Tadpole People: Why Young Children Draw Arms and Legs from the Head

In 1975 the British psychologist Norman Freeman published a short paper in Nature titled āDo children draw men with arms coming out of the head?ā Freeman gave children sheets on which a head and a body had already been drawn, and asked them to add the arms. When he changed the sizes of the head and the body, the children tended to attach the arms to whichever was larger.
A childās first drawing of a person is often a big circle with two legs coming straight out of it. The arms come out of the circle too, and there is no body. In English this is called a tadpole figure or tadpole person. In Japanese it is tÅsokujin, literally āhead-foot person.ā Freemanās experiment was an attempt to find out why this odd picture appears.
I covered the overall course of drawing development in Stages of Drawing in Young Children. This post looks more closely at the tadpole figure alone.
When tadpole figures appear
A 2015 paper by Gernhardt, Rübeling and Keller of Osnabrück University in Germany, citing a 1993 book by the British researcher Maureen Cox, says tadpole figures appear at around age 3. They come after scribbled loops close into circles and children can draw a circle with lines attached. It is the first person drawing an adult can recognize as one.
The timing varies, of course. Some children draw them before turning 3, others after 4. Some never draw a tadpole at all and start with a different kind of figure.
Why is there no body? Two views
Researchers have long split into two camps on why tadpole figures happen. The 2015 paper summarizes it like this.
One view is that the childās mental picture of a person is still incomplete. On this account, children think of the body as a head plus limbs and are not yet aware of the trunk. The paper names Piaget and Inhelder among others.
The other view is that children do have a picture of a person in mind, but have trouble getting it onto paper. Freeman took this side. In his 1975 paper he wrote that the tadpole figure is associated with production problems in programming the spatial layout rather than with any peculiar conceptual scheme.
In support of the second view, the paper cites work by Claire Golomb and by Cox showing that children know more about body parts than their drawings suggest. On this view, they are not unaware of the body. The way of putting it on paper simply has not caught up yet.
Is the big circle a head?
We adults see the big circle of a tadpole as a head. For the child, though, it may not stand for the head alone.
The abstract of Freemanās paper lists two hypotheses about tadpole figures: that the trunk is missing, and that the trunk is merged with the head. Freeman then says his results favor neither, and point instead to an error in production. The finding that arms went on the larger shape suggests that children were not drawing from the knowledge that arms belong to the body, but were being pulled by the sizes of the shapes on the page.
So you do not need to see a tadpole as a child forgetting the body. The big circle may be the head and the whole body at once.
Children in every culture draw them
The 2015 study asked 183 children aged 3 to 6 in seven cultural groups to draw themselves, and compared the tadpole figures among the drawings. In every group, the larger the head was drawn, the more likely the arms were attached to it. The size of the drawings and the detail in the faces, on the other hand, differed between urban and rural ways of life.
In other words, the vertical structure of the tadpole, a head with legs going down from it, was shared across very different upbringings.
Moving toward a figure with a body
Tadpole figures do not vanish overnight. Their shape changes little by little.
A common change is that a second circle or square appears below the first, and that becomes the body. Arms that came out of the sides of the circle may move to the sides of the lower shape.
Over time, necks, fingers and clothes appear, and the person settles into the childās own fixed way of drawing one. This is the stage often called the schematic stage, around the start of primary school.
Should adults correct the drawing?
When you see a tadpole, you may want to ask āWhereās the tummy?ā or draw a body in for them. One view is that you do not need to correct it.
The US art education organization The Art of Education, in its stages of drawing reference guide, recommends not correcting or judging childrenās drawings at this age, and not trying to get them to copy particular shapes or objects. The Tasmanian Department of Educationās booklet āMaking Marksā also notes that when adults give children templates to copy, children start building pictures from those templates, and the templates can stay with them for a long time.
A tadpole figure is not a wrong drawing. It is the easiest way for the child, right now, to draw a person. Instead of correcting it, here are some things you can do.
- Ask them to tell you about it. āWhat is this person doing?ā often brings out the story happening in the picture.
- Play with the body. Touch your tummies, stretch your arms wide, stand back to back. Games that draw attention to parts of the body, separate from drawing, may show up in a picture one day.
- Keep the drawings side by side. The change from tadpole to figure with a body happens gradually. If you keep drawings with dates, you can see it clearly later. I wrote about ways to keep them in How to Keep and Organize Your Childās Artwork.
More on what to say is in How to Praise a Childās Drawing.
Drawing with Kinder Paint
Kinder Paint, which I make, is a drawing app for iPhone and iPad for children aged 2 to 6. Paper and crayons are plenty, but since children sometimes draw on a tablet too, here are the points that relate to the tadpole stage.
The most basic canvas, the Drawing canvas, is a square canvas for free drawing. There are six pens, including crayon, pencil and watercolor, plus an eraser, and the line does not go wrong if another finger touches the screen mid-stroke. There is also a shape tool that draws circles.
Drawings can be saved to Photos. As above, keeping them with dates lets you follow how the person drawings change. The basic drawing features are free, and the free plan saves up to three canvases. There are no ads and no account.
The Paint Academy tracing lessons come with the paid Kinder Paint Pro (with a free trial). Tracing shapes is a different activity from free drawing. It can be used as time separate from free drawing, rather than to ācorrectā a tadpole.
For a first session, see Getting Started with Kinder Paint.
Kinder PaintCreative drawing for kidsSee the app ā