Why Do You Forget Why You Walked Into a Room? The Doorway Experiments

When people moved into another room, their memory for what they had just been handling dropped. It happened in a virtual space shown on a small screen and in real rooms, and going back to the original room did not make memory better. That is the result of a study by Radvansky and colleagues in the United States, published in the Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology in 2011.
In a Brain Mondo short video, I introduced this study in about 40 seconds. In this post I write about the thinking behind the experiments that did not fit in the video, the studies before and after it, and how solid the idea of “forgetting because of a doorway” really is.
Video: Memory facts: Walking through a doorway makes you forget (Japanese)
The video is in Japanese.
It started with a virtual space in 2006
As the “further explorations” in its title says, the 2011 study is a sequel. The original was a study by Radvansky and Copeland, published in Memory & Cognition in 2006.
In that experiment, participants moved through a series of rooms in a virtual space on a screen. In the rooms they picked up objects, carried them and set them down. Every so often an object name appeared, and their memory for that object was tested. The object could be one they were carrying at the moment or one they had just set down. The team compared how easy it was to answer when people moved within the same room and when they went through a doorway into a new room.
There were two results. One was that objects you are carrying are easier to recall than objects you have put down. That seems obvious. The other was that moving to a new room made memory for objects harder to retrieve. And the effect of the room change was larger for the objects people were carrying. You have it in your hand, and after a doorway it becomes harder to recall. The authors argued that simple accounts, such as forgetting because time had passed, could not explain this.
This drop in memory after a change of location is called the “location updating effect”. “The doorway effect” is probably the easier name to remember.
What the 2011 study wanted to check
The 2006 experiment used a virtual space on a screen, which raises a question. Does the effect depend on how immersed people are in the on-screen world? Or is the cause the change of location as a context in itself?
Some work in spatial cognition suggests that how much you feel you are inside an environment affects memory. If that were the cause, lowering immersion should weaken the effect, and a real room should strengthen it. The 2011 study tested this in three experiments.
- Experiment 1 showed the virtual space on smaller displays to reduce immersion.
- Experiment 2 used an actual environment instead of a virtual one, to make immersion as high as possible.
- Experiment 3 had people return, after moving, to the original room where they had first learned the objects.
Result: it happened on small screens and in real rooms
The location updating effect appeared in both experiment 1 and experiment 2. Memory dropped with reduced immersion on small displays, and it dropped when people walked through real rooms.
So the effect was not caused by being absorbed in the on-screen world. Small screen or real room, moving to a different place in itself affected memory. This is the part the video described as “in a virtual room on a small screen and in real rooms, moving made memory drop”.
Going back did not bring it back
The most interesting one is experiment 3.
Memory research has a well-known idea called “encoding specificity”. Going back to the situation in which you learned something makes it easier to remember. Returning to where you were to remember what you came for is something many people do without thinking.
If the doorway effect came from having left the place where you learned something, returning to the original room should restore memory. But in experiment 3, going back to the original room did not make memory better. The abstract says plainly that this is inconsistent with an encoding specificity account.
Going back to the first room is common, and sometimes you remember the moment you get there. But this experiment suggests that going back does not in itself restore memory. If you remember after going back, it may be less because you returned to the room and more because some other cue caught your eye.
The brain divides experience into events
So why do doorways make us forget? The team explains the results with a theory of event cognition and memory called the “event horizon model”.
Roughly, the idea is that the brain organises experience not as one continuous stream but in units of “events”. Moving to another room is a boundary between events. Once you cross it, a new event is set up, and the previous one is filed away as “the earlier scene”. Information from the earlier scene then becomes harder to retrieve. A 2015 study in the same line of work describes this as competition between event models, which produces interference.
The 2011 paper also included a further analysis to separate the influence of the current scene’s information coming to the foreground from the influence of interference at retrieval. It then interpreted all the results in terms of this model.
One strength of the model is that it also explains why going back does not help. Returning to the original room is not returning to the earlier event. It is crossing yet another boundary.
Related studies: it happens in imagination, and sometimes not at all
This idea leads to an interesting prediction. If the cause is the event boundary, then perhaps you would forget even without seeing a real doorway, just by passing through one in your head. A 2016 study by Lawrence and Peterson tested this. Participants got to know a real or virtual space, memorised an image and then imagined walking through the space. When the imagined walk went through a doorway, they forgot more.
On the other hand, there are results showing the effect does not always happen. In a 2021 study, McFadyen and colleagues tried to reproduce the doorway effect in four experiments: highly immersive VR, VR with a working memory load, passively watching video, and walking through real rooms. In none of them did they find a clear effect of doorways on forgetting.
In experiment 2, however, with a working memory load, people made more false alarms after a doorway, saying “yes” to memory probes that did not match. When your head is already holding other things, memory after a doorway is more open to interference. The authors write that the effect may not survive slight changes to the method, and that we need to ask what produced the earlier results.
Limits and common misreadings
Here are points to keep in mind when reading this research.
- Doorways do not always make you forget. In the 2021 replication, there was no clear effect under ordinary conditions. The doorway effect appears under some conditions and not others, and it is still debated.
- What drops is memory for things you were just handling. What these experiments measured was memory for objects learned just before. This is not about losing yesterday’s events or knowledge you have held for years.
- There is nothing magic about the door itself. Since it also happened with imagined doorways, what matters is thought to be the brain marking “the scene has changed”, not the physical door.
The video says “that forgetfulness might be the door’s fault”. It says “might” for these reasons.
Using it in daily life
Even so, knowing that memory slips more easily at a change of scene is useful in daily life.
- Make a note of what you are going for before you change rooms. This comes from the video. Keep it outside your head so it survives the boundary. Type a word into your phone, carry something in your hand, put up a sticky note. Any form will do.
- Say it out loud before you move. There is a view that saying “I’m going to get the scissors” once before going through the door gives you a cue in the new room.
- Be most careful when your head is full. In the 2021 study, memory after a doorway was more open to interference under a working memory load. When you move while thinking about something else, a note helps most.
- Know that going back may not help. Returning to the first room does not always bring it back. When it does not, it is easier on yourself to accept that this is how the system works than to blame your memory.
Brain Mondo is a series of daily short videos about the brain, each based on a research paper. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day, and it includes memory training where you keep in mind something you saw a moment ago. The once-a-day Brain Dojo Check also gives you a short-term memory score, which is a rough guide to how you are doing today.
References
- Radvansky GA, Krawietz SA, Tamplin AK. Walking through doorways causes forgetting: Further explorations. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2011;64(8):1632-1645.
- Radvansky GA, Copeland DE. Walking through doorways causes forgetting: situation models and experienced space. Mem Cognit. 2006;34(5):1150-1156.
- Lawrence Z, Peterson D. Mentally walking through doorways causes forgetting: The location updating effect and imagination. Memory. 2016;24(1):12-20.
- McFadyen J, Nolan C, Pinocy E, Buteri D, Baumann O. Doorways do not always cause forgetting: a multimodal investigation. BMC Psychol. 2021;9(1):41.
- Radvansky GA, Pettijohn KA, Kim J. Walking through doorways causes forgetting: Younger and older adults. Psychol Aging. 2015;30(2):259-265.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →