Ten Facts About How Memory Works for Students: About Four Items at Once, and How Reminders Are Used

Remembering to do something later is called prospective memory. A review that pooled studies comparing it across ages found that in laboratory tasks younger people did better, while in studies set in everyday life older people did substantially better. It is a meta-analysis by Henry and colleagues, published in 2004 in Psychology and Aging.
Brain Mondo has published a video that picks ten studies like this one, on how memory works, and puts them in order: how much fits in your head, when your mind drifts, and ways of storing things outside your head. Each point has one paper as its source. In this post I go through the ten papers from the video, together with the conditions of each study and some cautions for reading them.
Video: Ten facts about how memory works for exam students (Japanese)
The video is in Japanese.
How much fits in your head
1. Moving to another room lowers memory
Earlier research with virtual environments had shown that memory declines when people move from one location to another (Radvansky and colleagues, 2011, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology). In this paper, the same drop appeared both when people moved through virtual rooms on smaller displays and when they moved through real rooms.
In the third experiment, people went back to the original room where they had first learned the objects, but their memory did not improve. The authors explain the results with the event horizon model, an account of how we divide experience into events and remember them. The procedure of this study and the work before and after it are in my post on the doorway effect.
2. About four items at once
In 1956, Miller summarized evidence that people can remember about seven chunks in short-term memory tasks. According to Cowan’s 2001 review in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, that number was meant more as a rough estimate than as a real capacity limit. Others have since suggested a more precise limit of only three to five chunks.
Cowan brings together a wide range of data arguing that this smaller limit is real. When people cannot rehearse or use long-term memory to combine items into larger chunks, a single central limit averaging about four chunks appears. I also write about working memory capacity in my post on working memory.
3. Very few people can do two things at once
200 people used a high-fidelity driving simulator, driving alone, doing a memory task alone, and doing both at once (Watson and Strayer, 2010, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review). The dual task was driving while solving a demanding memory task presented by ear.
The vast majority showed a clear drop in performance when doing both. 2.5% showed no drop at all. In the single-task conditions, these people scored in the top quarter on every measure for both driving and the memory task. I cover this study in more detail in my post on multitasking.
4. People who gestured while explaining remembered more
Adults and children were asked to remember a list of letters or words while explaining how they had solved a math problem (Goldin-Meadow and colleagues, 2001, Psychological Science).
Both adults and children remembered more items when they gestured during their explanations than when they did not. The authors write that gesturing appeared to save mental resources on the explanation, so more could go to the memory task. The abstract does not give the number of participants.
When your mind drifts
5. Some people drift more during hard tasks
124 undergraduates first took tests of working memory capacity (Kane and colleagues, 2007, Psychological Science). Then for 7 days, a handheld device signaled them eight times a day to report whether their thoughts had wandered from what they were doing, and to describe the situation.
During challenging activities that needed concentration and effort, people with higher working memory capacity kept their thoughts on the task better and mind-wandered less. This study looked at a relationship, so it cannot show that capacity is the cause.
6. Mind-wandering is mostly about the future
As much as half of human thought arises without any link to what is in front of us (Baird and colleagues, 2011, Consciousness and Cognition). Because mind-wandering has been linked to worse performance, it has mainly been seen as a mental failure.
In this study, the content of mind-wandering was mostly about the future. People with higher working memory capacity did more future-focused mind-wandering, and it often involved planning their own goals. The authors suggest that mind-wandering may support thinking ahead in ways that are useful in daily life. The abstract does not give the number of participants.
Storing things outside your head
7. The more there is to remember, the more people write it down
In a short-term memory task, people either had to rely on memory alone or were allowed to write the items down (Risko and Dunn, 2015, Consciousness and Cognition).
Whether people chose to write things down was related to how many items there were to remember. People whose short-term memory capacity was actually lower, and people who believed it was lower, wrote things down more. They often wrote things down even when it brought no visible benefit. The abstract does not give the number of participants.
8. Reminders improved performance
Gilbert ran four online experiments with 1,196 participants (2015, Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology). Participants had to remember to do something a short time later, and could set a reminder if they wished.
Setting reminders improved performance, and older participants set them more often. People used reminders according to how much they had to remember and how likely they were to be distracted. Scores on this task also predicted whether people carried out an intention built into their everyday activities up to a week later, though the effect size was weak.
9. People choose reminders even when it costs them
In three experiments, participants chose between two ways of doing a memory task (Gilbert and colleagues, 2020, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General). Using memory alone earned the highest reward for each item remembered. Using reminders raised the number remembered but earned less for each item.
Participants were clearly biased toward reminders, even when choosing the better option would have earned them more money. How strong this bias was differed from person to person, stayed stable over time, and was stronger in people who underrated their own memory. When participants were advised which option was likely to give the best result, the bias disappeared. The authors add that the bias could not be fully explained by misjudging one’s memory. The abstract does not give the number of participants.
10. Older people remembered everyday plans better
This is the meta-analysis by Henry and colleagues from the opening. Prospective memory can be time-based, doing something at a set time, or event-based, doing something when a cue appears. In laboratory tasks, younger people did better on both. Among event-based tasks, the age gap was larger for tasks that demanded more deliberate effort than for tasks supported by more automatic processes.
Memory for things already learned, measured by free recall, showed a significantly larger decline with age than prospective memory did. In studies of prospective memory in everyday settings, older people did substantially better than younger people, for both time-based and event-based tasks.
Cautions for reading
The ten studies did not measure the same things. The first measured memory after moving to another room, the third driving and memory task scores, the fifth and sixth self-reported mind-wandering, and the eighth and ninth online memory tasks. None of them measured scores on a real exam.
The study designs also differ. The fifth looked at a relationship, so it cannot show cause. The second is a review that brings many studies together, and the tenth is a meta-analysis of many studies. For the fourth, sixth, seventh and ninth, the abstracts do not give the number of participants.
Each result holds under the conditions of its study.
Using it in daily life
Following the conditions the studies tested, it looks like this.
- When you explain how you solved a problem, move your hands as you talk. In the fourth study, people who gestured while explaining a math solution remembered more items.
- Hand things you need to do a little later over to a reminder. In the eighth study, setting a reminder improved scores on a task of remembering to do something later.
- If you are unsure whether to use a reminder, find out first which way pays off. In the ninth study, advice on which option was likely to give the best result removed the bias toward reminders.
Brain Mondo introduces research-based stories about the brain, in top-ten videos and short videos. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day.
References
- Radvansky GA, Krawietz SA, Tamplin AK. Walking through doorways causes forgetting: Further explorations. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2011;64(8):1632-1645.
- Cowan N. The magical number 4 in short-term memory: a reconsideration of mental storage capacity. Behav Brain Sci. 2001;24(1):87-114.
- Watson JM, Strayer DL. Supertaskers: Profiles in extraordinary multitasking ability. Psychon Bull Rev. 2010;17(4):479-485.
- Goldin-Meadow S, Nusbaum H, Kelly SD, Wagner S. Explaining math: gesturing lightens the load. Psychol Sci. 2001;12(6):516-522.
- Kane MJ, Brown LH, McVay JC, Silvia PJ, Myin-Germeys I, Kwapil TR. For whom the mind wanders, and when: an experience-sampling study of working memory and executive control in daily life. Psychol Sci. 2007;18(7):614-621.
- Baird B, Smallwood J, Schooler JW. Back to the future: autobiographical planning and the functionality of mind-wandering. Conscious Cogn. 2011;20(4):1604-1611.
- Risko EF, Dunn TL. Storing information in-the-world: Metacognition and cognitive offloading in a short-term memory task. Conscious Cogn. 2015;36:61-74.
- Gilbert SJ. Strategic offloading of delayed intentions into the external environment. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2015;68(5):971-992.
- Gilbert SJ, Bird A, Carpenter JM, Fleming SM, Sachdeva C, Tsai PC. Optimal use of reminders: Metacognition, effort, and cognitive offloading. J Exp Psychol Gen. 2020;149(3):501-517.
- Henry JD, MacLeod MS, Phillips LH, Crawford JR. A meta-analytic review of prospective memory and aging. Psychol Aging. 2004;19(1):27-39.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →