Eye Space and Life and Death: Nakade Shapes from Three to Six Points

The Nihon Ki-in, the main Go association in Japan, publishes a beginner textbook titled ๅฒ็ขๅๅฟ่ 19่ทฏ็ค 1 (Go for Beginners, 19x19 board, 1). Chapter 5 has a section titled โNakade: not letting the opponent make eyesโ (chapter 5 PDF, in Japanese, pages 117 to 120). It opens with this definition:
็ธๆใ็ผใๅขใใใใจใใธใฃใใใๆใใใใซใ๏ผไธญๆ๏ผใใจใใใพใใ
A move that stops the opponent from adding eyes is called nakade (ไธญๆ).
The textbook goes on to say that, basically according to the number of points in the territory, there are three-point, four-point, five-point and six-point nakade, and that in a nakade โthe center of the territory is the vital point.โ
This post follows that section in order and lists, size by size, which shapes become a nakade and which do not. What the word nakade means in tsumego solutions is in Tesuji Words in Tsumego, and how two eyes keep a group alive is in Living with Two Eyes.
The diagrams are drawn with characters: โ is Black, โ is White, ใป is an empty point and โณ is the vital point. In every diagram, Black is surrounded by White and cannot run out, and Blackโs wall has no gaps.
When a nakade works
The textbook gives four conditions for a territory where a nakade can be played:
- the wall around the territory has no gaps
- the wall has no weak points
- the territory has no dividing stones inside
- the corner has exceptions
Every diagram in this post is in the middle of the board, with a wall that has no gaps or weak points.
Two points
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
โโใปใปโโ
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
The textbook starts by explaining why there is no two-point nakade. A two-point territory has nothing to divide it, so โwhether Black plays first or White plays first, Black cannot make two eyes, and it is dead.โ White does not need a nakade here. Black is already dead.
Three points
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโใปโณใปโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
โโโณใปโโ
โโใปโโโ
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
In a three-point territory, the middle point is the vital point, whether the three points are in a straight line or bent. The textbook says that the vital point for a nakade is โthe center of the territory.โ Once White plays there, โBlack cannot make a divider to form eyes. This is called a three-point nakade.โ
If Black plays โณ first, Black gets one eye on each side and lives. If White plays โณ first, Black cannot split the space into two eyes and dies. Whoever plays there first decides the result.
Four points
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโใปโณใปโโ
โโโใปโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
In the T-shaped four, one point is attached to the middle of three. The vital point is โณ, the point next to all three of the others. If White plays โณ, it is a four-point nakade. If Black plays there first, the other three points become separate eyes and Black lives.
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
โโใปใปโโ
โโใปใปโโ
โโโโโโ
โโโโโโ
The 2x2 square four has no middle point. The textbook says of this shape that โthe territory has no center, so wherever Black plays to try to make two eyes, Whiteโs next move turns it into a three-point nakadeโ, and calls it โdead stones with only one eye.โ When White goes to capture, it can take all of Blackโs stones by going โthree-point nakade, then two points, then one point (one eye, in atari).โ
โโโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโโ
โโใปโณโณใปโโ
โโโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโโ
A four in a straight line is alive. If White plays on either inner โณ, Black plays on the other โณ and splits the space into two eyes. The textbook says the same about four-point territories shaped differently from the square: โAs it stands, Black is alive,โ because โthere is no center (vital point) for White to enter, so there is no nakade.โ In the middle of the board, a four bent into an L also has two vital points in the same way and is alive.
Five points
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโใปโโโ
โโใปโณใปโโ
โโโใปโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโใปโณใปโโ
โโใปใปโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
The five-point shapes that become a nakade are the cross and the square with one extra point bulging out. In the cross, the middle is the vital point. In the bulging shape, the vital point is โณ, the point of the square that touches the bulge. The textbook explains that the bulge makes that point the center.
The textbook calls these two โshapes on the edge of whether a five-point Black territory can make two eyes.โ It adds that โthere are many other shapes of five-point territory,โ but the others โhave many centers (vital points), so they are alive.โ If Black wants to live, it says, Black has to play the vital point before White does.
Six points and hana-roku
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโใปโโโ
โโใปโณใปโโ
โโโใปใปโโ
โโโโโโโ
โโโโโโโ
The six-point shape that becomes a nakade is the cross with one more point added. The vital point is the middle โณ. The textbook says this shape โis commonly called hana-roku (่ฑๅ ญ), because the territory looks like a flower (hana).โ Roku means six. If White plays โณ first, Black dies. If Black plays it first, Black lives.
The side that lives and the side that captures
After the five-point and six-point shapes, the textbook gives a rule for every size:
ใฉใฎใใซใใงใใใใงใใใ็ใใๅดใฏ้ฃๅฐใฎไธญๅฟใๅ ใใฆไปๅใใๅ ฅใใฆใใ็ผใใๅขใใใใจใ่ใใพใใๅใใซใใๅดใฏๆฅๆใซๆใฃใฆใ็ธๆใซ้ฃๅฐใฎไปๅใใไฝใใใชใใใใซใใพใใใใ
This is true of any nakade: the side that wants to live takes the center of the territory, puts in a divider and tries to add eyes. The side that goes to capture plays the vital point and does not let the opponent divide the territory.
The three-point shapes, the T-shaped four, the cross and bulging fives, and hana-roku each have a single vital point where White can play a nakade. If White plays there first, Black dies. If Black plays there first, Black lives. The square four has no vital point and is dead as it stands. Shapes with two vital points stay alive, because when one is taken the other is left.
Where to go next
How to read a tsumego diagram and its solution is in What Is Tsumego?, other words used in solutions alongside nakade are in Tesuji Words in Tsumego, and why a line that ends in ko is listed apart from the correct answer is in Ko in Tsumego.
Solving tsumego in Go365
Go365 contains tsumego from 1 move to 7 moves, with 1,000 problems for each length, 4,000 in total. You play Black on the board, and White replies automatically. The goal, โBlack to play: kill Whiteโ or โBlack to play and liveโ, is shown above the board. Moves are counted for both sides together, and winning a ko does not count as a correct answer.
All problems are free to solve. The app shows ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. Ads you choose to watch for a hint or to refill retries are still offered after the purchase.
Go365A Go life-and-death problem every daySee the app โ