← StudyX Devlog

When Your Child Asks You to Draw for Them: Is It OK for Parents to Draw?

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara ¡ DeveloperKinder PaintHow-To
When Your Child Asks You to Draw for Them: Is It OK for Parents to Draw?

In 2003, the developmental psychology journal Merrill-Palmer Quarterly published a study of mothers and children drawing together (Braswell and Callanan). Thirty-two children aged four and five took turns with their mothers drawing farm animals, and each tried to guess what the other had drawn.

Over the course of the game, the children’s drawings became easier to recognize. The children borrowed features such as ears and tails from their mothers’ drawings and put them into their own. This was clearest in the children whose drawings had been the most rudimentary at the start. What went along with the improvement was talk between mother and child about the features that tell one animal from another.

When a child says “Draw it for me,” some parents aren’t sure whether to draw or to encourage the child to do it alone. This post looks at that question, and at how to draw for a child when you do.

Is it fine to draw for them?

There is a view that if your child asks, it is fine to draw for them.

There is also the view that adults should keep their hands off children’s art. Viktor Lowenfeld, the art educator who wrote Creative and Mental Growth in 1947, was wary of adults imposing their own forms on children. I wrote about the debate over coloring books in Do Coloring Books Hurt Children’s Creativity?

On the other side, the art education researcher Brent Wilson has argued that children’s drawing develops through cultural influence and instruction. In a 2004 essay he questioned the long-held assumption in art education that child art unfolds naturally and that outside influences should be avoided. In his view, children learn to draw by borrowing from the pictures around them, including the ones adults draw.

The study above fits this view. The children watched their mothers draw and took ideas from them. Drawing for a child can also hand them one more piece of material to draw with.

When a child says “Draw it for me”

A child might ask for a drawing for several reasons.

  • They want to see how. They want to know how to draw a shape they can’t manage yet.
  • They want to play together. Doing the same thing side by side matters more than the picture.
  • They want the picture. They want a drawing of a favorite animal or vehicle to keep.

You can often tell which one it is by watching the child while you draw. If they watch your hand closely, they probably want to see how. If they take the finished picture straight away, they probably wanted the picture.

What to watch for when you draw

Draw on your own paper, not theirs. Avoid adding to a drawing your child is working on unless they ask. Take a separate sheet for yourself. If they ask you to draw on their paper, let them decide where.

Let them see you draw. Let a child watch your hand move rather than handing over a finished picture. Draw slowly and put the shapes into words: “A big circle, then two small circles on top. These are the ears.” In the study, too, the drawings improved when parent and child talked about the features that make an animal recognizable.

You don’t have to draw well. A detailed adult drawing gives a child nothing they can copy. Circles, lines and triangles, shapes a child can draw too, are easier for them to bring into their own pictures.

Don’t compare. When your drawing sits next to your child’s, it is tempting to say, “Look, this is how you do it.” You do not need to ask a child to draw it your way. What a child takes from your drawing is up to them. How to respond to their drawings is covered in How to Praise a Child’s Drawing.

Ways to draw together

Between drawing for your child and leaving them to draw alone, there are a few things in between.

Take turns. As in the study, each of you draws something and the other guesses what it is. If the guess is wrong, talk about it: “What could we add so it’s easier to tell?” Long ears make a rabbit, a long neck makes a giraffe. You can look for the shapes that tell things apart as part of the game.

Add to each other’s drawing. You draw a circle, your child adds eyes, you add ears, your child adds legs. One picture grows a turn at a time. If you lose track of whose line is whose, that is fine.

Stop halfway. Draw just a face, then hand it over: “What should the body be?” Leaving part of the picture undone gives the child somewhere to carry on.

Draw the same thing side by side. You and your child each draw the same thing on your own paper. When you are done, just put the two side by side and look. They will be different, and that is as it should be.

For a two-year-old, it is enough for an adult to draw circles and lines alongside them. Ways to join in at each age are in Drawing with a 2-Year-Old and Stages of Drawing in Young Children.

Montessori: show, then step back

In Montessori education, when an adult shows a child how to use something, the emphasis is on demonstrating the movement slowly and clearly rather than explaining it in words. After the demonstration, the child takes over. Once they start, the adult watches without stepping in too much.

This approach can also be used when a child asks for a drawing.

  • When you show, go slowly and keep the words few. Draw so that your hand can be seen.
  • When you have shown, give the pen back. Ask, “Do you want to try?” If the answer is no, that is fine.
  • Don’t correct the child’s lines. Even if they go outside the lines or the shape comes out different, those lines belong to the child.

Drawing for a child and letting them draw are not always a choice between two options. The adult shows, the child tries, and the two can go back and forth.

When they ask every time

Some children go through a phase of asking you to draw everything and not drawing themselves. You do not need to refuse. Instead of drawing the whole thing, use the “stop halfway” approach more and more.

A child who says “I can’t draw it” may be worried about not drawing well. A very polished adult drawing can make that worry stronger. Seeing an adult draw badly and enjoy it is more reassuring for a child. If a child doesn’t want to draw at all, see When a Child Doesn’t Want to Draw.

Sources

  • Braswell, G. S., and Callanan, M. A. (2003). “Learning to Draw Recognizable Graphic Representations During Mother-Child Interactions.” Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 49(4).
  • Wilson, B. (2004). “Child Art After Modernism: Visual Culture and New Narratives.” In E. W. Eisner and M. D. Day (eds.), Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education.
  • Lowenfeld, V. (1947). Creative and Mental Growth.

Taking turns in Kinder Paint

Kinder Paint is a drawing app for iPhone and iPad for children aged 2 to 6. It was developed under the supervision of an AMI Montessori teacher.

An adult and a child can take turns on the same canvas. While drawing, only the first finger to touch the screen makes a line, so other fingers on the screen don’t disturb it. To swap, lift your finger and hand the device over. There is an undo button, so if the child draws over your lines and you would rather they didn’t, you can step back.

If you want a second copy of your drawing for the child, choose the canvas in the Gallery and tap Duplicate. Your drawing stays as it is, and the child can add to or color in the copy. The fill tool colors an area with a single tap. There are also shape tools for circles, squares and triangles, which help when you want to show a shape.

The basic drawing features are free, and the free plan saves up to three canvases. The Manga and Dot canvases, the Paint Academy tracing lessons and unlimited canvases come with the paid Kinder Paint Pro. There are no ads and no account. For a first session, see Getting Started with Kinder Paint.

Download on the App Store

Kinder PaintCreative drawing for kids