Money Math: How to Teach Kids to Work Out Change

You have a $5 bill. You buy juice for $1.50 and bread for $2.60. How much change do you get?
The answer is 90 cents. This post looks at that kind of problem: what the US Common Core standards say about money in second grade, how Japan’s curriculum guide writes one change problem as three different expressions, and how rounding up tells you whether you have enough.
Money in second grade
The Common Core State Standards for Mathematics put money in second grade, under Measurement and Data, in a cluster called “Work with time and money.” Standard 2.MD.C.8 reads: “Solve word problems involving dollar bills, quarters, dimes, nickels, and pennies, using $ and ¢ symbols appropriately.”
The example given with it is: “If you have 2 dimes and 3 pennies, how many cents do you have?” Two dimes are 20 cents, and three pennies bring it to 23 cents.
The same change, written three ways
Japan’s Ministry of Education (MEXT) explains its curriculum in the Course of Study commentary for elementary arithmetic (2017, in Japanese). In the fourth-grade section on expressions that show how quantities relate, it uses a shopping problem: a child takes one coin to the shop, buys juice and bread, and is asked for the change. The guide uses yen. Here is the same problem in dollars, with a $5 bill.
The guide writes the change in two ways first.
- Buying the juice and the bread together: 5.00 − (1.50 + 2.60) = 0.90
- Buying them one at a time: 5.00 − 1.50 = 3.50, then 3.50 − 2.60 = 0.90
In the first, the two prices are added first. The total is $4.10, and $5.00 minus $4.10 leaves 90 cents.
In the second, each item is paid for in turn. After the juice, $3.50 is left. Paying $2.60 for the bread from that leaves 90 cents.
The guide then changes the money. If the child takes five smaller coins instead of one large one, the change can also be written as a third expression. In dollars, with five $1 bills, that is (2.00 − 1.50) + (3.00 − 2.60) = 0.90. Two dollars for the juice gives 50 cents back, and three dollars for the bread gives 40 cents back. Together, that is 90 cents.
Every expression gives the same 90 cents. What changes is the order of paying and the money handed over.
Expressions show the thinking
This problem sits where children learn expressions that mix the four operations and use brackets. The guide says that when a problem is written as such an expression, children should notice that an expression is a way to find the result and also a way to show the line of thinking.
It also says that thinking about how the expression changes when the situation changes, and sharing those ideas, builds the ability to show how quantities relate and to read what an expression means. Paying with one bill or with five is one such change.
Working with dollars and cents means working with decimals. Where the decimal point causes trouble is in Where Children Get Stuck with Decimals: The Decimal Point.
Rounding prices up to check the money is enough
In the fourth-grade section on rounding, the same guide says that when estimating whether something can be bought with a set amount of money, it is better to estimate the prices on the high side, by rounding up. The guide’s example is 1,000 yen.
In dollars, say you have $10 and want three things costing $2.80, $4.30 and $1.90. Rounded up to the next dollar, they are $3, $5 and $2. That makes $10, so the real total cannot be more than $10.
The real total is 2.80 + 4.30 + 1.90 = 9.00. Paying with a $10 bill gives $1.00 in change.
When every price is rounded up and the estimate still fits, the real total fits too.
What you can do in MathCal
MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it.
Every answer is handwritten: the child writes the numbers and symbols on the screen, and the app checks them. In my developer interview, asked why I chose handwriting over number buttons, I said: “Because moving your hand gets the brain working.”
In the Column Arithmetic Drill, the answer goes one digit per box. A box that has not been read yet is tinted, and each digit the app reads appears small above its box. Tapping the space next to it clears that box so the child can write it again. Once every box has been read, the Check answer button turns on. On iPad, you can also write with Apple Pencil.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. When they finish, they can stamp a calendar. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →