← StudyX Devlog

Can Adult Brains Change With Use? The Hippocampi of London Taxi Drivers

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 13 of 23

Can Adult Brains Change With Use? The Hippocampi of London Taxi Drivers

In London taxi drivers, the back part of the hippocampus, a region involved in memory, was larger than in people who did not drive taxis. The front part, by contrast, was larger in the non-drivers, and the longer someone had been a taxi driver, the stronger this pattern was. That is the result of a study by Maguire and colleagues in the UK, published in PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) in 2000.

In a Brain Mondo short video, I introduced this study in about 40 seconds. The video ends by saying “the possibility remains that their brains were different to begin with”. In this post I go as far as how later studies tested that possibility.

Video: Brain facts: The taxi driver’s hippocampus (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

London taxi drivers are a special group

To get a taxi licence in London, you have to go through training in which you learn thousands of places in the city and the routes between them. This training is known as “The Knowledge”, and it takes about two years on average to acquire. After that you must pass a very stringent set of police examinations.

They can build a route from anywhere in the city to anywhere else without a map. The team saw them as ideal for studying spatial memory and navigation. In animals, it was known that birds and small mammals that store food and must remember where have larger hippocampi. The team wanted to find out whether, in humans too, the experience of learning routes shows up in the shape of the brain.

What the study was

The participants were 16 right-handed male licensed London taxi drivers. Their mean age was 44 (range 32 to 62). All had been licensed for more than 1.5 years, with a mean of 14.3 years. Training on The Knowledge had taken 2 years on average (10 months to 3.5 years). All had healthy medical, neurological and psychiatric profiles.

The comparison group was selected from a database of brain MRI scans taken at the same unit. People under 32 or over 62, women, left-handed men and anyone with health problems were excluded, leaving 50 healthy right-handed men. The mean age and age range were matched to the drivers, with people spread evenly across each decade.

The analysis used two methods.

  • The first divides the whole brain into small points and automatically searches for differences in the amount of grey matter (voxel-based morphometry, or VBM). Its strength is that it does not decide in advance to look at the hippocampus, so it can find a difference anywhere in the brain.
  • The second measures cross-sections of the hippocampus one slice at a time by hand. The 16 drivers and 16 precisely age-matched controls were measured by one person who did not know who was a driver. The hippocampus was divided into front, middle (body) and back for comparison.

Result: the only difference was in the hippocampus

With the whole-brain method, the only places where drivers had more grey matter were the left and right hippocampi. No differences were found anywhere else in the brain. And the difference was not across the whole hippocampus, but limited to the back part on both sides.

The front part of the hippocampus, by contrast, had more grey matter in the controls. With the first method this front difference did not survive strict correction for multiple comparisons, but it was clearly confirmed by the second, hand-measured method.

In the hand measurements, the front of the hippocampus was larger in the controls, the back was larger in the drivers, and the middle showed no difference.

The total size of the hippocampus did not differ

This is an important point that the video did not cover.

In the hand measurements, the total volume of the hippocampus did not differ between drivers and controls. The averages for both the right and left hippocampus were almost the same. What differed was the distribution inside the hippocampus: larger at the back, smaller at the front. The authors describe it as a “relative redistribution” of grey matter in the hippocampus.

You sometimes hear that “taxi drivers have a bigger hippocampus”. More precisely, it is “a bigger back part and a smaller front part of the hippocampus”. That is what the video means by “part of the brain was larger”.

The longer the experience, the bigger the difference

The team also checked whether the difference might be incidental. For example, people who happened to have a larger back hippocampus might be good at learning routes and so become taxi drivers.

So they looked at how the time spent as a taxi driver (including training on The Knowledge) related to the size of the hippocampus. Even after removing the effect of age, the longer someone had been a driver, the larger their right posterior hippocampus (correlation 0.6). The hand measurements also showed that the longer the time, the smaller the front part (correlation minus 0.6). In the left hippocampus, no clear link with driving experience was found.

One driver, with 42 years in the job, was excluded from the correlation analysis as an outlier, because the next longest was 28 years. The authors write that his data were fully in line with the overall relationship.

The authors took these results as grounds for thinking that the change in hippocampal grey matter, at least on the right, was acquired. They concluded that the healthy adult human brain seems to have a capacity for local structural change in response to environmental demands. In their view, a “mental map” of the city is stored in the back of the hippocampus and takes up more room as it becomes more detailed.

As the video says, the 2000 study compared two groups, drivers and non-drivers, at a single point in time. The link with length of experience is a clue, but on its own it cannot fully rule out that they were different from the start. The same team went on to test this.

Navigation skill in people who are not taxi drivers (2003). The team studied people who did not drive taxis and looked at how their navigation skill related to brain structure. Despite a wide range of skill, there was no link with grey matter in the back of the hippocampus. It does not look as if people with a natural talent for finding their way simply have a larger hippocampus.

Comparison with bus drivers (2006). Taxi drivers were compared with London bus drivers who were matched for driving experience and stress. Bus drivers follow fixed routes. Even so, taxi drivers had more grey matter in the mid-to-back hippocampus and less at the front, and the link with years of experience appeared only in taxi drivers. The result points to spatial knowledge of the city, not driving itself or stress. On the other hand, taxi drivers were worse than bus drivers at learning new visuo-spatial information.

Four years of follow-up (2011). The most direct answer came from a follow-up study by Woollett and Maguire. They studied average-IQ adults before and after the four years they spent learning The Knowledge to become licensed taxi drivers. In those who qualified, grey matter increased selectively in the back of the hippocampus, and their memory profile changed too. No structural brain changes were seen in trainees who failed to qualify or in the controls.

The same people were compared before and after training, and the change appeared only in those who qualified. With this result, “they were different from the start” became hard to use as the whole explanation.

Limits and common misreadings

There are still points to keep in mind.

  • Where one part got bigger, another got smaller. The authors themselves raise the shrinking front part, and the weaker learning of new information seen in 2006, as a possible cost. Mastering one thing may come at the expense of something else.
  • The participants were a small number of men. The 2000 study had 16 right-handed men. This study cannot tell us whether the same happens in women or in other occupations.
  • The Knowledge is on a different scale from ordinary learning. It means learning thousands of places and routes over about two years on average, then passing a stringent exam. This is not a story about a few weeks of a game or practice producing the same change.
  • Bigger does not simply mean smarter. The larger back hippocampus was linked to detailed knowledge of London’s streets. It is not a finding that memory in general improved.

Using it in daily life

What can be taken from this study is the idea that the adult brain, too, can change shape according to how it has been used over a long time. Here is what follows from that.

  • Keeping at something over time matters. The change was seen in people who had learned and used routes for years. There is a view that how you use your brain shows more in the years you keep at it than in how much you do in a day.
  • Close the map app now and then when you walk. By one view, when walking in an unfamiliar town, working out the route yourself from time to time leaves your hippocampus a job it is good at. No study shows this makes the hippocampus bigger, but there is no reason not to.
  • When mastering one thing, keep an eye on the balance. As the 2006 study suggested, deepening one ability may have a cost.

Brain Mondo is a series of daily short videos about the brain, each based on a research paper. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day, and Today’s Training on the home screen picks a different set of trainings every day. It is nothing on the scale of changing your brain, but it can be a way into a habit of using your head a little every day.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits