age range and warnings. Read the age range on the package and warnings such as not putting the item in the mouth.
  • Caps. The international standard ISO 11540 aims to reduce the risk of choking on pen caps. Caps that meet it let air pass through, but with young children the surest way is for an adult to keep the caps.
  • Ingredient review. ACMI, the US art materials trade association, puts an “AP” seal on materials that a toxicologist has reviewed, and ACMI’s guidance recommends checking for this seal on art supplies for children in sixth grade or younger. Many products sold outside the US don’t carry it, so read it together with the other labels and warnings.

How Kinder Paint’s brushes differ from the real thing

Kinder Paint is a drawing app for iPhone and iPad for children aged 2 to 6. Its pens come in six kinds, including Crayon, Pencil and Watercolor Pen, and each has its own texture.

With an Apple Pencil, the crayon gets darker the harder you press, and the pencil changes both width and darkness. The lines look close to real materials, but the differences are clear.

  • There is no grain of paper and no drag of a crayon catching on it.
  • No pressure is needed to get color. A finger works too.
  • Hands and clothes stay clean, and undo lets the child redraw as many times as they like.

There is a view that paper and real materials are better for building hand strength and fingertip control. The app is useful for trying colors without worrying about mess, or for drawing when you are out. I wrote about dividing the two in Drawing Apps vs Paper.

The basic drawing features are free, and the free plan saves up to three canvases. The Manga and Dot canvases and the Paint Academy tracing lessons come with the paid Kinder Paint Pro. There are no ads and no account.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PaintCreative drawing for kids