← StudyX Devlog

Mannen Ko: A Ko That Ends as Seki Under the Japanese Rules

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperGo365How-To

Go365 · 9 of 11

Mannen Ko: A Ko That Ends as Seki Under the Japanese Rules

The Japanese Rules of Go (in Japanese), set by the Nihon Ki-in and the Kansai Ki-in, come with a set of worked examples for confirming life and death at the end of a game. Example 12 is titled 万年劫, mannen ko. Example 12 (in Japanese) gives its conclusion in one line:

黒白ともに「活き石」で、第八条により「セキ石」。

Both Black and White are living stones, and under Article 8 they are seki stones.

A ko is still on the board, yet neither side’s stones are dead. Both are seki stones. This post redraws the example’s diagrams in text and follows its moves one by one. The ko shape and the rule against taking back at once are in The Ko Rule in Go, and why tsumego answers list a ko apart from the correct line is in Ko in Tsumego.

The shape

● is Black, ○ is White, and ・ is an empty point. The letters a, b and c are labels for this post. The top row is the edge of the board, and so is the left column, so the top left is the corner.

○a○b●○
●○○c●○
●●●●●○
○○○○○○

The outer White stones are treated as alive here. Inside are:

  • one White stone in the corner, whose only liberty is a;
  • three White stones to its right, with liberties a, b and c;
  • eight Black stones around them, with liberties b and c.

Black can play a and capture the White stone in the corner. The Black stone at a then has only one liberty, the corner point, so White could take it back there. That is the ko.

When White starts

Diagram 1 of the example shows why the Black stones are alive.

White 1 is at c. The eight Black stones now have one liberty, b, and are in atari.

Black 2 is at a and captures the White stone in the corner. This takes the ko. The inner White group, now four stones with White 1, has only b left. The Black group gains a liberty, because the corner point is empty again, so it has b and the corner.

White 3 is a pass. White would like to take the ko back at the corner, but Article 7, paragraph 2 says that when life and death are confirmed after play has stopped, a stone may not be taken back in the same ko. White cannot play b either: that stone and the four inner White stones would have no liberties left.

Black 4 is at b and captures the four White stones. White started the attack, and White’s stones were the ones captured.

When Black starts

Diagram 2 shows why the White stones are alive.

Black 1 is at a and captures the White stone in the corner. White 2 is a pass.

Black 3 is at c. The three inner White stones now have only b. Black 3 joins the Black group, nine stones with liberties b and the corner point.

White 4 is played “left of 1”, on the corner point, and captures Black 1. Article 7, paragraph 2 goes on to say that after the side whose ko was taken has passed for that ko, it may take that ko again. White passed with White 2, so this capture is allowed. The corner point is filled, and the nine Black stones have only b.

Black 5 is a pass. Now Black cannot take back at a.

White 6 is at b and captures the nine Black stones. Black started the attack, and Black’s stones were the ones captured.

Both alive, both seki

Article 7, paragraph 1 defines living stones:

Stones that cannot be captured by the opponent’s moves, or stones that, even if captured, can produce new stones that the opponent cannot capture, are called living stones. Stones other than living stones are called dead stones.

In Diagram 1, White attacks and Black is not captured; White is. In Diagram 2, Black attacks and White is not captured; Black is. Whoever attacks loses the attacking stones, so both Black and White are living stones.

Article 8 then says that living stones with dame are seki stones, and that only the eyes of living stones that are not seki stones count as territory. Points b and c touch both Black and White, so they are not surrounded by one side only and are dame. The rules call both the Black and the White stones here seki stones. The eyes of seki stones are not territory, so this corner is territory for neither side.

The list of examples opens with a note: each verdict is the result of confirming life and death when play stops in the position shown, and it does not prevent the players from settling the position in actual play before the game ends (list of examples, in Japanese). The seki verdict applies when play is stopped with the shape as it is.

How it differs from an ordinary ko

Other examples in the rules also involve a ko. The commentary on Article 7, paragraph 2 (in Japanese) includes reference diagram 9, titled 本劫の手入れ (adding a move to an ordinary ko). Black has many ko threats, does not add a move, and claims the game is over. The verdict is that if the game ends like this, both the Black and the White stones are dead.

Play stops with a ko on the board in both cases. With the ordinary ko, both sides’ stones are dead. With the mannen ko, both sides’ stones are seki stones.

Where to go next

The ko rule and ko threats are in The Ko Rule in Go, ko in tsumego answers is in Ko in Tsumego, and counting liberties and seki are in Semeai in Go.

Solving tsumego in Go365

Go365 contains tsumego from 1 move to 7 moves, with 1,000 problems for each length, 4,000 in total. You play Black on the board, and White replies automatically. The goal, “Black to play: kill White” or “Black to play and live”, is shown above the board. Moves are counted for both sides together, and winning a ko does not count as a correct answer.

All problems are free to solve. The app shows ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. Ads you choose to watch for a hint or to refill retries are still offered after the purchase.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Go365A Go life-and-death problem every day