← StudyX Devlog

Enable Dots on Number in MathCal: Where to Turn It On and What Children See

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperMathCalHow-To
Enable Dots on Number in MathCal: Where to Turn It On and What Children See

MathCal’s Basic Calculation Drill has a setting called Enable Dots on Number. When it is on, a short row of small dots appears above each of the two numbers in a problem, one dot for each unit. For 3 + 4, there are 3 dots above the 3 and 4 dots above the 4. The App Store description calls them dot guides.

This post covers where to turn the setting on and what appears on the screen. After that, it looks at what Japan’s curriculum guide and a few studies say about counting and about how dots are arranged.

Where to turn it on

Open the Drills tab at the bottom and tap Basic Calculation Drill in the list. The screen that opens has a Game Settings section, and the Enable Dots on Number switch is in it.

The same Game Settings section has switches for leaving out addition, subtraction, multiplication or division, No Carrying or Borrowing, and Number of Questions.

Once you turn the switch on, it stays on until you turn it off. Turning it off brings back problems with numerals only.

What appears on the screen

In the Basic Calculation Drill, the child handwrites the answers to single-digit problems as quickly as they can. The problems are listed down the screen, and the one being solved now is underlined.

With dots on, dots appear above the numbers in the current problem and in the problems below it. The dots are the same colour as the numerals and sit in one row directly above each number. For 7 + 5, there are 7 above the 7 and 5 above the 5. Once a problem is answered and moves up, it shows numerals only, without dots.

In multiplication and division problems, the dots still show the size of each number. For 3 × 4, there are 3 above the 3 and 4 above the 4.

With or without dots, the answer is written by hand on the screen in the same way.

Counting in first-grade arithmetic in Japan

Japan’s Ministry of Education (MEXT) sets out what is taught in its Course of Study commentary for elementary arithmetic (2017, in Japanese). In the first-grade section on counting how many and in what order, it explains counting like this: first identify clearly the set of things to be counted, then say the number words “one, two, three, four…” in order, matching one to each thing, and the last number gives how many there are.

In the next part, on seeing one number as the sum or difference of other numbers, the guide says children should come to see five counters as the sum of two parts, and shows this figure:

● and ●●●● ●● and ●●● ●●● and ●● ●●●● and ●

The guide also says that relating 8 to 10, seeing that 8 is 2 less than 10 or writing it as 10 − 2, lets children see a number from several sides. It calls this way of seeing important groundwork for understanding carrying and borrowing in addition and subtraction.

The principles of counting are in Saying Numbers Is Not Understanding Them: What One-to-One Correspondence Means, and making ten is in How to Teach the Making Ten Strategy.

Seeing a number without counting: subitizing

Recognising a small number of things at once, without counting them one by one, is called subitizing.

A 2021 study by Starkey and McCandliss in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology notes that the development of enumeration skills over childhood is thought to reflect improvements in both subitizing, for small sets, and serial counting, for larger sets. Working with elementary school children, they proposed a new way to measure how many items a child can subitize. Their measure predicted unique variance in symbolic arithmetic ability.

How arrangement changes what young children see

A 2024 study by Splinter and colleagues at KU Leuven in Belgium defines perceptual subitizing as the rapid identification of small numerosities. They tested 119 children aged 3 and 4.

The children saw pictures of sets of three to five objects. The pictures varied in four ways: whether unrelated objects were also in the picture, whether the objects were all the same or mixed, whether they were in a line or placed at random, and whether they were separate or overlapping.

Pictures with unrelated objects, mixed objects, random placement or overlapping objects each led to lower accuracy and longer response times than pictures without them. The best results came from the simplest pictures: no unrelated objects, and the same objects, in a line, kept apart.

Numerals and amounts

A 2020 study by Hutchison and colleagues in Developmental Science followed 540 kindergarteners, at the outset of formal education, over one school year. It compared symbolic number processing, as with numerals, and non-symbolic number processing.

At both the beginning and the end of kindergarten, the relation between the two was stronger for quantities within the subitizing range than for quantities outside it. Over the year, within the subitizing range the relation ran both ways. Outside it, the relation ran one way only, from symbolic to non-symbolic.

What these studies cover

Splinter and colleagues studied how 3- and 4-year-olds recognise the number of objects in a picture, and did not look at calculation. The studies by Starkey and McCandliss and by Hutchison and colleagues looked at how skills relate to each other, and did not test whether practice changes them.

What you can do in MathCal

MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it.

Every answer is handwritten: the child writes the numbers and symbols on the screen, and the app checks them. In my developer interview, asked why I chose handwriting over number buttons, I said: “Because moving your hand gets the brain working.”

In the Column Arithmetic Drill, the answer goes one digit per box. A box that has not been read yet is tinted, and each digit the app reads appears small above its box. Tapping the space next to it clears that box so the child can write it again. Once every box has been read, the Check answer button turns on. On iPad, you can also write with Apple Pencil.

Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. When they finish, they can stamp a calendar. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.

Download on the App Store

MathCalHandwriting game for mental math