← StudyX Devlog

Estimating Answers in Math: Rounding and Rough Calculation

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperMathCalHow-To
Estimating Answers in Math: Rounding and Rough Calculation

What is 2,876 + 4,195, roughly? Rounded to the nearest thousand, it is 3,000 + 4,000 = 7,000. The exact sum is 7,071.

An estimate like this tells you about how big the answer should be before, or after, you work it out. This post looks at where estimating appears in the US Common Core standards, and at what Japan’s curriculum guide says about rounding and estimating in fourth grade.

Rounding and estimating in the Common Core

In the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics, rounding starts in third grade. Standard 3.NBT.A.1 reads: “Use place value understanding to round whole numbers to the nearest 10 or 100.” In fourth grade, 4.NBT.A.3 extends this: “Use place value understanding to round multi-digit whole numbers to any place.”

Rounding is then used to check answers. In the fourth-grade word problem standard, 4.OA.A.3, children solve multistep problems with whole numbers and “Assess the reasonableness of answers using mental computation and estimation strategies including rounding.”

Japan’s fourth-grade unit on rounding

Japan’s Ministry of Education (MEXT) explains its curriculum in the Course of Study commentary for elementary arithmetic (2017, in Japanese). Earlier grades already touch on estimating. In the second-grade section on addition and subtraction, the guide says that estimating roughly how large a result will be, and how many digits it will have, matters for all later calculation. Grade 4 has a unit of its own on rounded numbers, with three aims: know when rounded numbers are used, know how to round to the nearest, and estimate the results of the four operations to suit a purpose.

When rounded numbers are used

The guide gives three cases.

  1. A known number is rounded on purpose, as when the crowd at a baseball stadium is reported to the nearest thousand.
  2. Sizes are shown roughly, as when the populations of cities are compared on a bar graph.
  3. The true value is hard to pin down, as with the population of Japan at a given moment, so a rounded number stands in for it.

Rounding to the nearest

The guide calls rounding to the nearest the most widely used way to make a rounded number. It works like reading a measurement at the nearest mark on a scale. To round to a place, you only look at the digit one place lower and ask whether it is 4 or less, or 5 or more. Its example is 42,948 rounded to the nearest thousand: the hundreds digit is 9, so it rounds up to 43,000.

The guide also says a number line helps children see that rounding does not change the size of a number much. Rounding 4,320 to two significant digits gives 4,300, not 43 or 430.

Choosing how to round

On the third aim, the guide says children estimate sums, differences, products and quotients with rounded numbers, using mental arithmetic. Estimating to suit a purpose means being clear about why you want a rough answer, choosing how precise the rounded numbers need to be, and rounding up or down to make the estimate larger or smaller on purpose.

The same sum shows the difference. Here is 2,876 + 4,195, rounded to the thousands in three ways.

  • Rounding to the nearest: 3,000 + 4,000 = 7,000
  • Rounding up: 3,000 + 5,000 = 8,000
  • Rounding down: 2,000 + 4,000 = 6,000

The exact sum is 7,071. Rounding to the nearest lands close to it. The rounded-up estimate can never be smaller than the exact sum, and the rounded-down estimate can never be larger.

The guide’s own example is checking whether something can be bought with 1,000 yen: there, it is better to estimate the prices on the high side, by rounding up. That case, in dollars, is in Money Math: How to Teach Kids to Work Out Change. Its other example is a bar graph, where the size of the paper sets the smallest step on the scale, and that step decides how many digits to round to.

Products work the same way. For 312 × 48, rounding each number to one significant digit gives 300 × 50 = 15,000. The exact product is 14,976.

The guide says children should have chances to decide for themselves which place to round to and whether to round up, round down or round to the nearest, and then to look back on whether the choice was right.

Why estimate

The guide says estimating helps children see the outcome in advance and avoid large mistakes. It also notes a catch: with rounded numbers, you round first and then calculate, which is more steps than calculating directly, so children may not feel the benefit. It suggests showing them everyday situations where rounding makes the work quicker, and pointing out that newspaper articles and other school subjects use rounded numbers often.

Estimating the quotient in long division

At the end of the rounding unit, the guide notes that estimating products and quotients plays an important role when finding each digit of the quotient in division by a two-digit number. Its example is 171 ÷ 21: taking 10 as the unit, it is roughly 17 ÷ 2, so the quotient is about 8. Indeed, 21 × 8 = 168, and 171 − 168 = 3, so the answer is 8 remainder 3. When the first guess is too big or too small, the guide says the steps for correcting it should be taught carefully. Those steps are in Long Division Steps: Divide, Multiply, Subtract, Bring Down.

What you can do in MathCal

MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it.

Every answer is handwritten: the child writes the numbers and symbols on the screen, and the app checks them. In my developer interview, asked why I chose handwriting over number buttons, I said: “Because moving your hand gets the brain working.”

In the Column Arithmetic Drill, the answer goes one digit per box. A box that has not been read yet is tinted, and each digit the app reads appears small above its box. Tapping the space next to it clears that box so the child can write it again. Once every box has been read, the Check answer button turns on. On iPad, you can also write with Apple Pencil.

Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. When they finish, they can stamp a calendar. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.

Download on the App Store

MathCalHandwriting game for mental math