Piano Hand Position and Posture: What to Tell Young Children

An article on Yamahaâs site for music educators, âFix It: Tips for Teaching Basic Piano Techniqueâ (November 29, 2021, by piano pedagogue Dr. Diana Dumlavwalla), compares bench height to Goldilocks: it canât be too high or too low. As a guide, it says the arms should be about parallel to the ground, with the elbow at an angle of about 100 degrees.
In this article I gather what parents can tell a young child at home about hand shape and posture at the piano. My main sources are that Yamaha article and âHow to Develop Good Piano Hand Postureâ by Joseph Hoffman of Hoffman Academy, an online piano program for children. At the end I also write about how an on-screen keyboard on an iPad or iPhone differs from real keys.
One thing first
If your child takes lessons, follow the teacherâs words for hand shape and sitting. As I wrote in What to Do at Home Before Piano Lessons Start, teachers start in different ways. When a child hears one explanation at home and a different one in the lesson, it is confusing.
What I write here are only the basics that most teachers describe in roughly the same way. You donât need to say all of it at once.
Hand shape: as if holding a ball
The Yamaha article suggests having students hold a small ball, or imagine holding a bubble or an egg, to keep the bridge of the hand round. It notes that students often play with overly flat fingers and collapsed joints.
Hoffman suggests using the knees. Put both hands on your knees and let the fingers rest around the kneecaps. That shape is the shape on the keys. When playing, touch the keys with the pads of the fingertips.
Things you could say to a child:
- âThereâs a little ball inside your hand.â
- âKeep the knee hand and put it on the keys.â
- âNot pointy, not flat.â
âHold an eggâ is an easy image, but some children hear âdonât drop the eggâ and squeeze. Adding that a ball or a bubble is something you hold lightly may help avoid tension. Hoffman also writes that hands should be slightly curved and rest lightly on the keys, and that you should avoid playing with flat or stiff fingers.
Wrists: not too high, not too low
The Yamaha article says the wrist should always come back to a neutral position, which is generally parallel to the ground. Hoffman writes that wrists should be level at rest. They rise and fall naturally while playing, but should start and end level and relaxed.
A common sight with children is the wrist dropping below the keys, with the fingertips scratching at them. This is often because the seat is too low, so before correcting the wrist, check the bench height below.
Bench height and distance
Putting the Yamaha article and Hoffmanâs advice together, the guide looks like this:
- Height. With fingers on the keys, the arm from elbow to knuckles is about parallel to the floor. The elbow angle is about 100 degrees.
- Where to sit. On the front half of the bench.
- Distance. Far enough that the elbows are slightly in front of the body. Hoffman writes that if the elbows touch the torso, you are sitting too close.
- Left and right. Sit with the middle of the body near the middle of the keyboard. One way to remember it, with middle C in front of the belly button, is in How to Find C on the Piano.
The Yamaha article also notes that young children who are still growing need to sit higher and closer to the instrument than adults. Use the benchâs height adjustment if it has one, and if that isnât enough, add books or firm foam on the seat. Hoffman recommends a piano bench rather than a chair, since a chair will almost certainly put you too low.
Feet, back and shoulders
The Yamaha article says that if a studentâs legs are long enough, the feet should rest comfortably and flat on the ground. A young childâs feet usually donât reach. Then a footstool gives the feet somewhere to rest. With feet dangling, children tend to tense their arms and shoulders to hold themselves up. I also wrote about footstools in Digital Piano or Keyboard.
For the back, the Yamaha article mentions the image of a puppet held up by a string from the top of the head. In other words, sit up tall.
Hoffman writes that many children try so hard when they start that their shoulders creep up. He also says that students, especially young children, need lots of reminders about posture.
Donât push small hands
Notes out of reach can wait. When small hands stretch wide to press keys far apart at the same time, the wrist and fingers tense up. For a note out of reach, move the hand, or leave the note out.
Fix one thing at a time. Hand shape, wrist, elbows, shoulders, feet. Told all of it at once, a child canât tell what to pay attention to. Today only âthe ballâ, tomorrow only âthe feetâ, is plenty.
Play briefly, then rest. A young child canât concentrate on playing for long. If they say their hand is tired or hurts, stop and rest.
Donât keep stopping the music. If you stop every time to fix the shape, playing itself stops being fun. One option is to mention one thing after the piece ends. I wrote about practice refusals in When Your Child Refuses to Practice Piano.
Screen keys and real keys
The on-screen keyboard on an iPad or iPhone is quite different from a real one.
The keys donât go down. A screen is flat glass. There is no key depth to press into and no weight pushing back. Controlling finger pressure, and the feeling of pressing to the bottom of the key, canât be practiced on a screen.
Force doesnât change the sound. On Kinder Pianoâs screen keyboard, a hard tap and a soft tap make the same volume. Playing loud and soft, as on a real piano, canât be practiced on the screen.
The keys are narrow. The practice screen lays out three octaves across, so even on an iPad each key is narrower than a real one. On an iPhone they are narrower still, and the natural shape of five fingers on five keys is harder to make.
The height changes. An iPad lying flat on a table puts the screen low, and children tend to lean forward. Played on the floor, the back rounds even more.
Even so, some things carry over from the screen: the layout of the keys and where middle C is, how notes on the staff match the keys, finger numbers, and rhythm. Curving the fingers and touching with the fingertips can be done on a screen too.
When a child plays on a screen, these are things to watch:
- Put the iPad on a table and set the childâs seat so that the forearm is about level with the screen. Itâs the same idea as a piano bench.
- Sit up tall. If the child keeps peering down at the screen, raise the seat or bring the iPad a little closer.
- Touch lightly with the fingertips. Tapping harder doesnât make the sound louder, so thereâs no reason to press hard.
- On a small iPhone screen, donât worry much about hand shape. In Free play, switching the keyboard to Easy shows fewer keys, so each one is bigger.
If you want your child to practice with the weight of real keys, Kinder Piano also connects to Bluetooth and USB MIDI keyboards. How to connect is in How to Connect a MIDI Keyboard to an iPad or iPhone. When the keyboard sits on a table, the same idea of seat height and elbow angle applies.
About Kinder Piano
Kinder Piano is a piano app for iPhone and iPad for children from about age 3 to the early years of elementary school. I made it for my four-year-old daughter.
Following a score in treble and bass clef, it highlights the next note, shows the finger number, and lights up the key to press. Besides the on-screen keyboard, you can connect a Bluetooth or USB MIDI keyboard. All 21 nursery songs are free, as are the first classical piece and the first ear training level, free play and MIDI connection. A single one-time purchase opens the rest of the classical pieces and every ear training level. There are no ads and no subscription.
Finger numbers are covered in Piano Finger Numbers, and the path to the first song in Getting Started with Kinder Piano.
Kinder PianoA first piano for little handsSee the app â