Can an Adult Fix Their Pen Grip? Holding a Pen with Less Strain

In 2014, a Brazilian occupational therapy journal published a study of how 806 university students held a pen (Sime and colleagues, Revista de Terapia Ocupacional da Universidade de São Paulo). The researchers filmed right-handed students writing and classified their grips. The most common was the dynamic tripod: the pen held between the thumb, index and middle fingers, with the fingertips doing the moving. Next came the lateral tripod, where the thumb rests against the side of the index finger. And 34.86% of the students used transitional grips or variations of them.
So roughly one adult in three writes with a grip that differs somewhat from the picture in a school textbook. This post is for adults who have started to wonder about their own grip. It covers how to think about changing it, and how to go about it if you decide to.
It doesn’t have to match the textbook
First, a study that may take some pressure off. Schwellnus and colleagues (2012) compared the grips of children around the fourth grade. They found no difference in legibility or speed between the dynamic tripod and other mature grips such as the lateral tripod or a four-finger grip. The study was of children, but it is a hint that there may not be just one correct shape.
One way to look at it is that the question is not whether your grip looks right, but whether it causes problems. For example:
- Your hand or fingers get tired or sore after writing a little.
- You squeeze so hard that your fingertips turn white.
- It is hard to make small changes of direction, so letters don’t come out the way you want.
- Your fingers hide the tip of the pen.
If none of these apply, you don’t have to change anything. If they do, that is a reason to.
Can adults change their grip?
It is sometimes said that you can, little by little, but it takes time. Your grip is a movement your hand has repeated every day for decades. While you are paying attention, you can hold the pen the new way. The moment you scribble a quick note, it slips back. That is normal.
My own handwriting is not neat either. In my developer interview I said: “My own handwriting is not neat, but when I see someone with beautiful handwriting, I think, ‘That’s nice.’”
Three things to try first
Trying to change everything at once makes writing itself unpleasant. You can start with these three.
1. Hold the pen a little further from the tip. If your fingers are too close to the tip, they hide it, and your fingertips have less room to move. Move your grip up just slightly and see how the line looks.
2. Loosen the pinch. Hold the pen lightly between your thumb and index finger, and support it from below with your middle finger. Let the barrel rest near the base of your index finger. Rather than pressing hard with thumb and finger, think of the pen as supported at four points: three fingers and the base of the index finger. Glance at your fingertips now and then to check they aren’t turning white.
3. Set up the paper and your posture. Put the paper in front of you and hold it with your other hand. If you lean, or the paper is far away, your wrist and shoulder tense before your fingers do, and your grip falls apart. Japan’s national curriculum guidelines (in Japanese) list posture and how to hold a writing tool together, as one item for first and second graders.
How to practise
Use the new grip only during practice at first. You don’t need to take every work note with the new grip from day one. Set aside five or ten minutes a day and use the new grip only then. Once it feels familiar, extend it to writing that doesn’t need to be fast, such as a diary or a planner.
Write slowly, and write large. Your hand doesn’t know the new movement yet. Small, fast writing will pull you back to the old grip. Start with fairly large vertical lines, horizontal lines and circles, and move on to letters after that.
Change one thing at a time. Where you hold the pen, how hard you grip, the angle of the pen: however many things bother you, work on only one each week.
Watch your hand. You see surprisingly little of your own hand while you write. A mirror, or a short phone video of your hand, shows clearly where the pressure goes and where your fingers sit.
One approach is to plan on keeping it up for at least a few weeks. If pain persists, or you feel numbness, don’t push through it. See a doctor or an occupational therapist.
Does the grip change with an Apple Pencil?
The basics are the same. Pinch lightly with three fingers and let the base of the index finger support the pen. That holds on paper and on a screen.
What differs is the surface. Glass is more slippery than paper, and the tip is hard, so when you try to stop a line exactly where you want, your fingers tend to tighten. A grip you have fixed on paper can come apart on a screen.
When I made Smartpaper Letters, I tried an experimental version first. In the interview I said: “The rough feel of sand cannot be reproduced, but on an iPad with a paper-like screen protector, it worked quite well.” A little friction lets the line stop without extra force, which can give your grip some slack too. Choosing films and tips is covered in How to Make Apple Pencil Feel More Like Paper, and how a screen differs from paper in Can You Practise Handwriting on an iPad?
Grip aids
There are grips that slip onto a pen, triangular pens, pens with thick barrels and so on. What they share is that they make it clear where to put your fingers.
Grip aids can be a way in. Once your hand has learned where the fingers go, try a normal pen again. If your grip falls apart, go back to the aid for a while. How grip develops, and how aids fit in, is written for children in How to Teach Pencil Grip, but the ideas carry over. Other reasons handwriting gets messy are in Why Adult Handwriting Gets Messy.
Sources
- Sime and colleagues (2014). “Grasps for handwriting: prevalence of different types among young adults.” Revista de Terapia Ocupacional da Universidade de São Paulo.
- Schwellnus, H., and colleagues (2012). “Effect of pencil grasp on the speed and legibility of handwriting in children.” American Journal of Occupational Therapy.
- Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, Japan. Elementary school curriculum guidelines (2017).
Getting used to a new grip with StudyX Smartpaper Letters
StudyX Smartpaper Letters is an iPhone and iPad app for practising characters by tracing. You can write with a finger or an Apple Pencil.
Tracing can be used to practice a new grip. You don’t have to think about the shape of the character, so you can pay attention to your hand and how hard you are pressing. Type any characters into the search bar, and the model’s strokes animate one at a time in stroke order for you to trace. For the Latin alphabet, the Cursive Alphabet setting switches the models to cursive. With a new grip you will be writing slowly, so turning on Slow Animation in Settings helps.
When you finish a character, a score appears. It is a guide to how closely your lines overlap the model. Just after changing your grip, the lines may not overlap as well as you’d like, and the score can also show your hand settling into the new shape. In the interview I said this about the score:
The tracing score is not outside judgement. It is a measure for checking your own accuracy.
If you would rather not see it, turn off Display Score in Settings. The screen cannot see how you hold the pen, so check your hand in a mirror or on video from time to time.
It is a one-time purchase with no ads and no in-app purchases, and what you write is not sent anywhere. For a first session, see Getting Started with StudyX Smartpaper Letters.
StudyX Smartpaper LettersDigital montessori sandpaper lettersSee the app →