← StudyX Devlog

When to Use Hints in Sudoku: Not Too Many, Not Too Late

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperSudoku365How-To
When to Use Hints in Sudoku: Not Too Many, Not Too Late

Some sudoku apps have a hint button that fills the selected cell with the correct digit. That is one cell. But one cell can be enough to finish the whole board, and it can also leave you with nothing new to fill in.

Using a hint can feel like losing, and that feeling can leave you staring at the same board for a long time. The rules of sudoku say nothing about how many hints you may use. There is only one solution, so the finished board looks the same however many you used. What differs is what you found on the way.

This post covers what to check before you press, which cell to choose, and what to look at afterwards. The order for rechecking a board is in Stuck on a Sudoku? How to Find the Next Move, so this post stays on hints.

Before you press

There is no rule for how many minutes to wait. One measure is whether you have looked everywhere once.

You went through the digits 1 to 9 in the boxes, rows and columns. You wrote pencil marks and checked that you had not removed too many. And now you are looking at the same places in the same order again. Pressing at that point is one way to decide. Before that point, the cell a hint fills may be one you could have found.

Another view is that the right moment depends on what you want. While learning techniques, press as late as you can. If the goal is to keep a daily habit, press sooner and finish the puzzle. Neither one is the correct answer.

There is one more moment when the button looks tempting: a cell is down to two candidates and you cannot decide. If you guess, a right answer still leaves you without a reason. Is It OK to Guess in Sudoku? goes into this. A hint gives you a digit that is certainly correct, so you can work backwards to the reason.

Which cell to choose

Here is a board made for this post. A dot is an empty cell, and there is one solution.

1 ・ 9 | 4 ・ 7 | ・ 6 ・
4 ・ ・ | ・ 8 2 | ・ 9 ・
2 ・ ・ | 1 9 6 | 3 ・ 4

・ ・ ・ | 9 ・ 1 | 7 4 6
6 1 4 | ・ 7 ・ | 9 2 3
7 9 ・ | 6 ・ 4 | ・ 5 ・

9 ・ ・ | 7 1 ・ | ・ ・ ・
8 ・ 7 | 2 4 ・ | 6 1 9
・ ・ 1 | ・ 6 9 | ・ ・ ・

There are 36 empty cells. Looking for a digit’s place in the boxes, rows and columns finds nothing, and neither does looking for the digit of a single cell. Techniques 1 to 3 from How to Solve Sudoku: The First Techniques Beginners Should Learn stop here.

Now take each of the 36 cells in turn and put in only its correct digit. This is how many more cells those same three techniques then fill:

Cell that gets the digit Number of cells Cells filled afterwards
All cells not listed below 29 All 35 that remain
Row 9, column 7 1 3
Row 4, column 3; row 7, column 7; row 9, column 2 3 1
Row 1, column 9; row 3, column 3; row 7, column 9 3 0

The same single hint finishes the board from 29 of the cells and does nothing from 3 of them.

The number of candidates is a useful clue when choosing. On this board, 15 cells have two candidates, and 14 of those finish the board with one hint. There is an exception. Row 3, column 3 has the candidates 5 and 8, and putting in the correct 5 fills nothing else. When that happens, the next step is to go back over the board.

Look at the pencil marks first

If you keep pencil marks, the marks in the cell are worth a look before you press.

Row 2, column 4 has the candidates 3 and 5, and a hint there gives 3. If your marks in that cell have no 3, you removed too many somewhere. The hint doubles as a check on your marks. Once a digit is in the cell, the marks are gone, so this only works before you press.

Where to look afterwards

A new digit affects the 20 cells that share its row, column or box. That is where to look before spending another hint.

With a 3 in row 2, column 4, the top middle box leaves only 5 for row 1, column 5. Then the only place for a 3 in row 1 is column 2. From there the cells fall one after another until all 36 are filled. A second hint pressed right away would have been one you did not need.

Why that digit

A digit from a hint still has a reason. Here is the reason for the 3 in row 2, column 4.

Look for where a 3 can go in the middle box (rows 4 to 6, columns 4 to 6). Row 5 already has a 3, so the only cells left are row 4, column 5 and row 6, column 5. You do not know which one yet, but this box’s 3 lies in column 5.

So no other cell in column 5 can be a 3. In the top middle box, a 3 could go in row 1, column 5 or row 2, column 4. The first one is in column 5, so it is out. That leaves row 2, column 4.

This is technique 4 in the beginner’s post, usually called pointing. It is the one move this board was waiting for, which means the board can be solved with no hint at all.

If you follow the reason back, one hint leaves you with the name of a technique you missed. There is also a view that what you pressed on is worth remembering more than how many times you pressed.

About Sudoku365

Sudoku365 is a Sudoku app for iPhone, iPad and Android. It uses the classic 9×9 board. It has four difficulties, Easy, Medium, Hard and Expert, with 300 puzzles each, 1,200 in total. There is a Daily Challenge with one puzzle a day and a streak, and two people can play head to head or together over Bluetooth.

Pressing Hints fills the selected cell with the correct digit, and that digit cannot be changed. You start with 10 hints and get one more for each puzzle you clear or each ad you watch, so one hint per puzzle keeps your count level. A wrong number shows in red right away and counts as a mistake, but a hint does not. A puzzle finished with hints still counts toward your clears and your streak.

The app is free with ads, and a one-time Remove Ads purchase turns them off. For your first puzzle, see Getting Started with Sudoku365.

Download on the App Store Download on Google Play

Sudoku365Daily sudoku, alone or with two