Is It Hard to Sit and Just Think? The People Who Chose an Electric Shock Instead

Rather than spend 15 minutes in a bare room doing nothing but think, some people chose to give themselves an electric shock. Among men it was 12 out of 18, among women 6 out of 24. This comes from a study by the social psychologists Wilson, Gilbert and colleagues, published in Science in 2014.
In a Brain Mondo short video, I introduced this study in about 40 seconds. In this post I write about what each of the 11 studies checked, the details the video left out, and what later follow-ups found.
Video: Focus facts: Electric shocks and boredom (Japanese)
The video is in Japanese.
What the researchers wanted to know
The paper opens with figures from the American Time Use Survey. 95% of adults had done some kind of leisure activity in the past 24 hours, such as watching television, socialising or reading. Yet 83% had spent no time at all “relaxing or thinking”.
People can recall the past, imagine the future and picture worlds that have never existed. So why do they not make time for it? The team suspected that time with nothing to do but think is simply not enjoyable for most people.
Most earlier research on mind wandering looked at moments when people are doing something, like reading a book, and their thoughts drift away on their own. This study did the opposite. It took away every outside stimulus and left people with nothing but their thoughts.
What the experiment was
The basic procedure went like this. The participants, college students, handed over all their belongings, including phones and anything to write with, and then went alone into a plain, undecorated room. There, for 6 to 15 minutes depending on the study, they were asked to entertain themselves with their thoughts. There were only two rules: stay in your seat, and stay awake.
Afterwards they rated, on nine-point scales, how enjoyable it was, how hard it was to concentrate, how much their mind wandered and so on.
In the lab results from studies 1 to 6 (146 people), 57.5% said it was hard to concentrate and 89.0% said their mind wandered. That was with nothing around to compete for their attention. For enjoyment, 49.3% chose the middle of the nine-point scale or lower.
Same at home, same at any age
Maybe the unfamiliar lab was the problem. To check, in study 7 the team had college students do the same thing at home, when they were alone. 32% admitted they had “cheated” by listening to music, looking at their phone or getting out of the chair. Enjoyment was lower at home than in the lab, and concentrating was harder.
In study 8, people were randomly assigned either to just think or to do something they could do alone, such as reading a book, listening to music or browsing the web (15 people each, at home). Contacting other people was not allowed. Average enjoyment on the nine-point scale was 3.20 for thinking and 6.87 for the activities. This is the result behind the line in the video that simple activities were far more enjoyable.
To see whether this was just about students, study 9 recruited people aged 18 to 77 at a farmer’s market and a local church. The median age was 48. The results were much the same as with students. Whether people enjoyed the time was not related to age, education, income, or how often they used smartphones or social media.
The electric shock study
The best known is study 10. Participants first tried out and rated pleasant stimuli, such as attractive photographs, and unpleasant ones, such as an electric shock. They were also asked: if you were given $5, how much would you pay to experience this stimulus again, or to avoid it?
Then they spent 15 minutes thinking, with the usual instructions. This time they were told that they could give themselves an electric shock by pressing a button. The team took care to explain that the main goal was to entertain themselves with their thoughts, and that whether to take a shock was entirely up to them.
67% of men (12 of 18) and 25% of women (6 of 24) gave themselves at least one shock. And these numbers only count people who had said beforehand that they would pay to avoid being shocked again. One man pressed the button 190 times in 15 minutes and was left out as an outlier when the average number of shocks was calculated.
The authors think the gap between men and women is probably down to men’s higher tendency to seek sensation. Their summary is that being alone with one’s own thoughts for 15 minutes was apparently unpleasant enough to make many people choose something they had said they would pay to avoid.
Not because of dark thoughts
Perhaps being alone makes people dwell on their own faults and go round in circles. The team checked this too. They asked participants to write down what they had been thinking about, and analysed the text. How often people used words like “I” was not related to positive emotion words, negative emotion words or enjoyment (218 participants).
Another explanation is that thinking makes you be a “script writer” and an “experiencer” at the same time. You choose a topic, decide what happens, and then live through it in your head. So the team also tried having people spend a few minutes planning in advance what to think about. Enjoyment did not go up (averages of 4.97 and 4.94).
The last sentence of the paper reads: “The untutored mind does not like to be alone with itself.” The authors also write that this may be why many people try to gain control of their thoughts through meditation and similar techniques.
A follow-up in 11 countries
This was not just about Americans. In 2019, Buttrick, Wilson and colleagues ran the same comparison with 2,557 participants at 12 sites in 11 countries. When people were randomly assigned to think for pleasure or to do something, those who did something reported clearly greater enjoyment in every country.
How much people enjoyed thinking did differ by country. But those differences were fully explained by five individual traits. Four went with more enjoyment of thinking: liking to think (need for cognition), openness to experience, meditation experience and good mood at the start. One went with less: how much people reported using their phones.
There is also research showing that thinking can be made more enjoyable. In a 2017 study by Westgate and colleagues, people who were given a simple “thinking aid” found thinking easier and enjoyed it more. The authors conclude that thinking for pleasure on purpose takes mental effort.
Easy to misread
The study is sometimes summed up as “people prefer pain to boredom”, but not everyone chose the shock. Among women it was one in four. Leaving out the outlier, the average number of shocks was 1.47 for men and 1.00 for women, so few people kept pressing over and over.
Nor does the study say that time alone with your thoughts is bad in itself. People varied in how much they enjoyed it. Those who tend to enjoy positive daydreams liked it more. Those who said they get bored easily liked it less.
Using it in daily life
Here is what can be taken from this study.
- Do not blame yourself for reaching for your phone while you wait. Finding time with nothing to do hard was common to most people. Boredom feels bad, and that is not because your willpower is weak.
- If you want time to think, go in with a topic. Trying to “just think” without deciding anything seems to be hard. Having one cue, like thinking only about your next day off while you walk, should make it easier.
- Practise getting used to doing nothing. People with meditation experience enjoyed thinking more. One option is to make a few minutes a day to sit without doing anything.
Brain Mondo is a series of daily short videos about the brain, each based on a research paper. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day, and it includes training that asks you to hold your attention or switch it.
References
- Wilson TD, Reinhard DA, Westgate EC, et al. Social psychology. Just think: the challenges of the disengaged mind. Science. 2014;345(6192):75-77.
- Buttrick N, Choi H, Wilson TD, et al. Cross-cultural consistency and relativity in the enjoyment of thinking versus doing. J Pers Soc Psychol. 2019;117(5):e71-e83.
- Westgate EC, Wilson TD, Gilbert DT. With a little help for our thoughts: Making it easier to think for pleasure. Emotion. 2017;17(5):828-839.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →