Simplifying Fractions and Finding Common Denominators: Why the Denominators Must Match

Which is bigger, 3/4 or 5/6? Rewrite both with 12 as the denominator and 3/4 becomes 9/12, 5/6 becomes 10/12. That is nine twelfths against ten twelfths, so 5/6 is bigger by 1/12.
Rewriting fractions so they share a denominator is called finding a common denominator. Dividing the numerator and denominator by the same number to get a smaller denominator is called simplifying, or reducing, a fraction. In Japan, children learn both in fifth grade. This post sums up what the Course of Study commentary for elementary arithmetic (2017, in Japanese) from Japan’s Ministry of Education (MEXT) says about them, starting with why the denominators have to match. Number examples not taken from the commentary are my own.
What fifth grade covers
Fifth grade in Japan has a unit on the meaning and notation of fractions. Under knowledge and skills, children are to understand that a fraction made by multiplying or dividing the numerator and denominator of a fraction by the same number is the same size as the original fraction. In the same unit they learn about equal fractions and comparing fractions, and the two terms introduced are “common denominator” and “simplifying”. The next unit covers adding and subtracting fractions with different denominators.
In fourth grade, children only learn that, in simple cases, there are fractions of equal size. The commentary describes these simple cases as seeing, from fractions sitting at the same point on a number line, that fractions can be written differently and still be the same size. It adds that comparing fractions by finding a common denominator is taught in fifth grade.
Why the denominators must match
3/4 is three 1/4s, and 5/6 is five 1/6s. Because 1/4 and 1/6 are different sizes, comparing three with five tells you nothing. The commentary puts it this way: when comparing different things, you need to line up the base or the unit first. To compare fractions with different denominators, you rewrite them with a common denominator. Once they share a denominator, you can tell which is bigger by counting the unit fractions.
A unit fraction is a fraction with 1 as the numerator, like 1/4 or 1/12. Over a common denominator of 12, both fractions are counted in twelfths, so nine against ten settles it.
Fractions of equal size
Finding a common denominator relies on one property: multiplying or dividing the numerator and denominator by the same number does not change the size of a fraction. The commentary gives the example of multiplying the top and bottom of 2/3 by 2 to get 4/6, and dividing the top and bottom of 4/6 by 2 to get 2/3 again. It notes that this is a feature of fractions: the same size can be written in many ways.
Here are three strips of the same length, cut into 2, 4 and 8 parts and shaded.
1/2 |###############|...............|
2/4 |#######|#######|.......|.......|
4/8 |###|###|###|###|...|...|...|...|
The “#” marks the shaded part. The strips have different numbers of marks, but the shaded length is the same in all three. Multiply the top and bottom of 1/2 by 2 and you get 2/4; do it again and you get 4/8. Multiplying the top and bottom by the same number is the same as cutting the strip into finer parts. Comparing fractions with paper strips is also in When Fractions Don’t Click.
How to find a common denominator
The commentary describes finding a common denominator as rewriting fractions with different denominators as fractions with a shared denominator. When two fractions are given a common denominator, using the least common multiple of the two denominators keeps the result simple.
Here are the steps with 3/4 and 5/6.
- Find the least common multiple of 4 and 6. Go through the multiples of the larger number, 6, 12, …, and the first one that 4 divides exactly is 12.
- 4 times 3 is 12, so multiply the top and bottom of 3/4 by 3 to get 9/12.
- 6 times 2 is 12, so multiply the top and bottom of 5/6 by 2 to get 10/12.
Using 24, the product of the two denominators, also works: 3/4 = 18/24 and 5/6 = 20/24, and you can still compare them. The least common multiple, 12, keeps the numbers smaller. How to find the least common multiple is in Finding Multiples and Factors.
Adding and subtracting fractions with different denominators also turns into a sum with the same denominator once you find a common one. The commentary’s example is 1/2 + 1/3. Multiply the top and bottom of 1/2 by 3 and of 1/3 by 2, and 1/2 + 1/3 = 3/6 + 2/6 = 5/6. The commentary says that what matters here is not doing the common denominator as a mechanical step, but thinking about the number of unit fractions it gives. It calls this the basic idea behind addition and subtraction: calculating with the units lined up.
3/6 + 2/6 is three sixths and two sixths, five sixths in all. For 5/6 − 3/4, it is 10/12 − 9/12 = 1/12: ten twelfths take away nine twelfths leaves one.
How to simplify a fraction
The commentary describes simplifying a fraction as dividing the numerator and denominator by a common factor to get a fraction with a smaller denominator. The simplified fraction is the same size as the original. It adds that number lines and pictures are worth using when teaching this too.
Take 18/24. The greatest common factor of 18 and 24 is 6, so divide the top and bottom by 6 to get 3/4. If the greatest common factor is not obvious, dividing step by step by common factors gets you to the same place: divide by 2 to get 9/12, then by 3 to get 3/4.
A fraction is fully simplified when no number other than 1 divides both the numerator and the denominator. Only 1 divides both 3 and 4, so 3/4 cannot be simplified any further.
Answers to addition and subtraction can need simplifying too. For 1/4 + 5/12, use 12, the least common multiple of 4 and 12: 3/12 + 5/12 = 8/12. Both 8 and 12 divide by 4, so 8/12 = 2/3. Dividing 8/12 by 2 only gives 4/6, and since 4 and 6 still both divide by 2, it is not fully simplified yet.
Sources
- Japan’s Ministry of Education (MEXT), Course of Study commentary for elementary arithmetic (2017): fifth grade, A(4) meaning and notation of fractions and A(5) adding and subtracting fractions; fourth grade, A(5)
What you can do in MathCal
MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it.
In the drills, every answer is handwritten: the child writes the numbers and symbols on the screen, and the app checks them. In my developer interview, asked why I chose handwriting over number buttons, I said: “Because moving your hand gets the brain working.”
There are 59 Montessori lessons, and among them is Reduce & Common Denom. For simplifying, the child finds the greatest common factor; for a common denominator, the least common multiple. Each tap brings up the next step. A character explains the steps, beginning with “Finding a common denominator makes the bottoms match”. The Fraction Drill practices adding, subtracting, multiplying and dividing fractions. On iPad, you can also write with Apple Pencil.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. When they finish, they can stamp a calendar. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →