Semeai in Go: How to Count Liberties in a Capturing Race

The Nihon Ki-in’s autumn 2022 special quiz solutions include lines like these, in Japanese and then roughly in English:
黒13まで黒攻め合い勝ち。
With Black 13, Black wins the semeai.
初手黒3は白4で黒攻め合い負け。
If Black’s first move is at 3, White plays 4 and Black loses the semeai.
Life-and-death solutions end with “White is dead” or “Black lives”. Semeai solutions end with “wins” or “loses”. How these quiz headings and move numbers are read is in What Is Tsumego?. This post goes through what a semeai is and how to count one, with three small diagrams.
What a semeai is
The British Go Journal glossary defines semeai as “A race to capture between two adjacent groups that cannot both live.” The Japanese dictionary Digital Daijisen adds that neither group has a living shape and neither has a way out. Whichever side captures first keeps its stones.
Liberties and the number of moves
The empty points next to a group are its liberties, and a group with no liberties left is captured, as in Go Rules for Beginners. In Japanese these points around a stone are also called dame (駄目). The same glossary lists damezumari as “Shortage of liberties.”
A semeai compares two counts: how many moves you need to capture the other group, and how many moves the other side needs to capture yours. In simple cases, that count is the number of liberties.
The diagrams are drawn in text. ● is Black, ○ is White, ・ is an empty point. In every diagram the top row is the edge of the board, the left column is also the edge, and the top left is the corner. The race is between the inner black and white groups. The stones around them take no part in it here.
Diagram 1: the same number of liberties
○・・・●○cba●
○●●●●○○○○●
○○○○○●●●●●
The inner black group has five stones: four on the second line and one on the edge. Its liberties are the three empty points on the edge to the left. The inner white group also has five stones, and its liberties are a, b and c. That is three against three.
If Black plays first: Black plays a, and White has two liberties. White fills one of Black’s, and Black has two. Black plays b, White fills another, and each side has one. Black plays c and captures the five white stones. If White plays first, the same order lets White capture first. With the same number of liberties, the side that plays first wins.
With no shared liberties and a difference of one, the turn stops mattering. Count a shape where Black has four liberties and White has three. Even if White starts, after White has filled three of Black’s liberties it is Black’s turn, and Black still has one left. Black fills White’s last liberty and captures.
The order of filling matters too. Black fills White’s liberties starting from a, next to Black’s own stones. If Black plays c first, that black stone has only one liberty, and White captures it by playing b.
Diagram 2: shared liberties
○●●・○○●
○●●・○○●
○●●●○○●
○○○○●●●
The inner black group has seven stones and the inner white group six. Each has only two liberties, the two points in the fourth column at the top. Both points touch Black and White.
If Black plays on one of them, White is down to one liberty. So is Black. White plays the other point and captures every black stone. If White plays first, the same happens to White. A move on a shared liberty takes away your own liberty along with the opponent’s.
So neither side plays there, and neither group is captured. This is seki. The British Go Journal glossary defines seki as “A local stalemate between two or more groups dependent on the same liberties for survival.”
Article 8 of the Nihon Ki-in’s Japanese Rules of Go (in Japanese) calls an empty point surrounded only by one side’s living stones an eye (目), and any other empty point dame. Living stones that have dame are seki stones, and only the eyes of living stones that are not seki stones count as territory. The two points in Diagram 2 are not surrounded by one side only, so they are territory for neither. Seki as a way to live without two eyes is also covered in Living with Two Eyes.
Diagram 3: a group with an eye against a group without
・●・○○●
●●・○○●
○●●○○●
○○○●●●
The inner black group has five stones, and the corner point is Black’s eye. Black has three liberties: the eye and the two points in the third column. The inner white group has six stones and only those two points as liberties. As in Diagram 2, both points touch Black and White.
White cannot play in Black’s eye. That move would not capture Black, and the white stone would have no liberties. If White plays one of the two points, White has one liberty left, and Black captures by playing the other.
Black can play both points in turn. After the first one, Black still has the eye and the other point. White can play neither the other point nor the eye. Black’s second move captures the six white stones. In Diagram 3 Black wins whoever plays first. There are two shared liberties, as in Diagram 2, but Black’s eye means there is no seki.
Where to go next
Eyes, false eyes and seki are in Living with Two Eyes. Words such as vital point, nakade and sacrifice that appear in solutions are in Tesuji Words in Tsumego. Move numbers and labels such as 黒先白死 are in What Is Tsumego?.
Solving tsumego in Go365
Go365 contains tsumego from 1 move to 7 moves, with 1,000 problems for each length, 4,000 in total. You play Black on the board, and White replies automatically. The goal, “Black to play: kill White” or “Black to play and live”, is shown above the board. Moves are counted for both sides together, and winning a ko does not count as a correct answer.
All problems are free to solve. The app shows ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. Ads you choose to watch for a hint or to refill retries are still offered after the purchase.
Go365A Go life-and-death problem every daySee the app →