When Word Problems Stall: Draw a Diagram Before Writing the Equation

“There were some apples at first. After getting 5 more, there were 12. How many were there at first?” (translated from the Japanese)
This problem appears as a second-grade example in Japan’s national curriculum guide for elementary mathematics, the Course of Study commentary for arithmetic published by the Ministry of Education (MEXT) in 2017. The guide is in Japanese. The answer is 12 − 5 = 7.
The guide expects that some children will read “getting 5 more” and decide to add, while others will say it is subtraction. The story says the apples were received, yet the calculation is a subtraction. A child who can work out both 12 − 5 and 7 + 5 can still get stuck here.
Here is what the guide and the research say about putting a diagram between the words and the equation.
When the words point the wrong way
In its second-grade section on the relationship between addition and subtraction, the guide explains that with three quantities, which one you are looking for decides whether you add or subtract. It names three kinds of situations to teach:
- The story sounds like subtraction, but you add. Its example: some apples, 5 eaten, 7 left; how many at first? The answer is 7 + 5.
- The story sounds like addition, but you subtract. This is the opening problem, 5 received, 12 in all.
- The number taken away is unknown, and you find it by subtracting. Its example: 12 apples, some eaten, 7 left; how many were eaten? The answer is 12 − 7 = 5.
In the first two, choosing the operation from words such as “got” or “ate” gives the wrong answer.
The diagrams in the guide
For the opening problem, the guide shows two ways children might draw it.
One uses circles for apples. The child lines up circles scene by scene: an unknown number at first, 5 received, 12 in all. Children who think with the circles notice that there are 7.
The other is a tape diagram, a bar standing for each quantity. The guide describes a child who cuts the problem into short sentences and adds to the tape bit by bit as the story goes: “There were some apples at first.” “I got 5.” “Now there are 12.” Drawn this way, the child sees that taking 5 from the whole 12 gives the starting number, then checks it with 7 + 5 = 12.
The guide then says that when children cannot grasp how the quantities relate, or do not know how to solve a problem, it is important to confirm that drawing the situation as it unfolds makes the structure easier to see and helps them find the right calculation, so that they come to see the value of diagrams as a mathematical way of expressing things.
Tape diagrams continue past second grade. In the fourth- and fifth-grade sections on ratio, the guide has children show the base quantity and the compared quantity, and whole and part, with tape diagrams, number lines and expressions.
Both the circles and the tape show numbers and how they relate. Neither shows what an apple looks like.
Pictures and diagrams are not the same thing
A 1999 study by Mary Hegarty and Maria Kozhevnikov in the Journal of Educational Psychology separated two kinds of visual-spatial representation. Schematic representations encode the spatial relations described in a problem. Pictorial representations encode the visual appearance of the objects described in it.
Participants solved mathematical problems and reported how they solved them, and the researchers could reliably classify their representations as mainly schematic or mainly pictorial. Using schematic representations went with success in problem solving. Using pictorial representations was negatively correlated with success. Schematic use was also significantly correlated with one measure of spatial ability.
This was a study of the images people used in their heads and how they related to success. It did not train anyone to draw.
Third graders who were taught to draw
A 2012 study by Csaba Csíkos and colleagues at the University of Szeged and Eötvös Loránd University in Hungary did teach drawing, to third graders.
Five classes (106 children) took part in the program and six classes (138 children) were the comparison group. The program ran for 20 lessons with 73 word problems, covering the basic types of word problem. Teachers received lesson plans and transparencies showing different kinds of visual representations for the problems. The children were invited to make a drawing for each task, and group work and teacher-led discussion shaped their beliefs about what drawings do in word problem solving.
The effect sizes (Cohen’s d) were 0.20 on an arithmetic test and 0.62 on a word problem test, so the difference was larger for word problems than for calculation. The children’s beliefs about mathematics also changed significantly. The authors conclude that learning about visual representations in word problem solving is possible, feasible and important as early as grade 3, around age 9 to 10.
What a US practice guide recommends to teachers
The Institute of Education Sciences at the US Department of Education published Improving Mathematical Problem Solving in Grades 4 Through 8 in 2012. Its third of five recommendations is “Teach students how to use visual representations,” rated Strong Evidence, because six studies with middle school samples consistently found that using visual representations improved achievement.
The guide states that students who learn to represent the mathematical information in a problem visually before writing an equation are more effective at problem solving. Its visual representations include tables, graphs, number lines and diagrams such as strip diagrams, which use rectangles to represent the quantities in a problem.
Its suggestions to teachers include these:
- Consistently teach a few types of visual representation rather than many.
- Keep using the same representation for similar problems.
- Model how to represent a problem, thinking aloud about the decisions being made.
- Teach students to identify the information that matters, since problems often include information that is irrelevant.
The guide adds that strip diagrams suit comparison and fraction problems.
What is known, and how far it goes
Japan’s curriculum guide shows children turning a word problem into a diagram one sentence at a time from second grade. In Hegarty and Kozhevnikov’s study, people who used representations of relations, rather than of appearance, solved more problems. In the Hungarian experiment, third graders taught to draw did better on word problems afterwards. The IES guide recommends that teachers teach students to represent problems visually before writing the equation.
Hegarty and Kozhevnikov’s study is correlational. The Hungarian program changed several things at once, so it does not isolate drawing alone. The IES recommendation rests on studies with middle school students.
How to handle remainders in word problems is in How to Teach Division with Remainders.
What you can do in MathCal
MathCal is a math app where children write their answers by hand on the screen. I make it.
Every answer is handwritten: the child writes the numbers and symbols on the screen, and the app checks them. In my developer interview, asked why I chose handwriting over number buttons, I said: “Because moving your hand gets the brain working.”
In the Column Arithmetic Drill, the answer goes one digit per box. A box that has not been read yet is tinted, and each digit the app reads appears small above its box. Tapping the space next to it clears that box so the child can write it again. Once every box has been read, the Check answer button turns on. On iPad, you can also write with Apple Pencil.
Today’s Drill, Today’s Challenge and Today’s Lesson on the home screen are free every day, and setting a birthday picks them to suit the child’s grade. When they finish, they can stamp a calendar. Choosing any drill or lesson from the full lists requires a one-time purchase. There are no ads. How to start is in Getting Started with MathCal.
MathCalHandwriting game for mental mathSee the app →