← StudyX Devlog

Do Coloring Books Hurt Children's Creativity?

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara Ā· DeveloperKinder PaintHow-To
Do Coloring Books Hurt Children's Creativity?

The claim that coloring books are bad for children’s creativity is usually traced to Creative and Mental Growth, published in 1947 by Viktor Lowenfeld, an art educator at Penn State. According to an NPR article, the book says there is general agreement that coloring books are harmful to children’s creative expression. The reason given is that depending on someone else’s outlines makes children less confident in their own drawing.

Nearly 80 years later, some parents still wonder whether coloring books are all right. In this post I go through what is said about coloring and creativity.

What the criticism says

The example most often quoted from Lowenfeld’s book is about birds. As NPR describes it, the book shows children’s own drawings of birds, each one different, and then drawings made after the children had seen coloring-book birds, when many of them drew the same simple V-shaped bird.

Melody Milbrandt, an art educator at Georgia State University quoted in the same article, says coloring books make the key decisions for the child. Her concern is that children absorb stock symbols, such as a sun drawn as a yellow ball with rays in the corner.

What research shows

Lowenfeld’s bird example, however, is an observation shown in a book, not an experiment that compared children under controlled conditions. A search did not turn up any controlled experiment showing that coloring books lower children’s creativity.

There is research on coloring and mood, though. In a 2019 study, Carsley and Heath of McGill University worked with 152 schoolchildren with an average age of about 10. Before a spelling test, one group colored a set design and the other drew or colored freely. Test anxiety went down in both groups. Coloring did not come out as uniquely helpful.

With adults, the results look a little different. In a 2005 study by Nancy Curry and Tim Kasser of Knox College, students were split into three groups: coloring a mandala, coloring a plaid pattern, and drawing freely on a blank sheet. According to the college’s news article, after 20 minutes anxiety fell clearly in the mandala group, fell somewhat in the plaid group, and did not fall in the free drawing group. A set form may have a calming side. But that was a study of adults, and in the children’s study above, free drawing lowered anxiety too.

So research cannot yet say clearly either that coloring books lower creativity or that they are especially good.

Coloring and free drawing are different activities

One view is that neither is better than the other, and that they are different activities.

In a coloring book, the shapes are already decided. The child decides which colors to use and how carefully to fill them in. Moving your hand so you stay inside the lines, and finishing the whole page, have their own satisfactions.

In free drawing, the child decides everything, starting with what to draw and what shape it takes. Even if an adult cannot tell what it is, the child made those choices. As I wrote in Stages of Drawing in Young Children, the process by which shapes grow out of scribbles happens in free drawing.

Milbrandt puts it this way: coloring is not bad in itself, but the time spent on it is time not spent on other things.

Finding a balance

Here are some things to consider when a child seems to do nothing but coloring books.

  • There is no need to take coloring books away. If the child enjoys them, that is valuable time.
  • Keep blank paper within reach too. Just having empty paper next to the coloring book lets the child choose.
  • Leave room to draw beyond the page. Tell them it is fine to add a background around the picture, or a friend for the animal in it.
  • Let the child choose the colors. The sky does not have to be blue, nor the leaves green. A purple sky is the color that child chose.
  • Do not point out where it differs from the model. Talk about the colors they chose rather than about going outside the lines. I wrote about what to say in How to Praise a Child’s Drawing.

Some days filling in someone else’s lines, some days drawing on blank paper. Some would say that is about right.

In Kinder Paint

Kinder Paint, which I make, is a drawing app for iPhone and iPad for children aged 2 to 6. It mostly starts from a blank canvas.

It is not a coloring book of finished pictures, but a child can make their own coloring page. Draw a circle, square or triangle with the shape tools, then tap inside with the fill tool to color it in. The child decides both the shapes and the colors.

Paint Academy, which comes with the paid Kinder Paint Pro, is a set of lessons in tracing a model line. The child draws the line itself rather than filling in between lines, so it is something different from a coloring book.

The basic drawing features are free, and the free plan saves up to three canvases. There are no ads and no account.

How Kinder Paint compares with other ways to draw, including coloring apps, is in Kinder Paint vs Other Ways for Young Kids to Draw, and drawing with a Halloween theme is in Halloween Drawing with Kids.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PaintCreative drawing for kids