← StudyX Devlog

Ten Study Myths Debunked: Research That Rechecked Learning Styles, Handwritten Notes and Rereading

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperBrain MondoBrainDojo

Brain Mondo · 25 of 28

Ten Study Myths Debunked: Research That Rechecked Learning Styles, Handwritten Notes and Rereading

While watching a recorded lecture, 74 people took notes on a laptop and 68 took notes by hand. After a brief distraction, and with no chance to study, they took a quiz. The laptop notes contained more of the lecturer’s words verbatim and more words overall. Even so, quiz scores were no better than those of the longhand group. This was a 2021 replication by Urry and colleagues of a well-known 2014 study, published in Psychological Science.

Brain Mondo has published a video that picks ten studies like this one, studies that rechecked common beliefs about studying, and puts them in order: study methods, study environment, and keeping it up. Each belief has one paper as its source. Most of these results do not prove a belief wrong. They are replications that did not reproduce the original finding, or reviews that found no evidence for it. In this post I go through the ten papers from the video, together with the conditions of each study and some cautions for reading them.

Video: Study beliefs science overturned, which I wish I had known before exams: ten picks (Japanese)

There is also a short video with just three of them: Three study methods with weak evidence (Japanese)

The video is in Japanese.

Study methods

1. Match your learning style

Some people are said to learn best by seeing, others by listening, and so on. The idea that each person has a mode of instruction or study that works best is called “learning styles,” and it is used widely in education, from kindergarten to graduate school. In 2008, Pashler and colleagues reviewed the evidence behind it (Psychological Science in the Public Interest).

The authors say a specific kind of experiment is needed to test it. Students are first divided into groups by learning style, then each group is randomly assigned to different methods of instruction, and finally everyone takes the same test. The results then have to show that the method that works best for one style is not the one that works best for another.

The review found plenty of evidence that children and adults, if asked, will state how they prefer information to be presented. But it found virtually no evidence that matching instruction to style improves learning. Very few studies used a method capable of testing this, and several of those that did found results that flatly contradict the matching idea. The authors write that limited education resources would be better spent on practices with a strong evidence base.

2. Handwritten notes help you remember more

This is the replication by Urry and colleagues from the opening. It repeats Study 1 of the 2014 paper by Mueller and Oppenheimer.

As in the original, laptop notes contained more verbatim words and more words overall. But laptop participants did not do better than longhand participants on the quiz. Exploratory meta-analyses of eight similar studies showed the same pattern. In both the original and the replication, a higher word count went with better quiz scores. The original also found that more verbatim overlap went with worse scores, but that finding was not robust in the replication.

3. Hard-to-read fonts make things stick

Making information harder to learn can sometimes help learners. Psychologists call this “desirable difficulty.” From this came the idea that reading in a hard-to-read font would help memory, and a font called Sans Forgetica was created with that claim.

In 2020, Taylor and colleagues tested the font in four experiments (Memory). Participants read information in Sans Forgetica or in Arial. They rated Sans Forgetica as harder to read. Memory performance, however, was the same as with Arial, and sometimes worse. The authors conclude that the font creates a feeling of difficulty but does not help memory.

4. Highlight, then reread again and again

In 2013, Dunlosky and colleagues reviewed research on ten study techniques that students often use (Psychological Science in the Public Interest). They rated each one by whether its benefits held across learners of different ages and abilities, different materials, and different kinds of tests.

Two techniques received high ratings: practice testing and distributed practice, which spreads study over separate days. Highlighting and rereading were among the five rated low, along with summarization and others. Most students use them, yet they did not consistently raise performance. The authors give the example of using practice testing instead of rereading. The same review also comes up in the post on ten minutes a day for exam prep.

5. The more you reread, the more you remember

This is a 2006 experiment by Roediger and Karpicke (Psychological Science). Students read prose passages, then either restudied them repeatedly or closed the text and wrote down what they could recall. The final test came 5 minutes, 2 days, or 1 week later.

On the 5 minute test, the restudy group did better. On the tests 2 days and 1 week later, the group that had recalled did clearly better. Yet the restudy group was more confident that they would remember. The procedure is covered in detail in the post on the testing effect.

6. Getting it wrong costs you

These are six experiments by Kornell and colleagues from 2009 (Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition). They asked whether a failed attempt to answer a test question gets in the way of later learning.

Experiments 1 and 2 used questions about events that never happened, such as “What peace treaty ended the Calumet War?” There is no way to know the answer, so the first answer is always wrong. Experiments 3 to 6 showed a cue word such as “whale” and asked people to guess a weakly related word such as “mammal.” The rare correct guesses were left out of the analysis.

One group tried to answer before seeing the answer. The other group read the question and answer together. The group that tried first remembered more later, with both kinds of material. The authors suggest that taking challenging tests, instead of avoiding errors, may be one key to effective learning.

Study environment

7. A phone on the desk dulls your mind

This idea became well known through a 2017 study by Ward and colleagues. In 2022, Ruiz Pardo and Minda repeated its second experiment with the same method, after pre-registering their plan (Acta Psychologica).

The phone was placed on the desk, in a pocket or bag, or outside the room, and was either on or off, for six conditions in all. Participants did a task that requires holding things in mind while paying attention, and a task that requires holding back a response. Neither task showed a difference between phone locations. The authors conclude that the mere presence of one’s phone may not be enough to affect cognitive performance. Other research on a phone that is simply nearby is in the post on phone notifications and focus.

8. Frequent short breaks raise performance

This is a meta-analysis of studies on short breaks taken between work tasks (Albulescu and colleagues, 2022, PLOS ONE). It gathered 22 study samples from 19 records, with 2335 people in total.

Short breaks boosted vigor (effect size d=0.36) and reduced fatigue (0.35). Both effects were statistically significant but small. The effect on overall performance (0.16) was not significant. When split by type of task, performance improved only on tasks with lower cognitive demands. Longer breaks also went with a larger boost in performance. The authors write that recovering from highly draining tasks may need breaks of more than 10 minutes.

Keeping it up

9. A set number of days makes a habit

In 2023, Buyalskaya and colleagues used machine learning to trace how habits form (PNAS). They used more than 12 million records of gym attendance and more than 40 million records of hospital handwashing.

Contrary to the popular belief in a “magic number” of days, the gym habit typically took months to form, while the handwashing habit in the hospital took weeks. The time needed depended on the behavior. They also found that gymgoers whose behavior was more predictable responded less to an intervention designed to increase gym attendance. Research on habits is also covered in the post on ten habit tips for studying.

10. Telling people your goal helps you reach it

These are four experiments by Gollwitzer and colleagues from 2009 (Psychological Science). They looked at plans tied to the person someone wants to become, such as reading law journals regularly in order to become a lawyer.

People whose plans were noticed by others acted on them less than people whose plans were ignored. This held both in the field, over one week of effort, and in the lab, in how quickly people took chances to act. In Study 3, the effect appeared among people strongly committed to the goal, but not among those weakly committed. Study 4 showed that when others take notice of such a plan, it gives the person a premature sense of already being who they want to be.

Cautions for reading

Most of these ten studies do not show that a method fails. They found no evidence that it works, or failed to reproduce an earlier result. Pashler and colleagues, in the first study, also write that because so few studies used a proper method, it would be an error to conclude that every version of learning styles has been tested and found wanting. Many have simply not been tested.

The studies also differ in what they looked at. The second measured a quiz right after a lecture. The seventh is a replication of a single experiment, and its result differs from the original. The eighth looked at short breaks between work tasks and is not limited to studying. The ninth used records of gym attendance and hospital handwashing, not study habits.

Each result holds under the conditions of its own study.

Using it in daily life

Following the conditions the studies tested, it looks like this.

  • Take notes with whichever tool is easier, and write plenty. In the second study, laptop and longhand scores did not differ, and a higher word count went with better quiz scores.
  • After reading, close the book and write down what you recall. In the fifth experiment, the recall group did better on the tests 2 days and 1 week later.
  • Before looking at the answer, try to answer it yourself. In the sixth set of experiments, even when the first answer was wrong, the group that tried first remembered more later.
  • For plans tied to who you want to become, act before telling people. In the tenth study, people whose plans were noticed by others acted on them less.

Brain Mondo introduces research-based stories about the brain, in top-ten videos and short videos. BrainDojo is an app for training calculation, memory, attention and more in a few minutes a day.

References

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

BrainDojoBuild healthy brain habits