What Is Neuroplasticity? Does the Adult Brain Still Change?

In January 2004, Bogdan Draganski and colleagues at the University of Regensburg in Germany published a short paper in Nature. They scanned the brains of volunteers who had learned to juggle. In brain areas linked to processing and storing complex visual motion, grey matter had increased. The change was temporary: by a later scan, it had decreased again.
The paper’s abstract presents this as a result that goes against the traditional view. Cortical plasticity, that view held, was a matter of changes in how the brain works, not changes in its anatomy.
This post covers what “neuroplasticity” means in these papers, and what several studies found when they looked for changes in adult brains, kept to what the papers themselves report.
What the word means
In the papers below, “plasticity” refers to the brain changing in response to experience and learning.
In 2000, E. A. Maguire and colleagues at University College London published a study in PNAS on the brains of licensed London taxi drivers. The posterior hippocampi of the drivers were larger than those of people who did not drive taxis, while a more anterior part of the hippocampus was larger in the non-drivers. Hippocampal volume was related to how long each person had worked as a taxi driver: positively in the posterior part, negatively in the anterior part. The abstract ends by saying that the healthy adult human brain seems to have a capacity for local plastic change in its structure in response to environmental demands.
That study compared drivers and non-drivers once. It left open the possibility that people whose hippocampi were already shaped differently were the ones who became taxi drivers.
Following the same people for four years
In 2011, K. Woollett and E. A. Maguire published a study in Current Biology that scanned trainee taxi drivers before and after their training. To become a licensed London taxi driver, a trainee has to learn the layout of about 25,000 streets and thousands of places, then pass a strict set of exams. According to the paper, this usually takes three to four years.
The study followed 79 male trainees at the start of their training and 31 male control participants. Three to four years later, 39 of the trainees had qualified, and 20 who had not qualified also came back for testing. At the start, the groups did not differ significantly in age, handedness, education or IQ.
In those who qualified, grey matter increased selectively in the posterior hippocampi, along with changes in their memory profile. No structural brain changes were seen in the trainees who did not qualify or in the controls. The abstract concludes that specific, enduring structural changes in the adult brain can be brought about by behaviors that engage higher functions such as spatial memory.
The juggling experiments
The 2004 study from the opening compared people who learned to juggle with people who did not. Each person was scanned three times. Between the first and second scans, grey matter increased in the mid-temporal area on both sides (an area called hMT/V5, involved in seeing motion) and in the left posterior intraparietal sulcus. By the third scan, it had decreased.
In 2008, a team including Arne May, one of the 2004 authors, repeated and extended the experiment and published it in PLoS ONE. The volunteers were 20 healthy adults who could not juggle, with a mean age of 26.5. They learned the three-ball cascade and were scanned six times.
The results matched the 2004 study. Grey matter in hMT/V5 and other areas increased while the volunteers were practicing and receded after they stopped. According to the abstract, a change in this area could be seen as early as seven days into training. The figure legend in the paper notes that the seven-day change is a trend only.
The authors write that neither how well people juggled nor the practice alone could explain the changes. They suggest that learning a new task matters more for a change in brain structure than continuing to train a task already learned.
Does it happen around age 60?
Also in 2008, the same team published a study in the Journal of Neuroscience that asked the same question in older adults.
They recruited 93 healthy volunteers who could not juggle, with a mean age of 60. After people who dropped out or were excluded, complete data remained for 44 people in the juggling group (aged 50 to 67, mean 59.1) and 25 in the control group (aged 55 to 67, mean 60.2). The juggling group spent three months learning the three-ball cascade, then stopped practicing and was scanned again three months later.
They learned more slowly than the volunteers around age 20 in the 2004 study. At three months, only 10 of the 44 could juggle for 60 seconds. The paper therefore compares the 25 best jugglers with the 25 controls.
The jugglers showed more grey matter in the right hMT/V5, virtually the same area found in the younger group. They also showed temporary increases in the left hippocampus and in the nucleus accumbens on both sides. These increases reversed after the three months without practice. The abstract sums up that older people were able to learn to juggle, and that, as in the young group, grey matter changes related to learning the skill were seen.
What these studies show, and what they don’t
The four studies that scanned the same people before and after have one thing in common. Adults who learned something new showed changes in brain structure that MRI could measure. This was seen in people in their twenties, in people around 60, and in trainee taxi drivers.
In the three juggling studies, though, the changes were temporary and faded once practice stopped. The lasting change came from the taxi driver study, where men spent three to four years learning the streets of London. Where the changes appeared also depended on what was learned: an area for seeing motion in the jugglers, the posterior hippocampus in the taxi drivers.
How practicing one task relates to other abilities that were not practiced is covered in Does Brain Training Work?. A study on exercise, memory and the hippocampus is in Does Light Exercise Help Memory?
References
- Maguire EA, Gadian DG, Johnsrude IS, et al. Navigation-related structural change in the hippocampi of taxi drivers. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2000;97(8):4398-4403.
- Draganski B, Gaser C, Busch V, et al. Changes in grey matter induced by training. Nature. 2004;427(6972):311-312.
- Driemeyer J, Boyke J, Gaser C, Büchel C, May A. Changes in gray matter induced by learning: revisited. PLoS One. 2008;3(7):e2669.
- Boyke J, Driemeyer J, Gaser C, Büchel C, May A. Training-induced brain structure changes in the elderly. J Neurosci. 2008;28(28):7031-7035.
- Woollett K, Maguire EA. Acquiring “the Knowledge” of London’s layout drives structural brain changes. Curr Biol. 2011;21(24):2109-2114.
BrainDojo is a brain training app with 40+ trainings covering handwriting, reading aloud, arithmetic, memory and attention. A session can start at about ten seconds, and Today’s Training is picked for you each day. The Brain Dojo Check runs once a day, gives one test each for Processing Speed, Inhibitory Control and Working Memory, and returns your result as a radar chart and a rank.
Every training except the newest ones is free to play, and the free version shows ads. BrainDojo Plus removes the ads and lets you play the new trainings at any time. Your first session is covered in Getting Started with BrainDojo.
BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habitsSee the app →