← StudyX Devlog

Do You Remember More When You Write by Hand? Studies Comparing Handwriting and Typing

Hiroki ObaraHiroki Obara · DeveloperStudyX Smartpaper LettersHow-To
Do You Remember More When You Write by Hand? Studies Comparing Handwriting and Typing

Thirty-six women aged 19 to 54 wrote down words that were read out to them. They did it three ways: with a pen on paper, on a laptop keyboard, and on a tablet’s on-screen keyboard. When they then said aloud all the words they could remember, they recalled more of the handwritten words than of the words typed on either keyboard. This is a 2015 study by Mangen and colleagues in the Journal of Writing Research.

People often say that writing by hand helps you remember. In this post I go through studies that compared handwriting and typing: a replication of a note-taking study, a word memory experiment, and two studies that recorded brain activity during writing. For each one, I give what it measured and what it found.

A replication of the note-taking study

The best-known study of handwritten versus laptop notes is the 2014 paper by Mueller and Oppenheimer. That study, and the 2021 direct replication by Urry and colleagues, are covered in Ten Study Myths Debunked.

There is an earlier replication too. In 2019 Kayla Morehead, John Dunlosky and Katherine A. Rawson published “How Much Mightier Is the Pen than the Keyboard for Note-Taking? A Replication and Extension of Mueller and Oppenheimer (2014)” in Educational Psychology Review.

According to the abstract, Mueller and Oppenheimer had concluded that taking notes by longhand is superior. Morehead and her colleagues ran a direct replication, and extended it with groups who took notes on eWriters and groups who took no notes. There were two experiments.

Some trends suggested that longhand was better, but performance did not consistently differ between any of the groups. In the second experiment, the differences between groups became even smaller after students studied their notes. A meta-analysis of direct replications found small effects favouring longhand that were not statistically significant. The authors conclude that saying which method is better for the functions of note-taking “seems premature”.

Writing down words read aloud

The Mangen study from the opening is called “Handwriting versus keyboard writing: Effect on word recall”.

All 36 participants used all three writing methods, with the order balanced across people. There was one word list for each method. Memory was tested in two ways: oral free recall, where participants said the words they remembered, and recognition, where they picked out words from the list.

The advantage for handwritten words was in free recall. In the recognition test, the writing method made no difference. The authors write that, for aspects of word recall, “there may be certain cognitive benefits to handwriting which may not be fully retained in keyboard writing.”

Brain activity while writing

Audrey van der Meer and her colleagues at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology have recorded EEG while people write by hand and type, using a net of 256 sensors on the head.

In a 2020 paper by Eva Ose Askvik and colleagues, “The Importance of Cursive Handwriting Over Typewriting for Learning in the Classroom: A High-Density EEG Study of 12-Year-Old Children and Young Adults”, twelve young adults and twelve 12-year-old children wrote words shown on a screen in three ways: in cursive by hand, by typing, and by drawing. For handwriting they used a digital pen on a touchscreen.

In the young adults, writing by hand produced synchronized activity in the theta range in parietal and central brain regions. Drawing produced similar patterns in parietal areas. Typing produced a different kind of activity, and the abstract says its relation to learning remains unclear. The children showed the same patterns, but to a lesser extent.

A 2024 paper by F. R. (Ruud) van der Weel and Audrey van der Meer, “Handwriting but not typewriting leads to widespread brain connectivity: a high-density EEG study with implications for the classroom”, looked at connectivity between brain regions in university students. Forty students in their early twenties took part, and the 36 whose EEG data were clean enough were analysed.

The students were shown 15 words. For each one they either wrote it in cursive with a digital pen on a touchscreen, or typed it with their right index finger on a keyboard. Each word appeared once in each condition, and EEG was recorded for the first 5 seconds of each trial.

Connectivity patterns were far more elaborate when writing by hand than when typing, with widespread theta and alpha coherence between parietal and central regions. The abstract notes that, according to existing literature, connectivity in these areas and at these frequencies is crucial for memory formation and for encoding new information, and is therefore beneficial for learning.

What this study measured was brain activity during writing. The authors urge that children be exposed to handwriting at school from an early age. They also write that it is important to keep up with technology, and that teachers and students should be aware of which practice has the best learning effect in which context, for example when taking lecture notes or writing an essay.

Studies of young children learning letters

Some studies compared handwriting and typing in children who are just learning letters. Longcamp and colleagues’ 2005 study of children aged 3 to 5, and James and Engelhardt’s 2012 brain imaging study of children aged 4 to 5, are covered in Trace, Copy, Write, Test: How the Four Steps Work in BrainDojo Kids. A study comparing tracing with copying is in What Tracing Practice Does, and When to Move On From It.

What each study measured

The studies here measured different things.

  • Morehead and colleagues. Test performance after taking lecture notes. There was no consistent difference between groups.
  • Mangen and colleagues. Memory for words written down as they were read out. Handwritten words were recalled better in free recall, with no difference in recognition.
  • The two van der Meer lab studies. EEG during writing. The patterns of brain activity and connectivity differed between writing by hand and typing.

Comparing handwriting with typing gave different results for taking lecture notes and for writing down single words.

Practising characters in StudyX Smartpaper Letters

StudyX Smartpaper Letters is an iPhone and iPad app I make for practising characters by tracing. You can write with a finger or an Apple Pencil. It has more than 10,000 characters, including hiragana, katakana, kanji, and the alphabet in print and cursive.

Type what you want to practise into the search bar and you practise it one character at a time. With Cursive Alphabet turned on in Settings, letters of the alphabet are shown in cursive. The model shows each stroke in stroke order, and words you write often can be saved to the Word List.

It is a one-time purchase with no ads and no in-app purchases, and what you write is not sent anywhere.

Download on the App Store

StudyX Smartpaper LettersDigital montessori sandpaper letters